Chapter One
There are two types of people in this world: those who want to forget and those who want to remember.
I want to remember. More than anything.
I want to remember every laugh, every cry, every kiss, every song: the ones that made me weep and even the ones so unbearable, they made me want to claw out my eardrums.
I’d take having one memory of my adult life because for some reason, I don’t have many. All I know is that my name is Jamie Kessler, I’m forty-five, and I have no idea why the fuck I’m in California.
My older sister, Paige, sits next to me as we sit in an exam room at the Farrow Neurological Institute of Malibu. I stare at my phone’s black screen and study the fresh pink scar running diagonally from the left part of my hairline down two inches on my forehead, a reminder of why I’m at this building in the first place. Looking at it causes a swarm of emotions to build inside me. I force myself to stop staring at it and look out the window at the palm trees, a vastly different vertical structure than the skyscrapers I’m used to in New York City. Somehow, I remember my childhood, but around college, things disappear, with the exception of tiny details, like the fact that I call New York City home.
How I ended up in Southern California is the reason why I’m sitting in this exam room with Paige and what I can only assume to be one of the worst headaches of my life. My mind is empty space, except for the very few memories from being a kid and a teen. The more I try to conjure up a memory, the more my head hurts, and the more the confusion curdles into anger in my veins. Sure, my life only consists of sporadic memories, but I’m pretty certain that this kind of physical pain is high on the list. It feels like an iron crown clamping around my temples. Any little movement and another searing pang strikes through me. Hot. Sharp. Splitting. The fluorescent lights don’t help. They’re abysmal. You’d think all the new age hippies of Southern California would have banned these lights a long time ago.
I press my fingers into my temples and close my eyes. The malady and the confusion mix into a toxic cocktail that causes my eyes to sting, and if I wasn’t in public, I’d allow myself to cry, though that would probably also make my headache worse.
Morphine. What I really need is a morphine drip.
“You doing okay?” Paige says and rubs my back.
I shake my head. “My head hurts, and I have no idea what the fuck I’m doing here.”
“I promise, this is going to help.”
“Do they have morphine here?”
Paige laughs. “This is a neurological facility, so I’m guessing no.”
“So by help, you mean this will explain why I’m in California? It won’t help with the headaches?”
“I might have some ibuprofen in my purse,” she says and pulls out her purse to sift through it.
I lower my hands and look at her. “Why can’t you just tell me?”
“Because I’ve been advised not to.”
“By who?”
“By the doctors.”
“Which doctors?”
“The doctors here,” Paige says, her voice calm and steady. “They’re going to help you recover your memories.”
“Great, but can you tell me why the fuck I’m in California? You have to know why I’m here.”
“I do, but I can’t tell you, James. It will ruin the process.”
“What process?”
There’s a knock on the exam room door. Two female doctors walk in. They appear to be the same age, though the doctor with Dr. Singh stitched into her coat might be a little older. Brown skin, long dark hair pulled into a ponytail that rests over one shoulder, and black-rimmed glasses that let me know she’s probably stylish outside the office. The woman with Dr. Wilson embroidered on her coat steals my gaze. Fair skin and dirty blond hair that falls to her shoulders in loose, styled curls, her darker roots blending seamlessly with her eyebrows.
In five seconds, I know that Dr. Singh is the personable one. She gives me a friendly smile that eases my nerves and anxiety. Dr. Wilson doesn’t look at me. She takes her seat, pulls the pen out of her front pocket, and reads the paper on her clipboard.
“Good morning,” Dr. Singh says, sounding like she’s enjoyed at least one cup of coffee. “You must be Jamie?”
At the mention of my name, Dr. Wilson finally looks up and meets my gaze. Suddenly, I forget all about the fluorescent lighting blinding me because her dark blue eyes soften the sterile glow. Wow, they’re a deep, captivating blue. She offers me a forced smile, one that seems a bit shy…maybe she can tell that I’m absolutely checking her out.
“This is Jamie,” Paige says and nudges me in the elbow, pulling me out of my Dr. Wilson trance.
I blink back to the conversation. “Hi, yes. Nice to meet you.”
“How are you doing today?” Dr. Singh says.
Better now that one of my doctors is an absolute babe.
“I’m doing okay.” I want to say that I’m fantastic. My brain might be empty for the most part, and my head feels like it’s slowly being sliced open by a machete, but my eyes are finally having the time of their life.
“Before we get started, we’re going to ask you a few questions, all right?” Dr. Singh continues.
I nod.
Dr. Singh looks at her clipboard while Dr. Wilson pulls out clear round glasses from her coat pocket. She uses her bottom lip to unfold the temple tips and puts them on. The simple move makes her even more alluring.
“I understand that you have post-traumatic amnesia from a recent car accident, around three weeks ago?” Dr. Wilson says, looking at her clipboard.
Ah, right. There was a car accident that I have no recollection of. “That probably explains all my headaches,” I say. “And the mark on my forehead.”
“That would absolutely explain your headaches,” Dr. Singh says.
“We’re going to ask you some questions to gauge what you do remember,” Dr. Wilson says, interjecting. It’s clear she’s all business. Honestly, it doesn’t help tame my attraction. If anything, I find her seriousness sexy. “It’s all part of our pre-procedure consultation.”
“It’s okay if you don’t remember something,” Dr. Singh adds. “There are no right or wrong answers.”
I nod.
“Do you know your birthday?” Dr. Wilson asks, pointing the tip of her pen on the first bullet line on her clipboard.
“May 30, 1979,” I say.
Without glancing back up, she continues. “Do you know who is with you today?”
