Prologue

Camilla Lyons stayed on her knees, knowing how helpless and pathetic she must have looked. But she couldn’t bring herself to stand. She watched Alicia shove shirt after shirt into the barely used mauve suitcase they’d bought together a few years ago for their trip to Cancun. The hangers fell carelessly to the floor.

“I’m sorry,” Alicia repeated over and over. She swiped at her eyes every few seconds, as though the tears were just a minor annoyance. She seemed almost dazed. “It’s not your fault. It’s not mine, either. These things just happen. I’m so sorry.”

Enough rage coursed through Cami’s veins to propel her into the standing position. “What things just happen? A week ago, everything was fine, and now you’re so unhappy you’re leaving me? That’s not something that just happens.”

Alicia sighed heavily but still wouldn’t meet Cami’s eyes. She picked up the snow globe from her nightstand and gave it a quick shake. “I’m going to take this. Unless you want it?”

Cami turned toward the window, the tears that had been falling forever miraculously dried up. She wondered if she was in a state of shock. Below, Mike from 3C threw his trash into the dumpster, completely unaware that two floors up, Cami’s life was falling to pieces.

“No, I don’t fucking want it,” she snapped, barely a whisper. She swallowed hard, trying to rationalize what was happening. It had been less than a week since they’d been leafing through brochures for a tropical getaway. Cami fought a sob. She’d said all she could say, but if she didn’t try one more time, she didn’t think she’d be able to forgive herself.

“Alicia, wait,” Cami said. She took her by the wrists and forced her to look at her. “I love you. Whatever it is you’re going through, I’ll give you the time, space, anything you need. You are the great love of my life. The one. The only one. Please don’t do this. Please.” Cami knew she was begging, but she didn’t care.

Alicia’s eyes welled up again. “Cami, please stop. I just…I can’t do this. I thought this was what I wanted, marriage, kids, the whole thing. But then I just kind of sit back and wonder if I’m doing it because it’s what people are ‘supposed’ to do, and I don’t want to imprison myself just so I can say I’m successful in life.”

Cami took her point, but that didn’t make it hurt any less. “So you think spending your life with me is a prison sentence. Got it.”

“I didn’t say that. You just deserve more than—”

“No.” Cami held her hand up forcefully. “This is not about you being altruistic because you think I deserve someone better. Alicia, we’ve been together for six years. Six fucking years. We’ve had our ups and downs like anyone else, but you’ve never said you don’t want to be with me, or you don’t want a relationship or that you want to be alone. What changed? Is it because I’ve been too focused on my work? I know I’ve been focused on other things. We should have talked more. Is it because we started seriously talking about marriage? If it’s the word that’s freaking you out, then the hell with it! We won’t get married. I don’t need a wedding to know that I love you.”

Alicia covered her face with her hands. “I love you, too. But that’s not always enough.”

The words Cami had been swallowing since Alicia had made her grand announcement had finally rose to the surface. “Is there someone else?”

Alicia hesitated.

Cami felt her stomach sink to the floor.

“No. There’s no one else.”

“Do you want there to be?” Cami asked.

“No. That has absolutely nothing to do with this. But I don’t know what will happen in six months. A year? Five years?”

Cami shook her head. None of this made any sense. “You’re breaking up with me because you might want to see someone else in five years? Alicia, that’s insane. I might be dead in five years, does that mean I should leave you?”

Alicia took a step toward Cami, and for a fraction of a second, Cami’s heart swelled with hope. Alicia danced her fingers along Cami’s collarbone, and Cami shivered.

“I love you, Cam. I do, I honestly do. More than I’ve ever loved anyone. But I need to do this. I’ve been telling you that I’m in a rut. I just need something new, something different. There’s more to life, there has to be. I’m a hostage in my own skin. I quit my job today.”

Cami’s eyes grew wide. “You did what?” Maybe Alicia was having some kind of breakdown, some kind of mental crisis. She’d been a headline reporter at the Knox County Sun for the last four years, and as far as Cami knew, she loved it. She’d had her days where she’d compared the politics of it all to a war zone, but for the most part, Cami was under the impression that Alicia was content and fulfilled. Maybe that was the problem. Maybe Cami didn’t know her at all, even after six years together.

“Yeah, I did,” Alicia said. She seemed defiant. “And I leave tomorrow for Perth. I’m going to be exploring western Australia for the next six months.”

Cami’s head swam. Alicia had to be dragged out of the house on the weekend to do just about anything, and now she was going to Australia? For six months? Who is this person? “Are you going alone?” Cami’s voice sounded distant to her own ears.

“Yes. I’m staying at an Airbnb, and I set up a tour guide to help me get familiar with the area.”

“How are you paying for this?” Cami sat on the edge of the bed, feeling a little woozy. “When did you make the plans?”

Alicia pursed her lips. “I made the plans over the last couple of days. I wasn’t sure I was going to go through with it. I liquidated my 401K.”

“Are you in some kind of trouble? I can help you,” Cami said, reaching for her hand.

Alicia gave her hand a quick squeeze and dropped it. “No, Cami. I know you’re trying to make sense of all this. So am I in a way. I wish I had answers for you. I wish I could tell you the whys, but I can’t. It’s just something I have to do. Something I want to do. For myself.”

Cami squeezed the back of her neck. Nausea flooded her. “I think that maybe you should hold off on leaving for a few days. Talk to your parents. Your brother. Maybe call a therapist.”

“I’ve talked to my parents. I’ve talked to Sean. I don’t need a therapist. Well, maybe I do, but not about this.”

“I don’t know how to live without you, Alicia. I didn’t think I’d have to try.” Cami’s chest heaved with sadness. Everything that had happened since that morning felt like a dream. A vivid, terrible dream.

