Chapter One
Bitsy Hanover stiffened when the warm Georgia breeze brushed against her, bringing her back from her stupor. How long had she been at the crime scene? She glanced at her wristwatch, eyeing the numbers. Three hours and forty-seven minutes. It felt more like all day. A week. Maybe even a year that she’d stood there, watching, taking it in, wishing it wasn’t real.
She wasn’t as near to the dig site as she wanted to be. She could see only a portion of what they were doing. A marmoset of a man with Medical Examiner Staff in red letters on the front and back of his jumpsuit had warned her twice already to stay back, but she kept easing closer, as if unable to restrain herself, compelled to be as near as she could.
He straightened, then brushed his white-gloved hand across his sweaty little forehead, pointed at her, and scowled. “Ma’am, do not cross the yellow tape again, or I’ll have the police remove you from the scene.” He went on with his work.
The hell he will. Bitsy hesitated, then realized he really would do it, and being forced to leave would only cause more anxiety and add more turmoil to an already unspeakable day. She slid her foot back and reluctantly retreated the required distance, continuing to study the dig site in all its hideous commotion. Workers scurried about, dressed in white plastic suits. White booties over their shoes. White gloves. White, billowy clouds. White. White. White. Yet a dark foreboding hung all around her. She could feel it, sense it, almost touch it. It was an odd sensation in the sunlight. Shouldn’t it be warm and bright here? But how could it be?
Coroner’s staff scoured the dirt with their trowels, screens, and small picks, stopping every now and again, placing a gathered treasure into a clear plastic bag with the word EVIDENCE marked in red. EVIDENCE. Pieces of the crime scene. But it wasn’t just a crime scene. It was where her childhood friend, Hallie Lynn Peeples, had lain for thirty years, since she was ten years old. The earth had cradled her and held her all this time.
“A crime scene.” Bitsy whispered the phrase under her breath, easing into the words, trying them on to see how they fit. She was too exhausted and overwhelmed to say them with any force. “Crime scene.” This time they came out as a moan, a lamentation. Someone had put Hallie Lynn there. Murdered her, then threw her in, like she was trash. A stuttered breath brought bitter pain mixed with anger and bone-aching sadness. The disbelief lingered, draping over her, clinging to her, making it hard to breathe. “Hallie.” Her name slipped from Bitsy’s lips, mixing with tears, sliding down her cheeks. She didn’t wipe them away this time. What was the point? Besides, she had no energy left to do it. Hallie’s body wasn’t there anymore. They’d shipped her remains to the state lab.
Bitsy startled when a familiar soft voice spoke in her ear and a firm hand patted her back.
“There’s nothing you can do for her here.” Lilly Ashburn, Bitsy’s longtime assistant at the art dealership, squeezed her shoulder. “Why don’t you go home to your momma’s? I know she’ll want to see you.”
Bitsy recoiled at the thought of leaving. She folded her arms across her chest, pressing tightly, trying to hold back the pain. “I can’t.” Her cell chimed for the seventh time. Momma. She shut it off, slipped it into the pocket of her pink-flowered sundress, and focused on the workers who were shoveling near the empty grave.
Lilly rubbed Bitsy’s arm. “It’s okay to leave. And before you ask, no! No one is saying anything. I did hear a cold case investigator from up north has been assigned to the case, but I don’t know when they’ll get here. If you won’t go home, then come on back to the office. You need some water and rest. You’re going to make yourself sick.”
The thought of Hallie Lynn in that crude grave for thirty years crashed into Bitsy, slamming against the reality that if she’d remembered anything from the night Hallie Lynn had been abducted, it might have helped find her.
She took a deep breath, then let it out, as if breathing for Hallie Lynn. “She’s been dead all this time. Not just missing or taken by someone. Murdered.” The words trailed off, but their meaning permeated the air like the stench of something unbearable.
Lilly rested her head against Bitsy and wrapped her arm around her waist. “She’s not been positively identified yet. It could be someone else.”
Bitsy grazed the grass with her sandal, focusing on the mound of dirt next to the dig site. “It’s her. Grace, from the county sheriff’s department, told me she had a pendant around her neck. She loved that damned thing so much she never took it off. I asked her once why she wore it. She said her mother gave it to her.”
Lilly tightened her grip around her waist, as if to reassure her.
Bitsy appreciated the gesture, but the bitterness and pain were all she could feel, grasping her, tearing at her, encircling her like the yellow tape marking the crime scene.
Lilly positioned herself directly in front of her, blocking her view of the workers and the site. “Let’s go, darlin’. She’s at peace now.”
Bitsy rejected the thought. “Peace? Not hardly!” The words came out sharp, like they’d been ground on a whetstone. She repeated them, softer, to let Lilly know she was sure of what she was saying. “She’s not at peace, and neither am I. There’ll be no peace until we find out who did this and they’re rotting in hell.” She turned away. “Come on. You’re right. She’s not here anymore. I need to leave.”
She’d already heard three different people give their version of how Hallie Lynn’s remains had been discovered, but they were basically the same. Henley Development had hired Mr. Crenshaw, owner of the local excavation business and brother to Bitsy’s psychiatrist, to take down the unsightly cluster of juniper and shrub trees northwest of Savannah in preparation for the county’s summer project of expanding the park. He hadn’t been more than thirty minutes into the job when Harold, the lead surveyor, started waving his hands with a horrified look on his face. Mr. Crenshaw immediately shut off the excavator and jumped down from the cab to see what all the commotion was about, and it took only a half step to realize why Harold was so upset. There, among the dug-up debris, was what looked like a decomposed body part sticking out of the dirt. Both the men staggered back like they’d been sucker-punched in the gut.