I face Paige. She has the same dark brown hair as I do, but instead of waves, her hair is straight, falling down to her shoulders. Her eyes the same dark brown as mine. Even though we’re both in our forties and I don’t remember shit, I can see her youth shining through her faint smile lines. “My sleep paralysis demon?”
Dr. Singh laughs. Dr. Wilson finally looks up at me, one corner of her mouth tugging upward. At least I can make the hot serious doctor show a tinge of a smile. Feels like the first win for me since I could literally remember.
“She hasn’t forgotten her horrible sense of humor,” Paige says flatly.
“Clearly,” Dr. Singh says with a smile.
Dr. Wilson doesn’t miss a beat going through her list of questions. “What are your parents’ names?”
Paige stares me down, and I shoot her a glare. “You think I’d forget a couple named Gary and Mary? Absolutely not. That sticks with you, even through a traumatic brain injury.”
Once again, Dr. Singh chuckles, and Dr. Wilson mechanically moves through the checklist. “Do you know what your job is?”
“I do, which is weird and confusing.”
Dr. Wilson looks up with furrowed brows. “Can you walk us through what that feels like?”
“I remember my childhood and parts of my freshman year of college, and then I blank. But I know that New York City is home, even though I was born and raised in Virginia. I know what my job is. I work in the music industry, though I struggle to remember actually working my job. I don’t understand how I know these things but can’t think of a single memory. It doesn’t make sense. And there’s this really heavy feeling in my chest. It feels like a giant boulder is sitting right here,” I say, putting my hand over my sternum. “And I don’t know why.”
“Can you describe your chest pain? Is it more emotional or physical, like tightness or pressure?”
“It’s definitely not heartburn,” I say. “It feels like…anxiety? I’m guessing it’s because of everything that’s happened. It’s pretty stressful not knowing anything about yourself.”
“That makes absolute sense,” Dr. Singh says. “Not being able to remember parts of your own life does sound incredibly unsettling.”
“It’s very unsettling.”
“Can you think back on your earliest memory—or an early memory—and try to go through your life chronologically?” Dr. Wilson says. “And tell us what your last memory is?”
I do what Dr. Wilson says. I close my eyes and think back on my childhood. My earliest memory is when we lived in Tuckahoe, a suburb of Richmond, Virginia, that brick ranch house with woods as our backyard. It was the house my parents bought after they got married in 1974. I remember my dad teaching us how to ride our bikes down Beverly Drive and trick-or-treating around the neighborhood. I recall that when I was eight, we moved to a bigger house in Ashburn, two hours north. Dad switched jobs, and Paige and I cried and ignored him for two weeks as we packed up the Beverly Drive house. When we moved to Ashburn, we upgraded from a ranch to a two-story white colonial, and Paige and I were so excited to get our own rooms. Though, watching boring M*A*S*H reruns with my parents was far more interesting than anything Ashburn had to offer since it was newly developed, a small suburban dream in the midst of the northern Virginia cornfields. I know we adopted a German shepherd mix named Scout from the shelter, and Mom would go into a tizzy when Scout jumped up on the front door to look out the window as Paige and I came home from school every afternoon, and his long claws scratched the new paint.
I know I went to Broad Run High School, our colors maroon and gold, and for whatever reason, I wore a maroon BRHS shirt when Paige and I went to see Oasis at Nissan Pavilion, where I had a secret rendezvous with her best friend, Laura Schroeder…and then again two summers later after my freshman year of college, when the three of us went to Lilith Fair.
And then I hit a wall. There’s nothing else in my memory bank except for knowing New York City is home, and I work in the music industry. I open my eyes and turn to Paige, who’s staring at me, mouth agape.
“You had a secret rendezvous with Laura?”
I blink. Apparently, I’ve never told her. “Twice that I know of,” I say with a casual shrug.
“Oh my God. How did I not know this?”
“Don’t ask me. I don’t remember shit.” I face the doctors. “It gets really fuzzy then. I don’t remember anything after Lilith Fair—”
“What happened at Lilith Fair?” Paige barks.
I go back to the vague memory. It’s like an almost finished puzzle with a few pieces missing, but I can still see the image of Laura Schroeder sitting on my bed as I emerge from my bathroom. She wasn’t supposed to be there. She was supposed to be down the hall in Paige’s room.
“Laura was in my bed. I don’t know what she was doing there. Like I said, the memory is very fuzzy.” I pause. “What’s she up to now?”
Paige blinks a few times, her mouth still open as if she forgot to close it. “She’s married…to a man…and has four kids.”
“Ah, well, that must be nice for her.”
She shakes her head. “Jesus, Jamie!”
“How old were you during this last memory?” Dr. Wilson injects. Clearly, our sisterly bickering doesn’t faze or entertain her.
“I was nineteen.”
She nods as she writes something else on her clipboard. “And what’s the latest memory you can recall?”
I swim through the haze. “Moving into my college dorm sophomore year? Willard Abbey University, outside of Richmond, Virginia.” I rub my temples. The headache starts pressing into my skull yet again. “I’m so confused. I’m tired of being confused.”
“I can only imagine,” Dr. Singh says. “That’s why we’re here to help.”
“So all of this,” I say and gesture to the room, “is supposed to help me get my memories back?”
“Correct,” Dr. Singh says.
“That’s possible?”
Dr. Singh turns. “It is, thanks to Dr. Wilson here.”
“You developed this procedure?”
Dr. Wilson nods. “With the help of an incredible team, yes.”
“This isn’t some California hippie thing like ayahuasca?”
“This is an entire neurology institute, Jamie,” Paige says sternly. “Of course not.”
