Chapter One

Ginny

Have you ever gone so long without being alone that you’ve forgotten what solitude feels like? I’m talking about forgetting on a completely subconscious, cellular level. You’ve spent so much time with others that you no longer realize all the little things you would do differently if you were alone. The awareness of the people around you has seeped into your bones. You know they see you, so your consciousness of their perception of you becomes part of how you carry yourself, and the You you are around these other people starts to feel like the only You.

I think that’s what happened to me over the last few days, though I’m only noticing it right now. Now that I’m alone again.

This week has been one of the busiest of my life. College orientation. I haven’t been alone for longer than a bathroom break or a quick shower in five days. Even now, this peace won’t last very long. My roommate Jess had her first class at eight this morning, so when I woke up at nine thirty, she was already gone. I almost wish I’d gotten up earlier to bask in the quiet paradise of solitude (but not really, because sleep).

When my eyes opened and I became aware enough to note Jess’s absence, tension slipped from my shoulders that I had no idea I was holding. I’ve been overwhelmed this week, of course, but apparently, I hold that stress even in my sleep, which is a fun—meaning stressful and surprising yet altogether par for the course—new development. My first class starts at ten thirty, so the solitude would have ended soon enough anyway.

I guess that’s my life now; tiny little moments of time to myself interspersed in a busy college student schedule. I know a more overwhelming version of my life exists, but right now my brain has lost the ability to imagine something more intimidating than my reality.

Maybe that’s how everyone feels when they’re immersed in a new community. Or maybe it’s just an experience reserved for mega-introverts like me. I’m used to a lot of time on my own. Time to recover from every anxiety-provoking social interaction, time to recharge for the next one, and time to spare. Not that I don’t have friends back home, or a passable relationship with my parents, but being alone has become my default.

But now it’s almost ten and my new roommate is bound to return any minute. It’s not that I don’t like Jess—she actually seems pretty awesome so far. She’s the kind of unflappable person I find almost confusing. I’m sure she has as many moods as everyone else, but so far, she always seems to be happily going with the flow. I was completelyintimidated by that when we first met, but she’s funny, open, and kind, and I think we’ve started to get along relatively well after this week’s crash course in bonding.

I’m clicking the strap on my overalls into place when the door bangs open. Jess comes in and flops on her bed face first. Despite her eternally cool composure, she seems to have a penchant for throwing the door open like it weighs a thousand pounds. She’s going to put a dent in the wall soon enough.

“Hey.” Her voice is muffled in her purple duvet. “Good morning.”

“Good morning.” I check myself out in the mirror. I’ve chosen a pair of overalls over a T-shirt from my favorite coffee shop back home. Overalls always make me feel prepared, and the shirt makes me feel comfortable. A perfect first day combination. “How was your class?”

She flips over to face the ceiling and shrugs. “It was okay. I’m excited about it but also, it’s just, like, so much work.”

I smile. That’s the part of college I’m really looking forward to. I’ve always been a total nerd, but I may finally be somewhere where nerd is the goal. I had a difficult time convincing my parents to let me go to a tiny liberal arts college in Vermont, but this is exactly the kind of environment I want to learn in.

We chat about the presentation she has already been assigned for her environmental science class until I tell her I have to leave. She tilts her head back to look at me, dyed-green hair falling over the edge of her bed. I would love to dye my hair, but it’s the kind of thing I don’t think I’ll ever have the courage to do.

“I like your overalls.” I think she’s smiling, but it’s hard to tell upside down. “They’re a vibe.”

“I—” I have no idea what that means. “Thanks.” I smooth them out, suddenly self-conscious. I don’t envy Jess’s style, exactly, but I envy the confidence with which she wears it, so a compliment from her feels important. She wrinkles her brow at me. I must be acting strange in some way or another.

“Are you really bad at taking compliments, or do you think I’m, like, hitting on you or something?”

I blink at her directness. “Bad at taking compliments.”

She nods. I didn’t think she was hitting on me, but surprise made me hesitate. Last I heard, she was in a committed—although apparently doomed—relationship. The day we met, Jess confided in me as I helped her put up some photos.

“I shouldn’t even be hanging these. Basically, all of them have my girlfriend in them, and we’re probably gonna break up soon.” When I’d stuttered my condolences for her future break-up, she shook her head. “No worries. We both suck at long-distance, but we’re also both optimistic idiots, so here we are.”

She’d laughed, so I did too, and we’d moved on. I don’t think she noticed how the calm confidence with which she’d said girlfriend had left me in awe. Now Jess looks at me with her brows pulled down and a slight frown on her lips, and I feel like I’ve done something wrong.

“Ginny, you’re not, like…” She forms her words slowly, which I haven’t seen her do before. Is she going to ask me if I’m queer? My heartbeat accelerates and the tips of my ears go hot. “Not cool with the gay thing, right? You just seem a little shocked by that question.”

“No!” I shake my head vehemently. “No, no, of course not.” She must see how nervous I am, but I’m surprised she’s mistaken it for that kind of discomfort. I’m uncomfortable with myself, not Jess.

“Cool.” She’s less skeptical but not entirely un-skeptical. Her phone dings and she turns her attention to it, fingers flying at lightning speed as she texts.

This is my chance. My easy, totally ordinary opportunity to say I’m bisexual. Jess won’t judge. She’s nice, calm, and one of the most go-with-the-flow people I’ve ever met. Not to mention gay herself. And if I don’t say it now, it’ll be so much harder to say it later. But I’ve never said it out loud to someone before—assuming I don’t count my own reflection in the mirror—so the words don’t come easily.