Everyone knew it was Hallie Lynn Peeples. Had to be. Why? For one thing, it was a child—anyone could see that, and there was the dark, faded but still curly long hair, and the necklace.
Bitsy wasn’t sure if it was harder knowing or not knowing that Hallie Lynn was dead. All this time she’d imagined her somewhere, alive, living her life the best she could. Now she couldn’t avoid the cold, harsh reality of her death.
She’d been the last person to see her on that fateful evening in October 1995, and now Bitsy’s life would be torn open again, shredded into tiny pieces by the investigation. They wouldn’t leave her alone. They’d keep probing, hounding her to remember, like they did when Hallie Lynn was first taken. The trauma of the event had caused her to block out the critical details. At least that’s what all the professionals had said.
A tension headache crept up her neck, settling at the back of her head, then slithered into her temples. She massaged with her fingertips, telling herself she’d get past it. Tomorrow she’d wake up and not blame herself like she’d done every day for the past thirty years. Sure she would.
She’d wanted to help the police that night. Wanted to give them as much information as possible so they could find her friend, but everything blurred and faded when she attempted to recall it. Over the years it’d gotten worse. Now all she felt was nausea and panic when she tried to think about it. She wanted to remember. Didn’t anyone understand?
Chapter Two
FBI Special Agent Cecilia McConnel parked the rental car in the lot next to the river and got out, surveying her surroundings, trying to get her bearings. She tugged at the front of her sweat-soaked cream-colored silk blouse, hoping to keep it from sticking to her skin in the sweltering, humid Savannah heat. “God! How do these people survive down here?” Summer was just getting a good start. She wasn’t used to being without her suitcoat or carrying a purse, but she had to either wear her gun and holster and draw attention to it or stuff it in her handbag.
She looked left, then right, making sure no one was in earshot of her grumbling. After she crossed the trolley tracks and walked one block down the cobblestone street of the historic River Street District, she managed to find the address she was looking for. She’d started to enter the cluster of shops when a long, deep horn blasted. Startled, she turned toward the sound and saw a magnificent paddleboat, the Georgia Queen, pulling away from her dock.
McConnel made her way along the wide hallway toward the fourth door on the right. Outside, the sun had beat down so brutally her brain had felt like an over-easy fried egg. But in here there was just heat, thick and stifling. It hung in the air and refused to yield, even though the huge ceiling fans demanded it. She passed the open doors to the multiple shops. This wasn’t what she’d expected. No spit-shined buffed floors, no bustle of people scurrying on their way to find the best deals or browsing so as not to miss a single alleged Southern treasure marked down fifty percent. Sets of old china from the 1800s, Christmas ornaments, antique furniture, and on and on. No one stopped to say hello in that slow Southern drawl that rolled off their tongues like butter dripping from a fresh ear of steamed corn. The building was surprisingly empty for nine in the morning, and quiet.
The tile on the floor had intermittent cracks and looked clean enough, but it didn’t have a glossy shine, just a dull, worn haze. The hallway smelled like a mixture of newly laundered clothes and a day-old pastrami sandwich, with a hint of lingering furniture polish.
She wiped the sweat from the side of her face, aware she’d smeared what little makeup remained. She made a mental note. No more foundation in the South. Positioning herself in front of the door marked Hanover Agency, LLC in thick, black block letters, she squared her shoulders and knocked. Why she chose to bang on the thick Plexiglas window right in the center of the name, she’d never know. Maybe because the wooden frame looked splintered? Whatever the reason, she immediately regretted her choice. The A stuck to her knuckle.
“Damn.”
She quickly peeled it off her skin and tried to place it back on the door’s window.
It dropped and fluttered to the floor.
She picked it up from a crack in the tile, spat on it, and pressed it back into place. A little off the mark, but a valiant effort nonetheless. Or so she thought. She watched it fall again. “Damn it.” Before it floated past her knees on its return journey, she grabbed it. Now what? She could try again to put it back where it’d escaped from or throw it on the floor and pretend it’d been there all along. From the looks of the empty, stark hallway, no one would notice anyway. But her conscience wouldn’t let her leave it on the floor, even though she was sure she wasn’t the first to fall victim to the dilemma. She vied for another option and stuffed it into the side pocket of her purse.
She cleared her throat, still waiting for a response from her knock. Nothing. What to do? If she banged louder on the door frame or the Plexiglas, the vibration would probably knock the rest of the damned letters off the window. She had to do something. She couldn’t just stand there in the hallway. She had an appointment. She wasn’t some shopper looking for a bargain. She was here for a reason—to investigate the cold case, a very personal cold case, but they didn’t need to know how personal. That was no one else’s business but hers. It had haunted her thoughts and given her nightmares since she was eighteen years old.
She turned the thick brass handle, slowly opened the door, and leaned in, not spying anyone. “Hello? Anyone here?”
She stepped into the waiting area. Air conditioning. Cool, blessed air conditioning. She fanned the welcome chilled air to her neck.