“We have a very high success rate of bringing memories back,” Dr. Wilson says. She gets up, pulls a brochure from a display, and hands it to me. “There’s a lot of great information in this,” she says. “But I can explain if that will make you more comfortable.”
“Yes, please.” I don’t feel like reading an entire brochure. Plus, having a hot, serious doctor talk medical terms to me sounds entertaining, and I could use all the entertainment this offers to counteract the misery that comes from not remembering jack shit.
“I’ll try to explain in the simplest terms possible,” Dr. Wilson says, leaning forward in her chair and folding her hands on her lap. “You have retrograde amnesia, which happens when there is damage to the memory-storage areas of the brain, like the hippocampus. It’s not able to ‘fire’ in the right patterns anymore. This procedure, optogenetic auditory stimulation therapy, or what we call OAST,” she says, pronouncing the acronym as owst, “is a way to help the hippocampus fire in the right rhythm again.”
“How do you do that?” I ask, surprisingly following along. “Ayahuasca?”
Dr. Wilson lets out a single laugh. “No.”
“Good news for me.”
“You’ll wear a device that looks like a helmet. This helmet has electrodes inside and will deliver light patterns to your brain. But the special ingredient in this process is music.”
I perk up. Now she’s speaking my language. “Music?”
“Music is strongly linked to memory and emotion. This combination of light pulses and music helps synchronize the neurons in your hippocampus so they can reconnect with the lost memories. We can tailor the stimulation using pieces of information that are meaningful to you.”
“This sounds like hippie stuff.”
Paige elbows me in the arm. God, her elbow is pointy as hell. I shoot her a glare.
“When we get started, we’ll ask you to think back to the latest memory you can remember and think of a song that reminds you of that time. I’ll monitor your brain’s reactivity to the music on my computer, and Dr. Singh will control the light pulses. Do you have any questions so far?”
“Does this hurt?”
“Not during OAST,” Dr. Wilson says. “You might feel some taps on your head, and the helmet might warm up, but it’s not painful. However, after the session, you might experience headaches, and the confusion can cause more stress and anxiety.”
“More headaches?”
“It’s nothing over-the-counter pain medication can’t fix.”
“Excedrin hasn’t been doing the trick.”
“We can write you a prescription. Make sure to stay hydrated, eat a full breakfast, and get plenty of rest before and after each procedure. Any other questions?”
I shake my head once I realize I have nothing. I’m ready to get started. It’s only been three weeks since my accident, apparently. My memory is foggy, but it’s still enough time for the anxiety to swell in me.
“All right then,” Dr. Singh says, standing up. “Jamie, follow us down the hall, and we’ll get started.”
I follow Dr. Singh and Dr. Wilson down the hall into another room. Inside is a reclining chair and a long desk with multiple computer monitors. The harsh fluorescents blind me yet again and awaken the monster that resides in my head. I take a seat in the recliner. Dr. Singh adjusts my chair, grabs the helmet, and shows me the electrodes on the inside before she secures it to my head. The helmet wraps around the circumference and down the top of my head. She attaches the second piece of what looks like some medical version of stereo headphones over my head, covering my ears. Dr. Wilson takes a seat and messes around with the computer.
“Are you comfortable?” Dr. Singh says.
“So far so good,” I reply.
“It’s going to be okay,” Dr. Singh says with a reassuring grin, enough to loosen the knots of nerves coiling inside me. “I’ve done this too.”
“You have?”
“Yes. I figured if I was going to help patients remember, I should know what they go through.”
“Did you remember?”
I’ve only known Dr. Singh for about ten minutes, but wholesome oozes out of her. I don’t know anything about her except that she has eased my anxieties ever since she entered my presence. I guess having Wholesome Doctor is second best to having Hot Doctor. “I did. Some vague memories of my childhood came to life. The memories are really vivid. It was actually a lot of fun. I craved Jell-O Pudding Pops. And my Nani’s dal.”
I raise an eyebrow. “I remember those. The Pudding Pops.”
She nods. “The point I’m trying to make is that you might crave some nostalgic treats after. If you’re a nostalgic person, I think you will enjoy it.”
I purse my lips. “Sounds fun,” I say.
“Some people think so,” Dr. Singh says. “If it’s a good memory.”
“At this point, I’ll take any memory.”
I don’t really know if I’m a nostalgic person, but reliving memories of my younger years does sound like it could be fun. At least, I keep telling myself that as Dr. Singh and Dr. Wilson set up around me.
Dr. Singh shuts off the overhead fluorescent lights and turns on a dim floor lamp. Instantly, my muscles loosen, and I can feel the throbbing behind my eyes ease.
“To make you more comfortable,” Dr. Singh says and takes the empty seat next to Dr. Wilson.
Dr. Wilson swivels in her chair to face me. “Can you think back to that latest memory you have? It’s okay if it’s not precisely the last memory you recall, but it will help us pinpoint where to start. Once you have that memory, I want you to think of a song. You don’t have to put too much thought into it. Just a song that either reminds you of the memory or a song you would have listened to at the time.”
Trying to recall my last memories feels like swimming in the shallow end of the pool without goggles. I can’t tell if it’s more than two decades of past that fades the memory or if it’s because of the accident; I’m assuming it’s a combination of both. But while visualizing the memory and every single detail that still clings to it, at least there’s a song that plays loud in my head.
The last full memory that blooms is Lilith Fair, the summer after my freshman year of college. Laura Schroeder lying in my bed when she should have been in Paige’s room. How the song “Champagne Supernova” started playing in my head, tying me back to two summers prior when we could hear Oasis playing it live while fooling around in the back of her car. One song tied together two different memories.
That has to be the best starting point.