It’s almost funny how awful never having told anyone feels now, given how normal it used to seem. Just a short while ago I thought I was settled with that part of myself, and that people knowing wouldn’t change anything. I knew from the time I was thirteen I liked girls, but when I kissed a boy for the first time at fourteen, I knew I liked guys, too. So, I thought maybe I’d only ever date men. The liking-girls part of me could just stay private, and I’d never have to share that part of me with my religious and over-involved parents. But over the last six months or so, something changed. Not telling stopped feeling like privacy and started feeling like a big, bad secret.

It’s not that my home situation is even that bad. My parents wouldn’t be thrilled, but I’m pretty sure they wouldn’t do anything too drastic. They would probably learn to accept it someday. It’s always been me who couldn’t accept myself. I never felt secure enough in my sexuality to tell anyone, and I always hoped, as silly as it sounds now, I could find a way to accept myself without it ever having a real effect on my life.

When I got into college, I promised myself I wouldn’t let my sexuality feel like a secret here. I wouldn’t hide things. I wouldn’t build up the walls of shame and denial I lived with at home. I would be honest. I promised myself I’d be out. And if I’m going to follow through on that, now is the best time to start.

Determination rushes over me, combating my anxiety. I pretend to look for something in my backpack so I don’t have to make eye contact with Jess as I speak.

“Actually…” I clear my throat quietly, doing my best to sound completely nonchalant. “I’m bi.”

“Oh.”

I can’t stand it anymore and glance up to see her expression. She’s looking me over but doesn’t seem too surprised. Her expression clears and she nods.

“I see that for you.” Then she frowns. “Now I feel like I have to clarify that I really wasn’t hitting on you. I was joking.”

“I know.”

“Cool.” She smiles and turns back to her phone, and that’s it. She’s moved on already.

I told someone, and nothing changed.

I smile at my backpack as I zip it shut, then sling it over my shoulder. We exchange byes as I leave, and the tension in my shoulders feels even lighter than it did when I was alone.

 

v

 

My Gothic Literature course meets on Monday and Thursday mornings. I’m not sure why our term starts on a Thursday, but I’m happy my first ever college class is a literature course. I have absolutely no idea what I want to study here, but I’ve always had a passion for reading.

I put on my headphones while I walk. The campus is beyond tiny, so I barely enjoy two songs before I arrive in the small seminar room. I grab a random desk, take out a notebook and a pencil, and people-watch as other students slowly file in.

Two minutes before class begins, a group of three people come in together, laughing. They choose seats right across from me in the circle of desks, so it is almost natural to watch them. In particular, the girl directly across from me catches my eye. She listens to one of her friends tell a story, and I watch her brown eyes sparkle as she laughs. The easy confidence with which she carries herself is magnetic. She looks at her friends with endless focus and affection, like there isn’t a single sight in the world she’d rather bear witness to, and I’m mesmerized by the force of her attention. I’d look to see how they’ve drawn such intent focus, but then I’d have to look away from her. She pulls one leg up onto her chair, resting an arm on her knee.

I’m being a total creep. I force my gaze away.

Then I hear her laugh—loud and delighted. Screw it. I let myself look at her again.

She’s so hot. I am tentative saying those kinds of words about women aloud, but I’ve had a lot of practice thinking them.

She has high, prominent cheekbones and a strong jaw. Her dark brown hair is bleached blond except for her roots. It’s cut relatively short, like a long pixie cut, and she messes with it periodically. She shifts it from one side to the other, then lets it fall over her eyes just a bit when she looks down.

One of her friends—a Black student wearing a crop top I’d die to be able to pull off with confidence—says something and the girl bursts out laughing again. Her smile is wide, easy, and kind of goofy.

She radiates that I’m-queer-and-I’m-happy-with-myself energy I’ve always been drawn to and am more than a little jealous of. Not that I know she’s queer, but the hair and the rainbow laces on her Doc Martens are good clues, if I listen to stereotypes. I covertly study her outfit. She’s wearing a simple T-shirt and jeans with a hole in one knee. The light denim jacket draped over the back of her chair is practically covered in pins and patches. I squint to try to see what they are without being too obvious. One patch is a word in rainbow lettering, but I can’t make out what it says. Do straight people wear more than one rainbow item? I mean, they can, but multiple rainbows must suggest something.

God. I’ve been looking at her for a couple minutes and I’m already invested in her sexuality. I guess I can have a crush on her even if she isn’t queer, given I can’t imagine doing anything about it anyway. I promised myself I’d be out, not that I’d act on any possible feelings. I can only muster so much bravery.

She looks toward the door, and I follow her gaze.

The professor bustles in holding a mountain of papers. She announces herself to the room and immediately distributes copies of the syllabus. Then Professor Vargas asks us to introduce ourselves, which I’ve done about fifty times this week. One of Hot Girl’s friends volunteers to go first.

“Hi, everyone, I’m Mack Andrews, they / them pronouns. I’m a sophomore from Boston, and I study literature. And I’m super excited for this class!”

Hot Girl goes next, and I enjoy being able to watch her without being completely obvious.

“I’m Nat.” She pauses for the tiniest moment. “Natalie Becker, I should probably say.” She laughs and glances toward Professor Vargas, who writes on what must be a class roster. “She / her. I’m a sophomore…I’m from Brooklyn, and I study visual art mostly, but also a bunch of other stuff. And…” She runs a hand through her hair for the millionth time. “Yeah. That’s it.”