The room was about what you’d expect for an art dealership. A comfortable-looking brown leather couch, a polished wooden coffee table in front of it, and two small tables adorned with beautiful green and gold porcelain lamps on each end of the sofa. Several original oil paintings hung on the walls, scenes of Savannah city life back in the late fifties, or maybe it was the early sixties. Those days were long gone now. Moving to the painting nearest her, she studied it more closely, recognizing the artist. Herbert Randel, whose best work had been mostly done in the mid to late 1950s. A dark, ornate oak reception desk was squarely aligned with the back wall. The room smelled like coffee and something else sweet and overpowering. Licorice. She mentally congratulated herself on the revelation.
A stout woman, not as tall as McConnel, fiftyish, her short salt-and-pepper hair tortured into tight curls, shuttled into the office from the adjoining room on the left. Frowning, she stopped dead in her tracks. “Hey. What are you doing here? I told you reporters we don’t have anything to say.”
“I’m sorry. I’m not a reporter. I did knock. I stood out there for a while, but no one answered.”
“Well, what do you want?”
It was a good thing McConnel wasn’t a customer, or she’d have turned around and left. Right after she told the woman to kiss her ass. “I’m FBI Special Agent McConnel.”
The woman stood stoic, a blank stare on her face.
“From Toledo, Ohio. The cold case?”
No response.
Was this what humans acted like when they were exposed to ungodly heat twenty-four hours a day? She took another breath, then forced it out, along with the irritation that was rapidly accumulating. It had started the moment she stepped off the plane. The unbearable temperature, the impatient drivers who had no clue how to drive in a civilized world, the incessant jabbering by everyone she encountered, the car rental staff, the hotel clerk, the people waiting to check in after her, and essentially everyone she’d met. She was here for a reason, and she just wanted to get to it. She wasn’t usually this easily irritated. It must have been the circumstances. This entire experience was overwhelming and unexpected.
She thought she’d prepared physically for the change in climate, but she obviously hadn’t. She should have worn a light summer cotton skirt, not pants. A sleeveless blouse, absolutely not silk, would have helped, and she should have consumed more water instead of the alcohol on the plane and at the hotel last night. Her mouth was so dry her lips were sticking to her teeth. She handed the woman her business card. “I spoke with a Ms. Ashburn. She told me to be here by Tuesday afternoon. And, well…here I am.”
“That’s me. Lilly Ashburn. Hiya.” Lilly reached for McConnel’s business card as she looked her over from head to toe. And then she snorted. McConnel couldn’t believe it. She honest-to-God snorted.
Lilly made a half turn and yelled out of the side of her mouth toward the open office on the far right. “Hey, Bitsy. Your agent is here.” She tossed the card onto the desk, not looking at it.
A tall, slender woman appeared.
It was her.
McConnel knew her. Well, knew of her. She recognized her from the newspaper pictures and case files. She hadn’t realized she was called Bitsy. She knew her as Mary Elizabeth Hanover, forty-one, a year older than McConnel, who tried not to stare. She readjusted her focus to the gray, mottled plush carpet, but then she couldn’t help herself and looked at her again.
Hanover stepped a couple of feet from her and stopped. Her sea-green eyes moved over McConnel like she was exploring every part of her. A faint smile crossed her full lips.
If McConnel hadn’t disliked her so much, she might have enjoyed this meeting.
The woman held out her hand toward McConnel and said hello. “I’m Mary Elizabeth Hanover. Bitsy.”
Her Southern voice was sexy and clear, melodic, like saxophone music in a dimly lit nightclub. It threw McConnel off guard. She wasn’t expecting that voice, or for her eyes to be so vivid and soft.
“I’m FBI Special Agent McConnel. If you don’t mind, please call me McConnel.” She’d croaked the words out, her mouth still so dry she felt like she’d been sucking through an empty straw. It was embarrassing. She was more nervous about meeting her than she’d expected. So far, she wasn’t the cold, heartless, uncaring bitch McConnel had imagined, but the day wasn’t over yet.
Mary Elizabeth Hanover, or Bitsy, as she’d said, was standing in front of her, after all these years of reading about her, studying the case, scouring every detail repeatedly. McConnel had never spoken to her for any length of time, only long enough for Bitsy to hang up on her five times about six years ago. McConnel had tried to arrange a meeting to talk with her about Hallie Lynn’s abduction, but Bitsy wanted no part of it. To be fair, though, McConnel hadn’t identified herself as an FBI agent back then. Bitsy had no idea who she was, and there was no reason to think she would recognize her now. They lived states apart, and their lives were not similar in any way, except for the cold case. That’s what connected them, more than Bitsy could possibly imagine.
McConnel shook her hand, trying to focus. She’d blamed her for so long for not remembering what she saw the night of Hallie Lynn’s abduction that it seemed like a paradox to be this close to her and not feel the resentment and anger that had stuck to her all these years, like dandelion puffs on a blanket. If Bitsy had remembered what she’d seen the night Hallie Lynn was taken, the authorities could have found her, saved her. Now the cold case had been blown wide open by the discovery and identification of her remains. She needed Bitsy to remember. One little detail might break the case and identify Hallie Lynn’s killer. Bitsy had remained silent about it all these years, refusing to discuss it. It was locked in her mind somewhere, and now that Hallie Lynn’s remains had been found, McConnel was determined to pry the information she needed out of her, any way she could.
“Come on back,” Bitsy said.
The smile disappeared, and a deep sadness replaced the musical lilt in her voice. McConnel wasn’t expecting to hear grief in her tone. After all, it’d been thirty years. She assumed she’d let go of the tragedy long ago and moved on with her life, unlike McConnel, who’d been consumed by it from the moment she’d found out her own relationship to Hallie Lynn Peeples.