“ ‘Champagne Supernova’ by Oasis,” I say.
Dr. Wilson types away on the computer. The dreamy, gentle strumming of an acoustic guitar plays, the sound slightly hazy and watery. I close my eyes and let the song engulf me, immediately sparking the nostalgia.
And just like that, I’m immersed in the summer of 1996.
Chapter Two
The slow strumming of the acoustic guitar revived the spicy taste of Big Red gum and Bud Ice on Laura Schroeder’s tongue. It was early September 1996, the first time I smoked weed, kissed a girl, and the night I lost my virginity.
The two of us fucking in her Ford Fiesta, somewhere in the sea of cars in the Nissan Pavilion parking lot, was the product of Laura Schroeder suggesting that I shotgun the smoke from her mouth as my first taste of weed. I couldn’t say no. I was seventeen and desperate to feel another girl’s lips against mine, though I had no idea why I wanted it so much. Apparently, when you mixed marijuana with teenage hormones, it made absolute sense that what was supposed to be a simple bathroom break during the Oasis concert turned into us scampering off into the parking lot. We squeezed into the back and made out until our lips were chapped. Since we hadn’t had enough of each other, hands slipped underneath jean shorts, and I had my first taste of how magical women were while distance and the humidity muffled the lyrics of “Champagne Supernova.” I cried out during the guitar solo and opened my eyes to Laura, a salacious smirk taking over that sexy mouth of hers as the windows fogged up from our teenage passion.
I immediately bought the (What’s the Story) Morning Glory? album on cassette tape, along with a pack of Big Red, and listened to it incessantly on my Sony Walkman until it became the soundtrack of my senior year of high school.
Every time “Champagne Supernova” played through my headphones, I closed my eyes and transported myself back into that Fiesta, remembering how her ravenous lips moved against mine, how they nibbled and sucked on my bottom lip until a whimper slipped out of me, the way her eyes bored into mine every time she thrust into me. I couldn’t wait for summer, when Laura came back from her first year of college. In my delusional mind, Paige and Laura would invite me to another concert at Nissan Pavilion, and Laura and I would take another “bathroom break.” I didn’t even have feelings for Laura. I just craved a woman’s attention and mouth, and Laura was the only person at the time willing to give it to me.
However, the summer of ’97, Laura came back home and wouldn’t stop talking about her boyfriend, which absolutely shocked me. She paid no attention to me when I tried inserting myself into their conversations in Paige’s room. She sounded like one of those boy-obsessed girls, as if her boyfriend was a member of the Backstreet Boys.
I figured our clandestine moment was forever stuck in the summer of ’96. I retired the Oasis cassette tape after that. I didn’t even bring it with me when I moved into my college dorm and avoided Big Red gum at the campus dining hall shop. During that time, I was coming to terms with being a lesbian. I was the only one I knew, and I sure as hell got a whole lot gayer after that summer.
When we all returned home from college during the summer of ’98, Paige flaunted Lilith Fair tickets in my face. If anyone deserved to go to a music festival with a pack of women, it was me. The Alpha Delta Psi girls my freshman year of college had definitely helped solidify my understanding of my sexuality. There was a reason I gave the ADP girls the nickname “Ani DiFranco Sorority” in my head. Every one of those girls who blasted Ani DiFranco had made out with me at their parties throughout the year, giving me a whole new meaning to the song “32 Flavors.”
Naturally, I begged for Paige to hand over that third ticket. I wanted to see Sarah McLachlan, Natalie Merchant, Indigo Girls, Missy Elliott, and Liz Phair as much as I wanted to find a joint somewhere in the lawn and shotgun Laura. When Laura found out I was tagging along, she pouted and complained that the third ticket wasn’t going to her boyfriend, as if a straight white guy was dying to sing Sarah McLachlan with a bunch of lesbians.
Paige and Laura stole beers from our parents’ beer fridge in the garage and poured it into flasks that they hid in their boobs. We fanned our blanket out on the lawn surrounded by so many women. So much flannel.
Apparently, all Laura needed was a few sips of boob beer and some hits of a joint for her to remember how much she enjoyed my attention. By the time Sarah McLachlan came out, Laura’s hands grazed against mine too often to be considered a coincidence. When Sarah eventually sang “Building a Mystery,” everyone on the lawn swayed to the beat, lighters flicked against the night, and Laura found my sweating hand and clasped it through the rest of the song.
That was not a coincidence.
We got back home well past midnight, smelling like sweat, sunscreen, and weed. My legs and feet hurt from standing, my throat was hoarse from smoking and singing, and my teenage hormones were vibrating through me like an electrical current. I took a long, cool shower, feeling my body come down from all I had consumed.
When I emerged from my bathroom, I found Laura already in my bed, having snuck out of Paige’s room. She gave me that same dark, focused stare that I’d replayed in my head for almost two years. I put the Oasis cassette into my boombox that sat in the corner of my room and pressed play.
“Really?” Laura said as I crawled onto the bed.
“Thought you needed the reminder,” I said and lowered myself on top of her.
“I…don’t…need the reminder,” she said in between ragged breaths, causing my rampant teenage hormones to overpower me.
“I think you do,” I said as I slipped a hand underneath her new white Lilith Fair shirt. “I’ve heard way too much about your boyfriend since you’ve come home.”
I unclasped her bra and slid the straps down, pulling it away enough to see her nipples poking through the cotton.
I wasn’t sure how I had so much confidence as a nineteen-year-old who had only had sex once, with a woman who, for the first two months of summer, acted like I was as lame as Vanilla Ice.
I had no reason to have so much confidence with Laura Schroeder, but I did.