Natalie. Nat. It’s a nice name for my first college crush.

 

Chapter Two

Natalie

I’m ten minutes into my first class of the year and already doodling in the margins of my notebook. Great. Introductions are always boring, but I should probably try to focus for at least the first day. I put my pencil down and tear my gaze away from my paper even though the figure I am drawing still needs a face. A dude I know from an art history class last term is introducing himself, talking about how this class fits into his study of nineteenth-century philosophy. What an interminable douche. My fingers itch to draw again, but I drum them quietly on my knee instead. I’m so antsy lately, practically unable to concentrate on one thing at a time. I need to get my focus issues under control now that classes are starting up again, or I’m going to miss everything. I’m used to my ADHD affecting my focus, but it’s been worse than usual since I returned to campus a couple days ago. I’ve had this restless energy I don’t know how to quell.

Maybe it’s because the summer was so utterly depressing. I missed everything here so much—my friends, the classes, even my work-study job at the campus post office. I mean, I love my family, my neighborhood in Brooklyn, and working at my mom’s classic Jewish deli, Mim’s. I’ve probably spent more time in the store, which my mom named for my grandmother, Miriam, than anywhere else in the entire world. But I spent the summer thinking about how much happier I am at school. Now that I’m here again, it’s almost the opposite. Life back home is never far from my mind.

Three years of college may be a long time, but every moment feels like it’s too important to waste. I have to make a promise to myself. I will forget about everything at home and enjoy my freedom while I can. I’m going to live my best damn college life.

But to do that, I need to get out of my own head already. I flip my attention back to the room around me just as Professor Vargas interrupts the philosophy douche.

“That’s good, Louis…Next?” She gestures to the girl sitting directly across from me, who nods like she’s been given orders from a drill sergeant. Cute.

“Hi, everyone.” I smile at her light Southern accent. She waves at no one in particular. “I’m Ginny Holland. Uh…she / her. I’m a first-year. I’m from Virginia.” Ginny from Virginia. I wonder if Ginny’s a nickname. “I don’t know what I want to study yet, but I’m really excited for this class! Um…Yeah. Thanks.” She smiles and deep dimples appear in her cheeks. Very cute.

The next person begins their introduction, but I study Ginny from Virginia a little longer. She has long, dark brown hair and round wire-rimmed glasses. I’m such a sucker for the nerdy vibe. Normally, I wouldn’t say I have a type—beyond girls, of course—but I reconsider as I watch Ginny push her glasses back up the bridge of her nose. I want to see her eyes up close.

She listens intently as Professor Vargas prompts the next student, who’s so nervous his hands shake before he even starts speaking. He stumbles over his own name, and a smile forms on Ginny’s face. She seems kind and encouraging, even though the nervous guy isn’t looking at her.

Her gaze darts away from him and lands on me. Her dark eyebrows rise on her forehead, surprised, but she doesn’t immediately look away, so I don’t either. I smile, and she smiles back. She does a tiny wave under her desk, like she did when she introduced herself, but this time it’s directed at me. I wave back and she smiles wider, showing off her dimples. Yep. Definitely very, very cute. She looks away, so I do too, bringing my focus back to the class.

Professor Vargas gives us an overview of the course, talking about all the books we’ll be reading and explaining the essays for the term. I didn’t take any literature classes last term, and I missed it more than I thought I would. I don’t love writing essays, but I adore getting the chance to read books I never have time for at home. It’s great for inspiration, as of course I inevitably illustrate my favorite moments.

I tap my fingers restlessly on my leg again, then I let them drift to my paper. Based on the class description, this notebook will be full of vampires and Victorian-style ghosts by the time the term is over. I’d started a figure earlier but haven’t gotten past basic facial structure. I give her hair, long and dark, and pencil in delicate features and thin, circular glasses. I add one little dimple.

God, I’m such a sap, drawing a cute girl on the first day of class. There are tons of cute queer girls on this campus, and I’m determined to get to know a lot of them this term. Maybe Ginny from Virginia could be one of them, but there’s no need to be so focused on just her. Plus, I’m sitting between my friends Lizzie and Mack, and I do not want to know the teasing I’d get from them for openly drawing a stranger in class. I think of what to draw next as I flip the page.

I haven’t drawn someone in overalls in a while…Best to leave Ginny out of it, though. I sketch a pair of overalls on their own. My dream overalls. I add a tiny rainbow patch on the front pocket.

I wonder if Ginny’s the type to put a rainbow patch on her overalls.

I get absorbed in my sketch, drawing patch after patch all over the imaginary overalls, and before I realize what’s happened class is over. Mack immediately starts chattering about how excited they are for the first book we’re studying. I take one last look at my sketch. That turned out nice. I flip my notebook closed.

Ginny packs her bag and stands from her desk. Yeah, I definitely have a thing for overalls. I pull my gaze away and follow my friends out the door. It’s just past noon, so we head toward the dining hall for lunch.

 

v

 

I have three texts from my brother and two from my mom. I read Noah’s first.

 

moms upset

shes gonna text u about ur debit card

good luck

 

He adds a fingers-crossed emoji. Sure enough, my mom is less than pleased in her texts.

 

Why have you spent $86 this week?

I want you to enjoy your time at school, but you know you can’t spend money like that.