Bitsy was beautiful. Delicate fingers and perfectly styled mid-length wheat-colored hair. The defined muscles in her arms stood out against the spaghetti straps that hung loosely over her shoulders. She was slightly taller than McConnel and put together nicely, but the sorrow in her eyes made her look like she hadn’t had a decent night’s sleep in a long, long, time.
Bitsy turned and started toward what must have been her office, then halted suddenly.
McConnel almost stumbled into her.
“Lilly, if Bo calls, tell him I said he better get that contract signed and back here by three o’clock. If he doesn’t, tell him there will be no bonus. That ought to make him move a little faster.”
Lilly nodded, then left the room.
Bitsy motioned for McConnel to follow her, walking with a graceful sway.
McConnel found herself enjoying the show. Pleasant sensations associated with Bitsy Hanover were foreign and unexpected, but as enjoyable as they were, McConnel pushed them aside. The pressure was on to find the killer, and she needed to focus all her efforts. Interviewing a critical witness was just one of many tasks. Would it help or hinder if Bitsy knew who McConnel was? Would she be able to figure it out? Should McConnel keep it hidden? What was the best thing to do? One thing was clear. If the Bureau discovered who she was, she’d be suspended, fired, or worse. Everything had a price. How much was she willing to pay to solve this cold case?
Chapter Three
Bitsy sat behind her desk and motioned McConnel to one of the cushioned chairs in front of it. She could have sat on the couch or one of the two overstuffed chairs and encouraged a more intimate and less businesslike atmosphere, but she wanted to keep as much distance from this cold case investigator as possible. Something seemed familiar about her, but she didn’t understand exactly what. She didn’t know her. She didn’t want to know her, and she certainly didn’t want to invest in what was about to happen. That way the emotional upheaval wouldn’t consume her.
This woman in front of her, although very cute, with her short, curly dark hair and beautiful curves, had no personal interest in this case. It was simply another job. Curiosity. She was after a story like the gaggle of reporters and other thrill seekers banging on Bitsy’s door, hounding her.
Her palms became moist. That sinking feeling rushed in. Her heart rate quickened. She massaged her left temple, trying to relieve the pressure headache. She hadn’t eaten dinner last night or breakfast this morning. She needed to take better care of herself. She checked the time on the wall clock.
McConnel stared at her.
She hated that. Why couldn’t people just glance, or nod, or look around the room and go about their conversations? Bitsy had dark circles under her eyes, and her skin was pale. Everywhere she’d gone this week people had gawked at her. In the grocery store. At dinner when she and Lilly went to lunch the day after they’d positively identified Hallie Lynn’s remains. At the beauty shop when she got her hair highlighted, and when the TV reporters shoved microphones in her face on her way to her car. She cringed, sick to death of the endless questions. How do you feel about the discovery? Were you surprised? And the mother lode—What do you remember about that night? Every time the question surfaced, her heart skipped a beat, she tensed, and her head felt like it would explode. She wanted to remember. Couldn’t anyone understand? She wanted to recall that night and what had happened, but she couldn’t, other than seeing Hallie Lynn near the side street. That was it. Everything else was like trying to see fish in a muddy pool of water. All these years she’d kept hoping her memory would clear, but it never had.
She’d seen something critical to the case. She wanted to recall it, but for some reason she couldn’t. Hypnotism, therapy, endless counseling. Nothing helped. She hated herself for it. The guilt and shame haunted her dreams, but the harder she pushed herself, the darker that night became. She’d shoved it all away. That was easier. Self-loathing consumed her every time thoughts of it returned. If McConnel asked her that question, she’d throw her out.
McConnel cleared her throat. “I can see you’re upset. I’ll try to make this as easy as possible.”
Bitsy took a deep breath. Finally, someone who at least was a little sensitive. “You look so familiar. Have we met before?”
McConnel glanced at the floor, then settled her gaze on Bitsy.
Bitsy studied the gold flecks in her deep brown eyes. No. Her right eye was deep brown, but the other wasn’t quite as vivid and didn’t have the gold flecks.
“Heterochromia,” McConnel said. The corners of her mouth turned up in a shy, hesitant smile.
It was charming. Bitsy relaxed a little.
“It’s pretty rare. One in ten thousand people,” McConnel said. “When you see it, it takes a minute to adjust.”
“Does it affect your eyesight?” Bitsy regretted the question. “I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have asked that.” It was none of her business. The heat of a blush pushed up her neck and settled into her cheeks.
“It’s okay. The condition doesn’t have anything to do with my vision.”
Bitsy leaned into her chair and pushed against the leather backing, wondering if they’d found Hallie Lynn’s glasses at the crime scene. “So, have we ever met?”
McConnel slowly shook her head.
The vague feeling of familiarity drifted away, like the faint scent of pine on a breeze. “It’s very difficult for me to talk about Hallie Lynn,” Bitsy said.
McConnel reached into her leather case and retrieved a file folder.
Was it Hallie Lynn’s information? Her brief life’s story reduced to a few facts.
McConnel shuffled slowly through the papers. “I’ve read everything you’ve said, the police report, interviews, everything on record. I’ve been told you were at the recent crime scene.”
Bitsy nodded. “Yes.” She gritted her teeth and prepared herself for the question.
“I’m sorry. It must have been difficult for you.”