The night before Laura moved back to college three weeks after Lilith Fair, I found her in my room again. She shut the door and put in the Oasis tape in the boombox.
“Bed. Now,” she demanded.
A perfect way to end the summer.
v
“I feel rich,” Stacey Smith said as she logged onto AOL on her brand new ThinkPad laptop.
Stacey was my roommate freshman year, and we instantly clicked. She was hilarious, laid-back, with flawless dark brown skin and beautiful long box braids, and excellent taste in music. She grew up about an hour away from me in Washington, D.C. and had a scholarship to run track at Willard. Apparently, she was sort of a big deal in the 400 meter.
With an impressive cassette collection of all the best rap, hip-hop, and R&B and a skin care routine that tamed my period zits, it was a no-brainer to stay roommates at the start of our sophomore year at Willard Abbey University.
Willard Abbey had spiked their tuition by three grand that year in order to lend every student a ThinkPad laptop and joined the likes of the Ivy Leagues in offering on-campus housing high-speed internet. I felt spoiled. While my parents were stuck with their dial-up where the internet shut off anytime the landline rang, I was chilling in my three hundred square foot dorm room with the crème de la crème of web browsing.
“I’d hope we get something fancy out of that tuition increase,” Stacey continued and typed away, creating her first AOL screen name.
Then the wonderful sound of the AOL message ding went off on my computer, and a new chat from DCStacey400 popped up on my screen.
DCStacey400: What up
ItsJamie97: Yo
DCStacey400: What am I supposed to do on this thing?
ItsJamie97: Whatever you want. Read news. Go into chatrooms and talk to people. I use Ask Jeeves to help me with homework questions.
DCStacey400: Hmm okay.
She swiveled in her desk chair. “Have you really gone into chat rooms?”
“A few times.”
Every teen who had AOL explored the chatrooms, and that was exactly how I used the internet in 1998. During a time when being a lesbian was considered to be as bad as committing murder, the internet offered an anonymous glance into the secretive lives of other gay people all over the world. I’d snuck into a chatroom and observed the conversations. I was too afraid to even say hi, as if they would figure out my full name, address, and Social Security number just from my screen name.
Stacey was already curled up in bed asleep while I immersed myself in the blue light of my computer. I scrolled my mouse over to the chatroom section of the AOL home screen, and my heart quickened. Something about entering the unknown world with anonymous strangers online felt like a dangerous exploration. With a whole laptop to myself, unaffected by the phone line, I spent that first night back on campus getting lost in the world of AOL chatrooms. I imagined that this was how the first explorers felt sailing into uncharted waters, except instead of discovering new continents, I dove into a chatroom of lesbians debating which Spice Girl was the hottest.
Scary Spice, obviously.
Having fooled around with Laura Schroeder really made me ponder life’s deepest meaning, more than any of the Alpha Delta Psi girls. Drunkenly making out with sorority girls was practically a rite of passage; at least, society made it seem like that. But sleeping with your sister’s best friend—three times—meant so much more.
I was as gay as Ellen DeGeneres and Melissa Etheridge, and it was those AOL chatrooms that made me feel seen for the first time since discovering my sexuality. The chatrooms became a place for the “oddballs” to be themselves. While I lived vicariously through the “cool oddballs” while watching “My So-Called Life” and “Freaks and Geeks,” I got to actually live it online.
I opened a bottle of Strawberry Passion Fruitopia and sat back as screen names filled the chat. Someone named TasteTheRainbow asked the room who their sexual awakening was. I watched as people responded with Scary Spice, Gillian Anderson, Julie Andrews in the Sound of Music. XenaFanXO not so surprisingly said Xena. Miss Honey from Matilda. I was shocked that Claire Danes had yet to be mentioned. I typed her name and sent it off to the internet abyss. My palms instantly clammed up as I hit the enter key, and my heart hammered as I read my own words. While they were just words on a screen, a handful of people from around the world witnessed my answer. It was the closest thing I had ever done to “coming out.”
MalRooE80: Yes, to Claire Danes! Did my heart love till now? Forswear its sight. For I never saw true beauty till this night.
My heart spilled open reading MalRooE80’s response to me.
Since there were at least five different conversations flowing at once, I typed quickly to make sure my response to MalRooE80 wasn’t lost in the sea of enthusiastic lesbians responding with their crushes.
ItsJamie97: O, she doth teach the torches to burn bright!
ItsJamie97: Claire Danes is the only one who can make me appreciate Shakespeare.
MalRooE80: lol same!
TasteTheRainbow: She really does make Shakespeare more digestible.
ItsJamie97: I have no idea what any of these lines mean but if Claire Danes says gibberish, then let me be fluent.
MalRooE80: LOL ;)
I sat back as my closeted gay heart pleasantly thrummed at all the gayness my eyes were consuming. The last time I had consumed anything relating to being gay was when I was a kid, and AIDS was all the news spoke about on TV, casting a grim shadow on the community. I held that with me so tightly, it had become a poorly designed security blanket. The one moment that gave me some flicker of normalcy was when Pedro from The Real World: San Francisco boldly talked about his HIV-positive diagnosis. When he died, all that media consumption washed over me again.
But once I discovered the F4F chatroom, I wasn’t alone. Girls like me emerged in droves.
This entire time, I hadn’t been alone.
Then, a chatbox bleeped in the upper left hand corner. I sat straight up when I saw MalRooE80’s private message to me.
MalRooE80: If you’re a Claire Danes fan, please tell me you watched My So-Called Life.
MalRooE80: Oh, and hi. I hope it’s okay to message you privately. It’s hard to keep up with all these messages.