 

I sigh, feeling myself being pulled back into the stressful mindset I had just started to escape. I respond to my mother first.

 

It was all on school supplies.

My figure drawing and ceramics classes both require a ton of materials. I bought the cheapest options, I promise.

 

I go back to my texts with my brother. Noah is sixteen, three and a half years younger than me, and he should be in school right now.

 

Thanks but how did u know that?

Where r u?

 

He responds almost immediately.

 

mom texted me to ask if i knew if u were in class so she could call u.i told her to text u

and yes im in school. one mom is enough thank u

 

He punctuates that with two eyeroll emojis. I send back a shrug emoji just as a reply comes in from my mom.

 

Okay. Warn me next time. Love you.

 

I return the sentiment and shove my phone into my pocket. I hate that I have to deal with family finances even when I’m two hundred miles away. I’m on a scholarship, but college is still expensive as hell. When I got accepted here and added up all the costs, I told my mom I wouldn’t attend. But she knew how much studying art in college meant to me, so she didn’t entertain that idea for a second—even with the impact on her and the deli. I’m the first person in my family to go to college, and she’s always wished she’d been able to attend. It’s not not a lot of pressure, and that’s just one more reason to make the most of my time here.

“Nat?” Lizzie’s voice breaks me out of my anxiety spiral. I turn to see her looking at me quizzically. I’ve missed something. Again. “You okay?”

I nod, brushing off her concern. I’m great. “I’m awesome.”

Lizzie furrows her brow, but she moves on anyway. “We were talking about the party at Powell this weekend.” Powell is a dorm house known for throwing some of the wilder parties on campus. A party is just what I need to forget about my shitty summer.

“You gonna go?” Mack asks.

“Of course! First party of the year? I can’t wait.”

It’s gonna be great.

I just need to keep telling myself that and sooner or later I’ll actually start believing it.

 

Chapter Three

Ginny

God, I’m a nerd. The first big party of the year is tonight, but instead of drinking and dancing, I met a couple people from my psychology class at the student lounge for some tea and homework.

The culture here is so different than it was in high school. People think of nerdy as a positive trait. I don’t worry about seeming uncool for loving my courses, and I don’t need to feign interest in school sports. My social life isn’t what I want it to be yet, but I’ve met a lot of nice people, and I have enough acquaintances to have people to eat with at meals. Hopefully, I’ll get up the courage to go to one of the big parties one day, but I wasn’t ready to push myself quite that far out of my comfort zone tonight.

I pass Powell on my way back to my room, and music from the party booms out like an earthquake, overpowering the music in my headphones. Jess tried to get me to go with her tonight, but I declined. I smile at the grass as I walk. Yeah, I’m definitely happy with my textbooks and chamomile for now.

I make my way to my own dorm, upstairs and down the hall to my room. I open my door and—

Oh my God!

The hot girl from Gothic Lit is standing just a few feet in front of me. Natalie. Nat. She’s pulling up her jeans and not wearing a shirt.

Oh. My. God.

I tear my eyes away from her boobs to find her staring at me, eyebrows raised and an amused smile on her face. She looks only slightly surprised to see me, while I genuinely cannot process what I’m seeing.

“Hi?” She says it like it’s a question, with her focus half on me and half on buttoning her pants. I snap out of my half-naked-hot-girl-in-front-of-me stupor.

“I—um—sorry.” I take one huge step backward and let the door close in my face.

What the hell was that? I read the sign on the door, but it still says my and Jess’s names. Not the wrong room. A knock comes from the other side of the door.

“You can come in,” Natalie calls.

I hesitate. I mean, I wouldn’t mind exactly if she still isn’t wearing a shirt, but I’ll probably act like an idiot again. But she said I could come in. And it is my room, after all.

I push the door open slowly, peering in. She wears a pastel striped short-sleeve button-up shirt now, though she’s only half-finished buttoning it.

“Hey.” She sends me a slightly sheepish smile. “You’re Ginny. From Gothic Lit.” She remembers my name. I blush. A girl this hot shouldn’t be this nice, too.

“Yeah.”

“I’m Natalie, by the—”

“I remember you.”

She smiles and shrugs on her denim jacket with all its pins and patches. “Glad I made an impression.” Her deep brown eyes sparkle, and I blink back at her.

I should probably clarify why I walked in on her. “Um, this is my room.” I take a step in and gesture to my bed, as if that proves everything. “I’m pretty sure.”

“I figured!” She laughs. “Sorry I surprised you there. I met your roommate at the Powell party, and we were hanging out.”

I glance around. Maybe Jess is hiding under one of our beds or something.

Natalie must realize my confusion because she clarifies. “When we, uh, finished, she went to take a shower. I was just getting myself together before I left.”

Wow. That’s blunter than I’m used to, but I nod.

“Oh.” It’s all I can think of to say. My crush of less than one week has already hooked up with my roommate. Things move fast around here. I barely know her, but I’m still a little dismayed.

“You’re from Virginia, right?” She remembers that, too.

“Yes.”

“Ginny from Virginia.” She hums thoughtfully. I’ve gotten this reaction countless times, so I know where she’s going with it.

“Yeah, my parents are overly patriotic and abhorrently unoriginal.”

She laughs, and I smile back at her. “So, that’s your full name. Virginia? From Virginia?”

“Yep.”

“Wow.” She stops laughing for a moment, then seems to be hit with the ridiculousness of my name all over again. “That’s—damn.”