It didn’t raise its ugly head. Relieved, Bitsy drew in a cleansing breath. “It was hard, but I think I needed to be there. Closure, maybe. I don’t know. Have you been yet?”
McConnel looked away. “Not yet.”
A strange reaction from an agent with no personal stake.
Bitsy leaned back again, clasping her hands in her lap. The gesture anchored her, gave her the stability she needed at that moment. Every law enforcement professional she’d ever talked with wanted answers and couldn’t wait to be on their way, but McConnel didn’t. Why? Maybe she wasn’t the enemy after all. Maybe she was someone who could solve the crime this time. Would she be patient and listen to what Bitsy had to say? Or would she stalk off in a frustrated huff like everyone else because Bitsy couldn’t remember and didn’t have the answers they wanted?
Bitsy shifted and placed her folded hands squarely on the desktop. “It’s not just a crime.” She paused. Expressions about Hallie Lynn didn’t come easy. She’d pushed thoughts of her away for so long she felt like she was reaching into an endless void. “It’s a violation of human existence. Murder is such an ugly, foul word. I’ve never faced the possibility of Hallie Lynn’s death. I’ve always hoped and imagined she was alive somewhere, living a different life. A piece of me was taken with her that night.” The tears welled. Bitsy couldn’t stop them. She covered her face, embarrassed as they slipped down her cheeks. She wanted to control herself but couldn’t. The stark reality of Hallie Lynn’s death forced her to face what she’d avoided for thirty years.
“Here.” McConnel whispered the word so softly Bitsy almost didn’t hear it. She handed her a tissue from the desk.
Bitsy took it with a shaking hand and dabbed at her eyes, then tossed it into the waste can under her desk. “I’m sorry. I’m usually stoic at these interviews, but since the discovery of Hallie Lynn’s remains, it’s like reality bitch-slapped me. I’m still in shock.”
McConnel adjusted in her chair. “I’m sure this has been a horrible week for you. Let’s set another time to meet. Perhaps tomorrow?” She slipped the papers into her satchel.
“Yes. Thank you.”
McConnel’s sensitivity once again skewed Bitsy’s preconceived idea of her. She wasn’t the cold, annoying interrogator Bitsy thought she’d be. She was nothing like she’d expected.
Bitsy reviewed her crammed schedule on the computer, searching for a block of time. She scanned each day carefully. Usually, with investigators or reporters, she’d stall, tell them she’d have her secretary call, and then she wouldn’t. McConnel was different. How different Bitsy didn’t know, but she hoped this time the interrogation would go better. She reviewed the next day again. “I don’t have any time until tomorrow evening. I’m sorry.” She hesitated, then dared herself to ask, the question gushing from her mouth like water from a pump. “Why don’t you come to my house? Say eight?” She wrote the address on the back of a business card and handed it to McConnel, shocked that she’d invited her to her home. Was it too late to take it back? Should she keep her at a distance? Would that make it easier?
McConnel took the card and eyed it. “That’s fine. Would you like me to bring supper? I can stop by one of the restaurants and pick up something. What do you like?”
“How thoughtful. I’ll get the meal. You bring the wine. A full-bodied red would be good.”
McConnel smiled and stood, placing the card inside her purse. She picked up her satchel. “Tomorrow night, then.”
Bitsy walked her through the lobby and stopped to open the door for her, noticing the letter A was missing from the Plexiglas. “Damn it. Not again. I’ve got to get different lettering.”
McConnel fidgeted. “See you tomorrow evening.” She quickly walked down the hall.
Had that been a slight blush that pinkened her cheeks?
Bitsy summoned Lilly as McConnel left. “Call Bowman’s and get them to paint the letters on this damn door.” She suddenly felt exhausted, drained of any emotion, and feeling like she could finally sleep. “Cancel the Renard Group meeting and reschedule it for three this afternoon. I’m going home for a while.”
Lilly moved closer. “I’m glad. You look like you could use a few hours’ rest. Eat something while you’re gone.”
Bitsy started the car just before she left the office. She slung her purse onto the front seat when she got in and inspected herself in the rearview mirror. She looked as tired as she felt. She squinted. Black mascara was smudged under her right eye. She licked her finger and wiped at it. She’d broken down right in front of McConnel, and on top of that, she’d invited her to the house. “What was I thinking?” She watched the dash cam as she backed out.
Thirty minutes later she opened the garage door of her home—a two-story, four-bedroom estate in Richmond Hill. She’d grown up in Pine Grove, north of Savannah, but this had been home for the last ten years. Maybe when all this was over, she’d go somewhere else to live. She didn’t have to be in Savannah. It might be good to move from the area, maybe even leave Georgia entirely. Make a fresh start. But her three older sisters and their families and Momma and Daddy were all here. She couldn’t bear the thought of not having them around her. Most of the time. “Oh, hell. Momma? I forgot to call her.” She laid her phone on the kitchen counter as she passed by. “Later.”
She trekked up the stairs to her bedroom and slipped on her favorite silk nightshirt, then slid between the soft, cool bed sheets and drifted off to sleep.
Chapter Four
McConnel stared at the building she’d just left. Nothing had been what she’d expected. The feelings she’d had while she was with Bitsy were confusing and unsettling. She’d blamed her for so long for not being able to find Hallie Lynn, she didn’t know what to feel now. Bitsy had disarmed her, stripped her of her ammunition, then broken the wall she’d put up to protect herself. She’d read and studied everything she could about her over the years, but they were only facts, glimpses. She didn’t know Bitsy as a person. Maybe it was time to let go of the discontent and anger. But could she? Bitsy seemed genuine in her feelings about Hallie Lynn. It was clear in her eyes and the way she acted when she talked about being at the crime scene.