I smiled and quickly twisted the bottle cap back onto my Fruitopia bottle and pushed it to the side of my desk.
ItsJamie97: Of course I watched My So-Called Life. I may or may not have cried when they canceled it.
MalRooE80: I know, right? It was too ahead of its time.
ItsJamie97: It really was. Society can’t handle that.
MalRooE80: Apparently, enough fans complained, and they considered bringing it back for a second season, but Claire Danes said no.
ItsJamie97: It’s actually a tragedy. I still weep about it occasionally.
MalRooE80: Me too.
Our private conversation only lasted a few minutes before I forced myself to go to bed.
A couple days later, when I was nose deep in my biology elective homework, I heard that instant message bloop. The sound became as exciting as my landline phone going off in my room, a possibility of someone wanting to help distract me from something as mundane as learning about the reproductive cycle of paramecium.
MalRooE80: Hi! Did you hear that Claire Danes is hosting SNL in November?
ItsJamie97: Is she really?
MalRooE80: Really.
ItsJamie97: My eyes have been deprived of her for so long.
MalRooE80: I already have it marked on my calendar.
ItsJamie97: I’ll do the same. I would send a picture if I knew how to send one so you’ll just have to trust me.
MalRooE80: I don’t know anything about you except you love Claire Danes and My So-Called Life, but I do trust that you’ll mark it on your calendar ;)
ItsJamie97: I’m Jamie, by the way. In case my screen name didn’t make it clear.
MalRooE80: Hi Jamie. I’m Mallory.
I let out a sigh of relief. Thank God she was a woman…though I had no proof. Only her word. But I doubted that many men used winky face emoticons as much as Mallory.
ItsJamie97: Your screen name makes so much sense now.
MalRooE80: ;)
MalRooE80: Roo was a nickname my parents gave me. I loved Winnie the Pooh when I was a kid, and I’m the youngest child, so Roo stuck.
ItsJamie97: I’m the youngest too! And I loved Winnie the Pooh. I had a Tigger stuffed animal I carried around everywhere since I was 3.
MalRooE80: I had a Roo stuffed animal! He’s still on my bed.
We went back and forth for another half hour, taking turns asking each other questions. Mallory was eighteen, a freshman in college, and I told her I was a sophomore studying journalism, but not like Katie Couric. I had no interest in being on TV, and I was positive that no one had any interest in putting me on TV. I wanted to go into music journalism. I had so many music opinions, it would be a waste for me not to write about them.
MalRooE80: So you’re a big music fan?
ItsJamie97: More like a music snob.
MalRooE80: What music do you listen to?
ItsJamie97: A lot of grunge and rock.
MalRooE80: Nirvana?
ItsJamie97: Nirvana is fine, but I kind of think they’re a bit overrated.
MalRooE80: Whoa! Explain yourself. The floor is yours, music snob.
Little did Mallory know that she had opened Pandora’s box. I closed my biology textbook and pushed it aside. I had to be honest with myself: biology homework was done for the night. I had time to finish it tomorrow morning anyway.
I cracked my knuckles.
ItsJamie97: People talk about them as if they invented grunge. They didn’t, and the only reason why people act like they were the founding fathers of grunge is because Kurt Cobain killed himself so early in their career. And, yes, that was fucking sad. He was an amazing songwriter. But there are more grunge bands than JUST Nirvana.
MalRooE80: I can’t believe a self-proclaimed lover of grunge is saying this right now.
ItsJamie97: Look, Nevermind was a fantastic album. There’s no denying that. But you need to have more than one album to be considered the holy grail of grunge. True appreciators of grunge music know there are so many more bands out there than Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, and Alice In Chains.
MalRooE80: Name them!
ItsJamie97: Mudhoney, Screaming Trees, Tad. Oh, and Foo Fighters, if you’re a Nirvana fan.
MalRooE80: Honestly, I don’t listen to grunge. I’m indifferent to Nirvana and all of those bands.
ItsJamie97: What do you listen to?
MalRooE80: I feel like you might judge.
ItsJamie97: I might. Not going to lie.
A girl I found on a F4F chatroom who was indulging my love for Claire Danes and music had my undivided attention. I didn’t even need to know what she looked like. I didn’t care. I’d made a pen pal in the internet age who was like me. We hadn’t even talked in depth about women other than Claire Danes, and that was enough for me to chip away at the internalized homophobia society had implanted in me.
I grabbed another bottle of Fruitopia from the mini fridge while I waited for her next message, I pulled my blanket from my bed, and got cozy in my computer chair.
Mallory was a big Alanis Morissette fan. Jagged Little Pill was the album currently in her Walkman that she listened to on her walk to classes, and she told me she was just getting into Radiohead, one of my favorite bands. Not only did we share a love for Claire Danes and women in general, but we both revered the biggest love of my life: music. I had no idea who MalRooE80 was on the other end of the computer. She could have been a middle-aged dude with a receding hairline and Jeffrey Dahmer glasses. Whoever she was, I hadn’t ever talked to someone quite like her. We got lost in our conversation until the early hours of the morning. I glanced at the clock on my computer screen, telling me it was way past my bedtime and that I’d struggle waking up for my eight a.m. biology class in the morning.
But I knew deep down that the sleep deprivation was worth it because just like that, I found my first queer friend in the uncharted waters of the internet.
Chapter Three
I open my eyes to find myself drenched in the soft, dim lighting of the exam room. The warmth of the helmet cools. It takes a few blinks to orient myself back to the present. In a doctor’s office. In California, of all places.
Dr. Singh flashes a professional smile. “How are you doing?”
A couple more blinks later, I say, “Okay…I think.”