“Yeah.” I put my hands in the pockets of my light flannel jacket. Her laughter dies down and she looks me over. My ears go hot under her scrutiny.

“I like Ginny,” she murmurs. “Suits you.”

“Thanks.” We stand in silence for a moment, but then her gaze shifts to the door. She takes a couple steps toward it, and I adjust to give her room, but she stops abruptly. I meant to get out of her way, but I somehow brought us closer together. Her hand brushes the side of my jacket as she turns to me.

“Sorry again about…” She gestures to herself.

“No, no, it’s fine! No worries.” Hopefully I don’t sound too okay with it. “I’m sorry I walked in on you…” I repeat her gesture, so I don’t accidentally say something about how good she looked half naked. She laughs.

“It’s literally your room. No reason to be sorry. Good thing you didn’t walk in ten minutes earlier.”

“Oh, wow!” My brain concocts an image of walking in on her and Jess, but I shove it away. That would be a whole other level of awkward. “Yeah, I should probably talk to Jess about protocol for…guests.”

“I always forget to lock these doors.”

“Yeah.” Though I haven’t done anything in this room worthy of locking the door.

She glances to the door, back to me, then looks at my oversized red-and-white flannel jacket. She ghosts her fingers over the bottom edge of it.

“I’ve been looking for something like this.” Her voice is low, like her words are for my ears only. She plays with the corner of my jacket, and her knuckle brushes right above my hip. It’s the quickest, tiniest touch, but my stomach muscles tense. She looks up at me from under the hair hanging over her eyes, then back to the jacket. “I have tons of flannels, but only shirts. No jackets. Gotta change that if I want to keep my reputation as a stereotypical lesbian, right?”

“Uh, right. Definitely.” I laugh lightly. She cringes.

“Not to put that generalization on you. Sorry. I was just talking about me.”

“It’s fine.” Just say it, Ginny. It’s never going to feel normal if you don’t treat it like it is normal. “I’m bi, not a lesbian, but I do get the flannel thing.” I gesture to my jacket. “Obviously.” She chuckles.

“Gotcha.” She thumbs the fabric for a moment again. “This is a good one.” She returns her hand to her side and takes a step back.

I miss the closeness more than I care to admit.

“Well, good night, Ginny from Virginia.” She pulls the door open and shoots me a quick grin.

“Good night, Natalie.” And then she’s gone. I flop on my bed. The image of her tugging her jeans over her hips comes back to me—the unselfconscious way she held herself, even when I stared at her chest like an idiot. I have years of experience gawking at hot girls from a distance, but doing it up close is a whole new adventure.

If Nat starts dating Jess, walking in on her half-naked in my room could become a regular occurrence. That sounds like torture and heaven all at once. But last I heard, Jess still had a girlfriend. I know she’ll be heartbroken if they split up, but I hope that’s the answer. Or at least I hope she told Natalie about her girlfriend first. I’ll have to ask Jess about that in some non-judgmental way. The door bangs open, and as if I’d summoned her, Jess comes in, wrapped in her fluffy blue robe.

“Hey, Gin.”

“Hey. I met your, uh, friend, earlier. Well, I’d already met her, actually…but…yeah.”

“Natasha?”

Well, not knowing her name makes it seem less likely they’re going to start dating anytime soon.

“I think it’s Natalie.”

“Oh, damn, right.” She laughs and starts to change into her pajamas.

“I don’t want to pry, but—”

“Sara and I broke up yesterday.”

“Oh, God, I’m sorry. That sucks.”

She shrugs and turns away from me. I can’t see her face, but it’s clear she doesn’t want to talk about it. I lie back on my bed, letting my thoughts drift back to Natalie.

She was really nice. And funny. And still super hot. And I think she was flirting with me. Hopefully someday I’ll be brave enough to flirt back.

 

Chapter Four

Natalie

Usually, I avoid Monday morning classes like they’re someone sneezing on the subway without covering their face, but I made an exception during registration this term since Mack and Lizzie were already planning to take the course. I thought I’d at least be tired and miserable with my friends. Surprisingly, I’m not miserable at all as we walk out of the dining hall toward the literature building. Still tired, sure, but also excited. After my awkward yet incredibly endearing encounter with Ginny in her room a couple nights ago, she’s been on my mind a lot. I haven’t had that much fun flirting with someone in a long time.

I love first conversations. Conversations where you first get a sense of someone. The first time you think Hey, you seem cool. I think I’d like to get to know you better.

I had that feeling from the moment she’d backed out the door of her own room, adorably confused and trying to be respectful even though I was the one in her space. The second I left the room I almost went right back in. I wanted to ask if she wanted to keep talking as much as I did. I wanted to keep flirting with her so I could watch her react. I wanted to keep playing with her flannel to see if she’d touch me back.

I couldn’t tell if she was flirting or just being nice and meeting my energy, but she definitely seemed interested by the sight of me half-naked. If she is into me, I certainly wouldn’t turn down the chance to hook up with her. But even if she’s not interested, I’m eager just to talk to her again. So when Mack and Lizzie head toward the desks we sat at last class, I gesture to where Ginny sits.

“Let’s go over there.”

They shrug and follow. Ginny is rifling through her backpack, so she hasn’t noticed us yet. I plop into the seat beside her, and she looks up. She smiles when she sees me, like it’s an automatic reaction, and I know I must be grinning back.

“Hey,” she says.

“Hey.” I turn and gesture to my friends, who are settling in at the desks next to us. “Ginny, this is Mack Andrews, and this is Lizzie Moore. Mack and Lizzie, this is Ginny.”