McConnel unlocked the car and opened the door. The blast from the heat blew back against her with such force it almost knocked her over. “Oh, my God!” She auto-started the car, then stood beside it, waiting for the air conditioning to make getting in bearable.
The more she thought about Bitsy, the more uncertain she felt, making it difficult to know what to do. Her anger had become a blanket of comfort, but now she saw the damage it’d done. Every relationship she’d ever had was empty and hollow. She’d had several women in her life, but each relationship had ended within a year. They’d all told her the same thing: “There’s no room in your heart for anyone else.” She had lots of excuses. There wasn’t a deep enough attraction. She couldn’t commit to them because they didn’t understand her. Now she questioned all of it. Were they right? Was she so full of anger and bitterness she didn’t have any room in her heart for anything deep or meaningful? Forty wasn’t young anymore. She’d carried her feelings of ill will and discontent for over twenty years. They’d encased her like vines on a wooden fence.
She slipped into the car, relieved the air conditioning had done its job. The steering wheel was warm but manageable. She grasped it and stared at the now-empty dock. If she discarded the hatred, where would her emotional protection be, that shield guarding her from the pain and loss? If she let go of all of it, maybe she could totally focus on finding who killed Hallie Lynn. Killed her. Not kidnapped her. The thoughts burrowed into her mind. She reached under the collar of her blouse and lightly touched the pink stone teardrop pendant. She vaguely remembered getting it when she was about five or six. She’d worn out five gold chains since then. She brought it to her lips and kissed it, then returned it to its position against her chest. A crime scene photo of one identical to it was in Hallie Lynn’s file. It was around her neck when they found her remains. That’s when McConnel had decided to withhold who she was from the FBI and asked to be assigned to the case. Emotion swelled, as it always did when she thought of her. Now that Hallie Lynn’s death had been confirmed, McConnel couldn’t have any more fantasies of her being alive.
McConnel had been raised in a loving home by her adoptive parents, but her real mother, a drug addict, had given her away when she was a month old. McConnel had convinced herself, at eighteen, after the shock of finding out who her biological mother was and that she’d been robbed of a relationship with her fraternal twin sister, that if she’d been there with Hallie Lynn, maybe she could have stopped what happened to her. Maybe if they’d been walking home together, the abductor wouldn’t have taken her.
Hallie Lynn’s mother hadn’t picked her up from school that night after the play. The report said she had to work at the local restaurant and couldn’t get off. Why hadn’t she arranged for Hallie Lynn to go home with someone else? Her mother had said in her statement, “Our apartment was only six blocks from the school. She walked home all the time, and nothing ever happened to her. Why would she need someone to be with her?”
Why? Because she was ten years old, that’s why. Her mother was unfit. McConnel’s adoptive parent—her biological mother’s best friend—and her husband should have taken both the girls, not just her.
McConnel reached into her purse and pulled out the wallet-sized photo of Hallie Lynn that her adoptive mother had given her the day she told McConnel the truth. She held it tightly, gazing at it. Hallie Lynn was seven at the time of the picture. She grabbed the other worn, faded snapshot she always kept with it, one of herself at the same age, and placed them side by side. “You and I. Twins.” They had the same expressive smile and bone structure, but Hallie Lynn’s hair was not as curly, and their eye color was different.
Since the day McConnel found out who Hallie Lynn was, she hadn’t stopped trying to find her. A part of that journey was over now. She finally knew where Hallie Lynn was, but she had to uncover the rest of it. Who killed her and why? McConnel gripped the steering wheel tighter. Whoever murdered her would pay. That was an absolute.
Bitsy wasn’t the enemy after all. She obviously cared deeply about Hallie Lynn and had also mourned her loss, even longer than McConnel had. Bitsy’s life was entwined in Hallie Lynn’s disappearance and death. McConnel would untangle all the threads, even if it took her the rest of her life.
She planned to visit the crime scene next and then go on to the sheriff’s office in Effingham County, the jurisdiction where Hallie Lynn’s body was found. She returned to the hotel in downtown Savannah, changed into a cotton blouse, then made the trip to the park, just over the county line.
The car lot was almost empty. She stepped out, clipped her badge onto her belt, and walked past the benches surrounded by oak trees draped with pale-gray moss. She continued near the north side of the park on the path leading to the area with yellow crime scene tape. No one was there. All the evidence needed had been gathered in the days before. Now it was only disturbed ground, cold and empty, void of any hint that Hallie Lynn had been there all this time. She carefully walked around the site, inspecting the soil. They’d found little evidence due to the years of decomposition. Why here? Why put her in this place? The abduction had happened at the school in Springfield, about a thirty-five- or forty-minute drive from the park, which was isolated, and most likely covered more densely with brush thirty years ago. She walked to the edge of the woods and scrutinized the secluded tree line. It had to have taken time to dig the grave. Did he carry her to this spot after he killed her, or had he brought her here and then murdered her?
“Hey!” A deep male voice echoed in the stillness.
She turned.
A sheriff’s deputy in his mid-twenties angled toward her, his hand resting on the gun at his hip. “No one’s supposed to be here.”