It feels like mental whiplash, going from vividly reliving the summer of 1996 through the fall of 1998 to opening my eyes in 2024. I still taste the Fruitopia and its sugary strawberries, but it’s faint.
“Would you like to describe more of what you’re feeling before we move on?” Dr. Wilson says.
I think for a moment. “It’s weird. I felt like I was in my college dorm in the fall of 1998, drinking Fruitopia. I can still taste it.”
Dr. Singh nods. “It’s odd, right? I experienced the same thing when I had my first session. One of my clients called it the rewind effect, and I think it’s pretty fitting. You’ll notice throughout this process that during the session, the memories become so vivid, it’s disorienting when you come out of it. Like waking up from a dream.”
“Yeah, except you’re reliving your entire life.”
“It’s the closest thing we have to going back in time. Neat, isn’t it?”
“A bit of an understatement, but, yeah, it’s pretty neat.”
“We can thank Dr. Wilson for that.”
Dr. Wilson gives another thin, modest smile to Dr. Singh.
“Are you ready to dive back in?” Dr. Wilson asks.
If OAST means I get to relive my youth, I absolutely want to dive back in. I never needed to open my eyes back to 2024, with a persistent headache and my bones feeling heavier and achier. I want to feel the rush of excitement that was logging on AOL and talking to the mysterious girl who made me feel a little less like an oddball, who seemed to understand me, and I seemed to understand her without even knowing her life story, what she looked like, or what she sounded like.
The ball of anxiety that clung to my lungs when I first walked into the exam room dissipated, and what replaced it was youthful eagerness.
“I’m ready,” I say.
“Great. Now, thinking about the last memory you had, is there a song that’s coming up for you?”
I don’t need to think too long or hard. “ ‘Fake Plastic Trees’ by Radiohead.”
“Great choice,” Dr. Singh says.
The helmet warms up, and like the first round, I close my eyes and wait for the music to fill my ears.
v
I brought out The Bends cassette tape that had been buried in a small cardboard box in my dorm closet. I had new inspiration to relisten to the album on my walk to classes. It became the album of my fall semester of my sophomore year..
With my Walkman headphones on, I read my biology notes about the life cycle of cells on my bed. The only way I kept myself from falling asleep was the sound of “Fake Plastic Trees” saving my brain from rotting from complete boredom. Right as the bridge played through my headphones, the sound of the AOL door sound went off on my computer. It pulled my attention from the best part of the song. The screen name I always hoped was online appeared. MalRooE80.
My heart raced. I’d wanted to message her but didn’t want to come off as too eager. Plus, I really needed to study for the exam I had at eight the next morning. But after every line I reviewed, I stole a glance at my computer screen, making sure she was still there.
Maybe she’s waiting for you to message.
No, you need to review this shit no matter how much it kills your soul. A biology gen ed class should NOT lower your GPA when you’re majoring in journalism.
I listened to the first voice because it involved more exciting things, like talking to the only lesbian I knew. I wasn’t going to learn anything by combing through textbook words that were blending together. I had to preserve all my brain cells for more important classes that actually impacted my journalism degree.
So I closed my biology book, pulled my laptop onto my lap, and thought about how to initiate a conversation with Mallory.
ItsJamie97: Not to sound super creepy, but I don’t even know where in the world you live.
It was valid. We had been talking for about a month, and we were too lost in conversations about Claire Danes, Kate Winslet, and the backlash of Ellen’s gay episode that we hadn’t even asked about where the other person lived.
Five minutes later, my computer chirped with an incoming message.
MalRooE80: Let’s play a game, Carmen Sandiego style.
ItsJamie97: I love games, and I used to LOVE Carmen Sandiego. Hit me.
MalRooE80: The first Father’s Day was celebrated here.
ItsJamie97: Clue 2.
MalRooE80: Only if you ask nicely.
That was flirting, right?
ItsJamie97: Clue 2, pretty please.
MalRooE80: Fun fact: this state produces the most apples out of all 50 states.
I thought. I wasn’t an expert in apples or any fruit really.
ItsJamie97: Maine? Vermont?
MalRooE80: Which one? You have to pick one.
ItsJamie97: Vermont.
MalRooE80: Incorrect.
ItsJamie97: Maine.
MalRooE80: Also incorrect.
ItsJamie97: You tricked me!
MalRooE80: I did no such thing. Last question that will give it away. It’s named after a president, but the president never stepped foot here.
ItsJamie97: Washington?
MalRooE80: Yes!
ItsJamie97: Do you live in Seattle?
MalRooE80: No. But Seattle is a dope city.
ItsJamie97: Seattle is my number 1 city to visit.
MalRooE80: Seattle? Not Paris? London? Berlin?
ItsJamie97: Nothing compares to Seattle. It’s the capital of grunge music!
MalRooE80: That’s true. I live in the eastern part of the state. Basically surrounded by a desert.
ItsJamie97: Washington has a desert? God, I don’t know anything.
MalRooE80: It does ;) I don’t live in the desert. I live in Spokane. It’s not as cool as Seattle. Now it’s your turn. I want to guess.
ItsJamie97: Okay, give me a second to think of some clues.
I took a few encouraging sips of Fruitopia while I tried thinking of interesting Virginia facts…if there were such things.
ItsJamie97: First clue: this state has mountains and beaches.
MalRooE80: Oregon?
ItsJamie97: X
MalRooE80: California?
ItsJamie97: XX
ItsJamie97: Clue 2: So many presidents were born here. It’s like the president factory of the country. 8 presidents.
MalRooE80: Pennsylvania?
ItsJamie97: XXX
ItsJamie97: If you get three wrong, does that mean you lose the game?