They exchange hellos and Mack immediately asks Ginny what she thought of the reading assignment for today. Mack can talk about literature endlessly, and Lizzie is incredibly friendly, so the conversation takes off quickly. I sit back for a couple minutes, listening to them chat about George Eliot books and the other classes they’re taking this term. Lizzie makes a joke and I watch Ginny’s dimples appear and disappear as she laughs.

My chest squeezes. I must be even more invested in friendship with Ginny than I realized if I’m this happy to see her getting along with my friends.

Professor Vargas blows in like a hurricane a few minutes later, carrying another mountain of papers that seem ridiculously precarious. I’d bet good money she’s lost more than a few of those over campus today. She’s the only professor I have who avoids technology in our assignments. Some students seemed annoyed when she asked us not to use laptops in class unless we needed them, but I find her aversion to the digital age charming. She distributes some academic essays on the reading, and class begins. About halfway through the class, she gives us a few questions about the reading and tells us to split into pairs for one-on-one discussion.

I turn to Ginny. “Partners?”

“Sure.”

We chat about the reading for a bit, but I find myself paying way more attention to what I can learn about Ginny than the book. She’s smart, thoughtful, and clearly comfortable talking about literature. An easy confidence enters her voice and her adorable Southern-accented words become smoother and more deliberate.

“You love this,” I say when we finish Vargas’s questions.

Her brow furrows. “What? The book?”

“Talking like this. The questions. The analysis. All this academic shit.”

“Yeah, I do.” She shrugs. “Not being a nerd has never been a skill of mine.”

“Aw, nerds are cool now. Smart is sexy and all that.”

She glances around the room, eyes flickering over all the students eagerly engaged in discussion. “I guess it is here. I’m still getting used to that.”

“It wasn’t like that back home?”

“Hard no.” I laugh at the way she widens her eyes at me, as if the idea is unfathomable. I grew up in a pretty liberal Brooklyn bubble, where we were all told different was special and unique was normal, so this campus full of aggressively progressive hipsters has always felt like home to me. But it’s clear it is new to Ginny. “Do you like it? The academic shit, as you put it.”

I tilt my head side to side a couple times, considering her question. “It doesn’t always come naturally to me, to be honest. Reading eight-hundred-page books and writing tons of essays, I mean. But I enjoy it, yeah. It’s not, like, my thing, but it’s fun.”

She laughs. “You are a nerd. You just called eight-hundred-page books fun.”

“Hell yeah.” I lean in a little closer, propping my chin on my hand. “Like I said, smart is sexy, right?”

She nods while her lips quirk with a smile. “Right.” She draws the word out, her light Southern accent more pronounced than usual. Raht. My eyes flick from her lips to her eyes. She holds my gaze for a long moment, then looks away. “You study art, you said? That’s your thing?”

“Yeah, my major is visual art. I draw and paint, mostly.” She glances to the notebook on my desk, where I scribbled a couple quick sketches before the class broke into groups. I turn it around so she can see. I point to one of the more detailed sketches. “That’s my cat back home. Moose.” She leans over to study the drawing.

“Moose,” she repeats, smiling at the sketch. “You’re very talented.” She makes eye contact again—this time over the rims of her glasses. My cheeks heat.

Her eyes are so damn green.

I’m the one who looks away first this time. I’m not generally prone to embarrassment, but the intensity of her green eyes and the sincere compliment were too much for me.

“Thanks.” I mean it. I flip through my notebook, searching for another drawing to show her. I think I did a couple drawings I really liked in this notebook, but it might have been another one.

There’s a sketch of a tree behind the science building that’s nice but nothing special.

One page has about twenty attempts to draw a mirror that all turned out weird.

There’s—Shit!

I quickly flip back to the drawing of Moose before Ginny can see the sketch I did on the first day of this class. The one with long dark hair and glasses that might seem suspiciously familiar to her. I glance up at her, but she’s looking at the floor.

I follow her gaze and realize she’s taking in the flower tattoo on my ankle. I lift the cuff of my jeans so she can see all of it.

“It’s a dahlia. My mom’s favorite.”

“It’s beautiful.”

“Thanks. Are you pro or con on tattoos? For yourself, I mean. If you’re con for others, you can keep that opinion to yourself.” She laughs.

“Pro. Generally pro. Well, pro in a very aspirational way, you know? I would love one, but I think it would take me about thirty years to work up the courage. Plus, my parents would lose their minds, so it’s probably a good idea to wait a while.”

“Yeah, my mom wasn’t too into it. She went on and on about how I couldn’t be buried in a Jewish cemetery. But she got over it. I can’t wait to get another.”

Ginny looks down at my ankle again. “It’s very…” She tilts her head as she thinks. “You, I guess. Not that I know you all that well. It just reminds me of your sketches.”

“That’s because it is my sketch.”

Her gaze flies to mine. “Really? That’s awesome.”

“Yeah. I mean, I didn’t do the tattoo myself, obviously, but there’s a girl in the year above me who does stick-and-poke tattoos, and I gave her my sketch. She’s really talented and, you know, not insanely expensive, if you’re ever interested.”

“Wow.” She opens her mouth to say more but stops. There’s a look in her eye as she studies me that I can’t quite identify.

“What?”

“It’s just really cool that you know yourself like that. You know what you want to put on your body and you’re talented enough to make it happen.”

I shrug. “It’s just a flower.”