McConnel pointed to her badge and walked toward him. “Special Agent McConnel, FBI, assigned to this case.”
The deputy eased his stance. “Why FBI? I thought you people didn’t care about cold cases.”
She ignored his statement.
The deputy moved toward her and offered his hand.
McConnel shook it.
“We’re all stunned,” the deputy said. “I’m Graham Newton, Effingham County deputy.”
McConnel nodded.
He inspected the bare ground. “I’ll be glad when this whole mess is over. Anything I can do to help?” He moved around the dig site, then came back to stand beside her.
“I think I have everything I need. I plan to talk with the sheriff as soon as I’m done here. Do you know if he’s in his office?”
“He was an hour ago. I can’t speak for him now. We’re a small department, just the sheriff and three deputies, including me, and Grace, the dispatcher.” He scuffed a small pile of dirt with his shoe. “I imagine you’ve got your work cut out for you. I heard they didn’t find anything that would solve the case.” He bent, reached for a handful of sandy soil, sifted it through his fingers, then stood. “I wish you luck in your investigation.”
“Thank you. I can use all I can get.”
He tipped his hat. “I need to get back on patrol.” He turned and left.
It was quiet, only the sound of a few birds in the trees. She surveyed the remains of the gravesite once again, then hiked back and auto-started the car before she got near it. She wouldn’t make that mistake again.
The Effingham County Sheriff’s Department, located in the city of Springfield, was in a small, dark-red brick building. A dispatcher looked up from her console and greeted her. Her name badge identified her as G. Ellington. Grace?
“Hey. May I help you?”
“Hi. I’m FBI Special Agent McConnel. I’m working the Hallie Lynn Peeples cold case.” She indicated her badge. “Is the sheriff in?”
Grace nodded. “One minute. I’ll let him know you’re here.” She walked to the back of the room and knocked on a door, then peeked in. She returned a few seconds later. “Go on back.” She pointed behind her and returned to her station.
McConnel entered the sheriff’s office.
He stood. In his fifties, about six foot one, he had an impeccably groomed head of thick, dark hair, graying at the temples and at the top. A jagged scar the size of a nickel marred his right cheek, just above the jawline. His uniform was spotless and perfectly pressed. His name was Gerald Atwater, and he’d been a deputy at the time of Hallie Lynn’s kidnapping.
“Glad to meet ya.” His Southern drawl was thick and heavy on his tongue. He shook her hand. “Have a seat.” He gestured to the two sturdy, worn wooden chairs in front of the desk as he returned to his seat.
She slid into the one on the right.
“I’m afraid we can’t help you very much.”
“Thanks for taking the time to see me, Sheriff. I understand you were one of the deputies at the time of Hallie Lynn’s disappearance.” It was hard to say her name out loud.
“Yes. That was a long time ago. I’d only been on the job about a year. It’s tragic to find her body after all this time. We all hoped she’d lived through the ordeal.”
His eye contact was intense, penetrating. What was he looking for?
“The department only handles incidents outside of the city limits, so she was in our jurisdiction, but we didn’t investigate the Peeples case. The Springfield city police chief took over because he had more expertise. Back then there was only me, another deputy, Jasper Watkins, and the sheriff at the time, Mason Tucker.”
“Were you involved in it?”
“What?”
“Did you take part in the investigation?”
The sheriff shook his head. “I was only in on the tail end of it because I was off for a couple of days and had gone to Cameron, fishing on the Savannah River with a buddy of mine.”
“Is Mason Tucker still alive?”
“No. He died of a heart attack about ten years ago, and Jasper, the other deputy at the time, moved to Athens, Georgia, in 1998. He’s a professor at the University of Georgia.” He rubbed the side of his nose. “I suppose that’s the pitfall of a cold case. Everything’s changed. The Springfield police chief, Owen Gibson, who led the investigation, is still around. He lives with his daughter and her family in Tusculum, just up the road a way.” He typed into his computer and then wrote the address and phone number on a yellow sticky note and handed it to her. “Other than being called when the body was discovered, the sheriff’s department wasn’t involved in this current part either. Mostly we kept everyone clear of the scene so the state forensic people could do their job. We don’t have the expertise to investigate. Now the state routinely brings people in for those kinds of things.”
“Have there been any other disappearances in this county over the years?” She knew the answer but wanted to see his reaction.
“No. Thank goodness. You workin’ the investigation by yourself?”
McConnel nodded. “For now.” She rose and shook his hand. “Thanks for the information.”
The sheriff stood. “Any time. Sorry I couldn’t be more helpful.”
The next stop was the Springfield police station, on the other side of town. She talked with the chief and was permitted to scour what records they had, but it was nothing more than a review of what she already knew.
Her last stop for the day was to see Owen Gibson, retired Springfield police chief. She found the address and parked on the street just past the house, a two-story, older home, surrounded by beautiful magnolia trees and live oaks with moss hanging everywhere. She couldn’t stop looking at it. There was something serene and mystical about it, like stepping back in time.
An older woman, maybe in her early sixties, came to the door, her pleasant smile lighting up her face like someone had held a candle next to her. “Are you the investigator? Sheriff Atwater said someone might be stopping over.”
“I am. FBI Special Agent McConnel.”
“You ain’t from around here, are you?”
“No, ma’am. I’m from Ohio.”
The woman laughed. “Well, I guess we’ll have to let you in anyway. Come on in.” She opened the door wider and motioned for her to enter. “I’m Peggy, his daughter. Daddy’s in the back yard.”