MalRooE80: Absolutely not. Give me clue 3.
ItsJamie97: Only if you ask nicely.
MalRooE80: Pretty please with a cherry on top?
ItsJamie97: Good enough. Clue 3. Last one. Get it wrong and you officially lose. It’s home of the first English settlement.
MalRooE80: Virginia. Jamestown, Virginia to be exact.
ItsJamie97: You paid attention in history class! Though I don’t live anywhere near Jamestown. I live about 40 min outside of DC. But my college is in Richmond.
MalRooE80: I’ve never been to DC. But I always wanted to.
ItsJamie97: Every school on the East Coast takes their 8th grade trip to DC in the spring, which isn’t that amazing when you live so close to it. I wish they would take us to Orlando instead, the most magical place on Earth.
MalRooE80: I’ve never been east of the Mississippi.
ItsJamie97: I’ve never been west of St. Louis.
MalRooE80: Maybe one day we will finally escape to the other’s side the country.
ItsJamie97: Here’s to hoping.
MalRooE80: You know what song is going to remind me of you now? “Meet Virginia” by Train. It’s always on the radio.
ItsJamie97: It’s a great song. Though you won’t ever catch me wearing high heels. Especially when I exercise.
MalRooE80: That lyric might be wrong, but based on that, I’m assuming you don’t wear dresses.
ItsJamie97: I do not. But I do like the idea of you listening to the song and thinking about me.
I checked the clock on my laptop. It was 11:11 p.m., and I knew that my test on the life cycle of cells at eight a.m. was already haunting me the next morning. As much as I didn’t want to stop talking to Mallory from Spokane, I knew my future self would really be upset if I didn’t get a good night’s rest.
ItsJamie97: Well, it’s 11:11 my time. I’ll wish on that.
MalRooE80: Does it count if you tell me your wish?
ItsJamie97: Who knows. But if you want to use your wish on me getting a good grade on my biology exam tomorrow morning, that would be greatly appreciated. Good night!
MalRooE80: I’ll see what I can do ;) Good luck!
v
At first, we chatted online briefly about once a week, usually on the weekends when we weren’t invested in studying. Whenever we found ourselves online at 11:11 my time, 8:11 her time, we messaged each other, 11:11. Soon, anytime I caught the clock at 11:11, I thought of her while making my wish, the same wish I always made. She filled my mind quite often, all the undiscovered parts of her. We had great conversations online, and I couldn’t help but wonder what we would be like in person. What did she look like? What did her voice and laugh sound like? Would we have been friends if we lived in the same town?
“You’ve been really wrapped up in AOL,” Stacey said one Friday evening in our dorm.
She’d cracked open our window so the joint smoke filtered outside instead of alerting our RAs that we were up to no good.
“I’ve been talking to someone,” I said.
“Some random dude from the internet?” She didn’t say it in a judgmental tone. More curiosity, and luckily, she was too focused on grinding the weed to let any sort of judgment rise to the surface.
I nervously scratched the back of my head. I hadn’t spoken the words into existence. I felt like I was in my own episode of a TV show, about to announce to my best friend that I was gay like Ellen. “More like a random chick from the internet.”
Stacey looked up with a curious brow raised. “A chick? Really?” I nodded. “How do you know it’s a chick and not a serial killer?”
It was a fair question, and I was glad that she asked that first rather than questioning the gender. “I don’t think dudes use a lot of emoticons.”
“You don’t know that.”
“No, I guess not. She knows a lot of gay things, though.”
She pursed her lips and nodded. “Nice.” She went back to sprinkling the weed on the rolling paper.
“Nice? That’s it? That’s your reaction?”
She shrugged. Sometimes she was so nonchalant about the most random things. “Did you want me to spray holy water on you or something?”
“No…I just thought…I mean, a lot of people aren’t cool with the whole lesbian thing.”
“And a lot of people aren’t cool with the whole Black thing, and here we both are, ticking Willard Abbey’s diversity boxes in this really homogeneous college. Also, you told me as if this was supposed to be a shocking secret.”
“You’re not shocked?”
Stacey let out a bellowing laugh. “Please. I’ve been through your cassette collection. Melissa Etheridge, Tracy Chapman, Ani DiFranco, Dar Williams, Indigo Girls. And you went to so many Alpha Delta Psi parties last year. Everyone knows so many of them are friends of Dorothy.”
“No one uses that term anymore.”
“You don’t know that. Also, my oldest cousin is a lesbian and has used that. She’s been out since the eighties. Not really the ideal time for my aunt and uncle to find her fooling around with her track teammate in her dad’s Bronco, but alas.”
“So you’re unfazed by this news?”
She placed the joint in between her lips, lit it, blew the smoke out of the opened window, and then offered it to me. “Girl, I’m from DC. It’s basically illegal to be a Republican there.”
“I don’t know. What about the world? AIDS? The Bible?”
“You think I give two shits about the Bible? No. Also, it’s who you are. You’re a lesbian. I’m Black. We can’t change that, and I’m not down for anything or anyone who chastises people for who they are. If anything, the whole AIDS epidemic made me see how much hatred there is in this world. The eighties was fucked up. I blame Reagan, but that’s a whole other conversation.”
I took a hit and coughed my right lung out the window. “Yeah, it is,” I said through my burning throat.
“I’m glad you told me and that you trust me. I think I love you even more knowing that you’re not some straight white girl from the ’burbs.”
“Thanks? I think?”
“It’s a compliment. I’ll always have your back. Go fool around with all the women you want. Just make sure they aren’t assholes because I will judge you for that.”
“I’ll try my best.”
“Great. Now give me that joint. You’re hogging it.”