“Not to you.” She raises an eyebrow in challenge.

I feel the answering smirk on my face. I like that she pushes me. I like that she already sees me enough to push me. “No, not to me.”

“You have a lot of drive, don’t you?”

I nod. I used to think I wasn’t particularly ambitious, but applying to art school changed that. I’ve never wanted anything more than to be able to call myself an artist, even if it won’t last forever. Getting this tattoo last year was like inking a small reminder to myself on my ankle. I am an artist. My art will always be a part of me, no matter what else I do.

“That’s amazing. I have absolutely no idea what I want to do with myself,” Ginny says.

We’re complete opposites. I know exactly what I want to do with myself—be an artist. But I won’t be able to do that. I will have to go back home when I graduate and help my mom run the deli. Someday Noah and I will have to run the store on our own, my art will fall by the wayside, and that’ll be my life.

But I don’t tell Ginny any of that. I want to learn more about her, not depress her.

“You don’t want to study literature?” I ask instead.

“Maybe? I don’t know. I’ve always loved it, but I also feel like I have no idea what else I could do, you know?”

“I’m kinda jealous of that. That…freedom.”

“Really?”

“Really.”

She studies me for a moment before nodding. I think she can tell how much I mean it, even if she doesn’t know exactly why I mean it. “Well, right back at you. Knowing what you want so clearly? That’s…that’s everything.”

Damn. I can barely imagine being in her shoes—no idea what to do with my life but open to all the possibilities. But despite her blissful freedom, she’s jealous of me. My life can’t suck that much if she sees something enviable in it, even if she doesn’t know the whole story. I’ve been trying so hard to forget about my obligations back home so I can enjoy my time here, and for the first time since I got back to campus, that fantasy actually feels possible.

I lean in to ask Ginny what else she’s interested in, but Professor Vargas calls our attention to resume group discussion. I turn my gaze to the professor and try to listen.

My fingers itch to flip back in my notebook and finish the sketch I’d begun last class. I want to capture the way Ginny furrows her brow when she’s focused. I want to find a colored pencil that exactly matches the green of her eyes. I want to perfect her adorable dimples, making the right slightly deeper than the left, just like it is in real life. But I can’t—not with the real-life Ginny barely two feet away. I have no idea how she’d react if she caught me mid-sketch. It’s probably for the best, anyway. I draw cute girls all the time, but usually not the ones I actually become friends with. And after that surprisingly special conversation, I know I want to be Ginny’s friend.

I draw a sandwich instead, trying to focus on how hungry I am instead of the urge to memorize her features. Maybe I can manifest mozzarella and tomato sandwiches in the dining hall if I draw them well enough.

Professor Vargas dismisses us fifteen minutes later. When Ginny slings her packed bag over her shoulder, she turns to Mack and Lizzie.

“It was nice to meet y’all,” she says, and they return the sentiment. She turns to go, but I stop her with a hand on her elbow.

“Wait, where are you headed?”

“Lunch, I guess.”

“Come eat with us.”

Mack and Lizzie nod. “Yeah!” Mack says. “I want to pick your brain on that Dickens book you were talking about.”

Ginny’s dimples make another appearance. “Sure, thanks. That sounds fun.”

 

v

 

We all head toward the dining hall together. It occurs to me Ginny probably doesn’t have many friends yet since it’s only the second week of school. Maybe she can be part of our group. Given the way Mack enthusiastically echoed my invitation to lunch, it seems they like her, too.

We snag a table outside the dining hall and go inside to grab food. Lizzie and I head toward the display of sandwiches, while Ginny and Mack get in line for hot food.

“So…” Lizzie starts as I survey the sandwich options. Tragically, there is no mozzarella and tomato today.

“So?” I prompt Lizzie when she doesn’t continue.

“So, what’s going on? You have a crush on her, don’t you?”

I forgot how easily Lizzie can tell what I’m feeling. I’m typically hard to read—or so I’ve been told an almost concerning number of times—but Lizzie has been an exception to that rule since the day we met.

It was only two days into orientation last year when I walked in on her crying in a bathroom in the basement of the arts building. There was a talk about clubs and activities we were supposed to attend, but instead we sat on the cold tile floor together and I comforted her while she unloaded her fears about living up to her parents’ insanely high expectations. In minutes, I felt like I knew her—probably because I related to her eldest child overwhelmed by parental pressure to excel in college story at every turn.

After fifteen minutes, I hadn’t said a word about myself, but she looked me in the eyes and said, “You know exactly what I’m talking about, don’t you?” Her confidence told me it was more than a random guess. She’d seen something I had no idea I was showing.

I should have known Lizzie would notice my attraction to Ginny, but I can’t pass up the opportunity to tease her a little bit.

I shrug at her knowing smirk.

“Whoever could you be talking about?”

She scoffs. “Don’t pretend you don’t know I mean Ginny.”

“Fine. I know you mean Ginny.” I hesitate to agree completely, because I know Lizzie will take me having a crush way too seriously. She loves the idea of seeing me in a serious relationship for the first time, so I need to stay nonchalant to keep her from hounding me. “I don’t know if I’d say I have a crush on her, but…I mean, she’s cute, right?”

“She’s definitely cute. And…” She waits expectantly until I give in.

“And nice. And funny.”

“Hmm.” Lizzie raises her eyebrows at me. She is not subtle whatsoever. She may as well ask me if I like-likeGinny and send us all the way back to middle school.