She led McConnel through the living room and dining room and then to the glass French doors at the back of the kitchen. She opened it and pointed. “He’s by the river, just there.”
McConnel thanked her and made her way down the steps and out to the edge of the water, where an older man with snow-white hair was sitting in an Adirondack chair with a long bamboo pole by his side, trying to bait a hook.
“Chief Gibson?”
He turned toward her, his blue eyes bright and clear. “Are you the FBI agent from up north?”
“Yes, sir. Special Agent McConnel.”
“Take a load off.”
She sat on the bench beside his chair.
He finished baiting the hook and tossed the line into the river. It splashed, disturbing the reflection of the setting sun on the water. He leaned back, stuck the pole in the holder in the chair, and then reached down beside himself and raised a large glass mug of what looked like tea. He took a gulp and set it on the arm of his chair and pointed. “See that big boulder out there on the far side of the riverbank?”
She looked where the chief was pointing. “That darker one?”
“Yeah, that one. It’s been there since before I was born. This is my parents’ home. My daughter and her family live here now. That boulder will be here long after I’m gone.” He gazed at it, then swatted at a mosquito that looked like it needed a saddle. He sighed deeply and slowly shook his head. “Damn whoever killed that child.”
McConnel kept quiet and listened.
“Some things you take to the grave with you,” he said. “I don’t want that sweet little girl’s death to be one of ’em.” He looked across the water as if searching for something. “That night there was a stillness in the air. The minute I left the school I could feel it. When I got to the Peepleses’ home, Ms. Peeples was crying and screaming about someone taking her daughter. I think she was so full of guilt and shame she couldn’t help us. I thought it might have been her boyfriend, Curtis Stillman. It’s usually not a stranger. They’d had a fight that morning, and he’d skedaddled. We finally found him drunk in a bar a couple counties over. We held him for two days, but I couldn’t get anywhere with that knucklehead. I brought him in for questioning three different times and never did get anything useful out of him. I don’t think he did it. He was killed in Atlanta about a year later, knifed outside a bar. We just didn’t have any suspects. There was no trace of her. Not until her remains were found last week.” He ran his hand through his thinning white hair. “There just weren’t any suspects.” He said it like an excuse. He stood and brought the line in from the river, then laid the pole beside his chair and sat again.
“Our best hope of finding who took her was Bitsy Hanover. Still is. Somewhere locked inside that pretty girl is the answer to who killed Hallie Lynn. You want to find the killer, get inside Bitsy Hanover’s head.” He took another drink from his mug. “She and Hallie Lynn were thick as thieves. Couldn’t separate those two with a wedge. Saturdays I’d see ’em all over town. They were sweet kids. Bitsy was never the same after that night.” His voice lowered. “She withdrew. The spark went out of her. I thought I’d find who took her or find Hallie Lynn, but never did. Now we discover she’d been here all this time.” His expression seemed to change from reminiscent to matter-of-fact. He adjusted in his chair toward McConnel. “Don’t suppose you know if there’s goin’ to be a funeral?”
“No. Not right now. Her remains are being held at the state crime lab. They can’t be released until my investigation is closed.”
“I wish you well,” the chief said, “but I don’t put much stock in you being able to find her killer.” His eyes were moist and red.
McConnel needed a few more questions answered. “Do you think it was someone local?”
“Now that we know where she was all this time, I think the choice of where she was put is interestin’. The killer didn’t just wander into it. You’d have to have known the area to find that specific spot. It’s got perfect cover. No one would see him there.”
“Him?”
The chief pursed his lips. “I believe so. Do you know how long Hallie Lynn was alive before she was killed?”
McConnel mentally reviewed the report. “The coroner estimates she was killed shortly after she was taken, but he stated it was an educated guess. Remnants of her clothing were found on her remains—a white sundress with yellow daisies. A part of one of her shoes was still on her left foot. The description matched the report when she was taken, and the shoe size was correct. She had a pink teardrop necklace around her neck.” The weight of McConnel’s identical one lay heavy against her chest.
“Do they know how it happened?” he asked.
“Broken hyoid bone, so strangulation. One other thing, the first two fingers of her left hand were broken.”
The chief cringed. “She was a feisty little thing. I imagine she put up quite a fight.”
“Chief, do you remember what Bitsy said to you when you questioned her the first time? You wrote in your report she stated it was dark and she couldn’t see any details.”
He nodded. “Her words were jumbled, and what she said didn’t make much sense, so I summarized in the paperwork. I remember it like it was yesterday. I was the first one to interview her. Her family lives not far from here. Her parents called me and wanted me to come over. Bitsy was crying and pacing. It was about one in the morning by the time I got to their house. I’ll never forget it. She was wringing her hands and shaking. She said, ‘Hallie was there and then she wasn’t. The shiny dark took her.’ ”
“Shiny dark?”
“Yep. That’s what she said, and then she had nothing else to say about it.”
“How far away was she when Hallie was taken?”
“As near as we could figure, it was around two hundred yards.”
“And she didn’t say anything else.”
“Nope. That’s all she ever said.”
They both sat without words and stared off at the river, ambling on its way.
McConnel finally rose and thanked him.
He shook her hand. “You find who did it. You’re our only hope now. I’m too old, and no one else gives a damn.”
“I’ll do all I can.”
She left. She wanted to get something to eat and put the day behind her. She was even more sure now that Bitsy was the key, but how to help her remember?