“Oh, shut up.” I shove her lightly and she almost drops the sandwich she’s putting on her plate. “I want to be her friend.”

“And hook up with her.” Good. As long as Lizzie’s staying away from the romance idea, I don’t need to worry.

“Well, yeah. Have you seen her dimples?”

“I have.” She sighs wistfully as we maneuver back outside. I can always trust Lizzie to drool over hot girls with me.

“But I really do want to be her friend, too.”

“So, what’s the order of priorities there? Hookup then friendship, or the other way around?”

“Friendship first, definitely.”

We put our food on our table. Ginny and Mack haven’t arrived yet, so Lizzie continues her line of questioning. “Do you even know if she’s queer?”

“She’s bi.”

Lizzie laughs. “How long did you wait before asking her that?”

“I didn’t ask. That would be rude. She offered. After I not so subtly mentioned being a lesbian.”

“Of course you did.” She holds my gaze, a sincere smile on her face. “You know…I missed you this summer.”

A twinge of guilt pricks me. I wasn’t great at keeping in touch with my friends over the break, especially Lizzie. I didn’t know how to respond to all the how are you texts when I didn’t have anything remotely fun or interesting to share. We talked about her loving but deeply overbearing parents, her exhausting summer internship, and her brief interactions with her high school ex. But I froze every time she asked about me. I didn’t want to wallow in self-pity or bring down her stellar summer with my shitty one. I couldn’t tell her the truth. I dissociated through a day of work with my mom, tried to draw but didn’t feel inspired, then binge-watched TV on my laptop alone in my room. So instead, I gave her bland, diluted updates, and our conversations got shorter and more sporadic as the break went on.

“I missed you too, Liz. And I…I know I’m not the best at keeping up with texts and everything. I’m sorry about that.”

She blinks at me, sandwich halfway into her mouth, then puts it back down and reaches out to squeeze my arm. “It’s okay. I know you were busy. Working at your mom’s store and…everything.” I nod, but she’s left an unspoken question between us. I wasn’t too busy to talk about her life, and yet she doesn’t know anything I did this summer beyond work.

Our friendship lives in this awkward, undefined limbo sometimes. There’s a line I haven’t crossed yet—a line I haven’t wanted to cross. She’s the closest person I have to a best friend, though I know I can’t really call her that. Your best friend knows you, the good and the bad, and I still hate the idea of Lizzie seeing all the bad. I want to fix anything I damaged between us over the summer, but I’m not ready for that level of vulnerability. I’ll have to find another way to get our friendship back to where it was last year.

Whatever the hell that might be.

We eat in silence for a moment before she spots something over my shoulder and whispers, “Try not to stare too much.”

I glance behind me to see Ginny and Mack approaching. Mack gestures animatedly as they discuss a book I’ve never heard of. I’m grateful for the reprieve from my conversation with Lizzie, especially when Ginny sits next to me. I can focus on how the tiny table means her leg keeps grazing mine instead of what a shitty friend I’ve been.

As we eat, our friends Beth and Rafael join us. I introduce them to Ginny and have that same feeling of sudden relief when they seem to get along. All my closest friends are here now—plus Ginny. Maybe she’ll become one of my closest friends, too. I like that idea a lot.

Rafael says something that makes the rest of the table laugh, but I don’t catch it.

Ginny catches my eye and gives me a wasn’t that so funny? look. I laugh with her even though I have no idea what he said. She leans toward me and whispers, “Thanks for inviting me to have lunch with you and your friends.”

“Of course.” I match her intimate volume. “I’m really glad you came.” She smiles, and I do my best to not stare at her dimples.

I wonder if that stereotype about lesbians staying friends with their exes is true. So many things like that are stupid generalizations, and yet I’m a lesbian who loves flannel. Lizzie’s a lesbian who hates flannel but owns a Subaru Outback. I know some queer people who had crazy dramatic breakups and can’t stand to be in the same room with their exes now. But my best friend from high school still video chats once a week with a girl she dated for our entire sophomore year. I’m sure Ginny and I could hook up once or twice and still be friends. Now I just have to find out if she’d be interested.

Laughter resounds around the table and pulls me back into the conversation.

“—and he just keeps talking and talking and talking, so we’re all looking around at each other like, is this guy for real. Even the professor—”

Everyone is captivated by Mack’s story, but I’ve missed too much to understand.

My friends are bound to notice if I keep spacing out. Lizzie probably already has. Ginny helped me get out of my head for a moment earlier. I need to hold on to that feeling and not get trapped in anxiety about what each interaction with her might mean. Whatever happens with Ginny, it’s supposed to be fun. Casual. Easy.

“It’s only been two classes, and I already want to explode every time he talks. He is the most annoying literature bro I’ve ever encountered, and that’s saying a lot at this school.”

I can only assume they are talking about the philosophy-obsessed guy in our lit class.

I lean forward and catch Mack’s eye. “What about that guy who wouldn’t stop talking about Hemingway in your feminist lit class last year? I wasn’t even there, and I remember every insufferable thing he said.”

Mack throws their head back and groans. “Oh, God, Nat, Hemingway dude! I can’t believe I forgot about Hemingway dude. You’re right. No one could be worse than him.” They recount some anecdotes about their least favorite classmate to Ginny. We all listen, rapt despite the fact that the rest of us have heard these stories multiple times before.

Ginny’s shoulder shakes with laughter against mine, and I feel luckier than I have in months. I want to bottle the rush I get from the simple melody of her laugh.