“I don’t know how to live without you, either. We’ll figure it out. Trust me, I don’t want to hurt you, Cami.”

Maybe it was a midlife crisis. Alicia was a little young for that at thirty-four, but Cami had heard of it . What she would have given for Alicia to have gone out and bought a Corvette or for her to have gotten a gaudy tattoo across her back.

“Okay. I understand,” Cami said, trying to rein herself in. She needed to be calm, pragmatic. “So take the six months. Enjoy yourself, live it up, figure out everything you need to figure out. When you come back, we’ll talk, and maybe things will feel different for you. Maybe we can start over.”

Alicia hesitated again. “I don’t know what’s going to happen, Cami. But I can’t let you believe that in six months, everything will go back to the way it is now. That would just be cruel.”

Cami breathed in deeply and craned her neck toward the ceiling. She was beginning to spiral, the perceived loss of control sending her into a mild panic attack. Her face flushed, and her heart fluttered.

“This is it? That’s it, after six years together? We have a life, Alicia. Everything in this apartment is ours, we have friends and a checking account, and we spend the holidays with each other’s families.”

“You can have everything in the apartment.”

Cami fought the urge to scream. “That’s not what this is about. I don’t give a shit about the apartment. What I’m saying is that this whole thing is just insane, and I don’t understand what’s happening. This isn’t you. It isn’t.”

Alicia nodded. “It wasn’t. But now it is. It has to be. I love you, I have to go.”

In a daze, Cami watched as Alicia grabbed the suitcase from the bed and sprinted for the door. She wanted to follow. She wanted to yell for her not to go. When Cami tried to muster up something, anything, that might convince Alicia to stay, her voice failed her. Nothing came. Just the silence that blanketed her after the door closed behind Alicia.

 

Chapter One

Three Years Later

 

Cami sat back in her chair and rubbed her temples. Sunny April afternoons killed her. The tree pollen coated her windowsill like a fluorescent dust storm. But Cami hadn’t taken a sick day since the New England Patriots had won their first Super Bowl, and she’d faked an ear infection so she could go to the Boston parade.

“Have you taken anything?” Kelsey Chandler asked, tossing a cough drop onto Cami’s desk.

“Why, do I sound that bad? Yeah, I took some Claritin a little while ago. Didn’t help,” Cami said. She cleared her throat and popped the cough drop into her mouth.

“Yes, you do. You sound like shit. Why don’t you just go home? Not like there’s a whole lot you can do here,” Kelsey said.

She wasn’t wrong. Cami could feel her eyelids growing heavier by the second. But she just couldn’t allow herself to leave. Their sleepy town had been a peaceful haven for as long as Cami had lived there, the entirety of her forty-two years. With the closest city about thirty-five miles to their east, Oakview was little more than a speck on the map.

They were known for one thing, and that one thing permeated just about every facet of Oakview’s commercial viability: black pepper ice cream. No one could fully trace the ice cream’s origin, but the first known recipe was found in Ginny Bower’s basement back in 1947. The Bower family had sent it into an old magazine, and it had actually gained traction for a while. People from all over New England came to Oakview to try Aunt Ginny’s Black Pepper Ice Cream. Cami wouldn’t say it out loud for fear of being blackballed, but she thought it tasted kind of like sugary seaweed.

The peace that their small town had come to take for granted was shattered a little less than a month ago. A jogger had placed a frantic 9-1-1 call to alert them to a seemingly unconscious woman lying facedown in the woods. The freak March nor’easter had left her covered in nearly a foot of snow.

Cami had been promoted to Detective II years earlier, and while that sounded like a prestigious promotion, she would quickly remind herself that there was a total of seventeen employees in the entire law enforcement agency. She had investigated many crimes over the years, the worst of them being a hit-and-run that had taken place on Main Street. When the call from the jogger had come in, Cami had an eerie premonition that this one might not have been as innocuous as the crimes she was used to investigating.

Sure enough, the woman that had appeared to be unconscious was dead. A single bullet hole in the back of her head had betrayed the notion that she was simply lying there, blissfully asleep. There was no evidence of robbery or sexual assault or anything else that led to a motive or a suspect. The town had grieved for her while promising to bring her killer to justice. Things like that just didn’t happen in Oakview.

The only thing they had to go on was a wooden alphabet block that was found in her pocket. Sandy-colored wood with a bright green T on its front. It didn’t appear to be from a collection in her house, she didn’t have children or grandchildren, and she didn’t teach, so it was just another dead end.

“I was just going over the cell phone reports again. All sorts of pings around town and then nothing after three o’clock that afternoon. Either she turned it off, which is unlikely since prior to that day, she never turned her phone off, or the killer made her turn it off. Which means she had to be in one of these places with him. Or her.” Cami scrunched up her face, forcing herself to see something that wasn’t there. A missing puzzle piece.

Kelsey sighed. “We’ve gone over those reports about a hundred times. Nothing new is going to suddenly appear. Go home, Cam.”

Cami shook her head. “I know. Everyone in her orbit has a rock-solid alibi, and she didn’t have any enemies that we know of. Did her mom call again today?”

“Every day. Nothing like telling an eighty-something-year-old that we’re still coming up empty. Today, she asked me to reach out to the Los Angeles PD since she was sure they could help. It’s so damn sad.”

“I just need some coffee. I’ll go home in a little bit, I promise,” Cami said. She was probably lying, but if her head felt any fuller, she really might have to pack it up and head home.

Kelsey nodded, pursing her lips. Cami knew she didn’t believe her, but she didn’t care. Work was her refuge, and even when she wasn’t feeling great, it was still better than sitting at home forcing herself to read a book or focusing on a movie that she had no interest in.

Cami shook the cobwebs from her head and plodded to the kitchen. She grabbed a pumpkin spice K-Cup from the cabinet and brewed herself a steaming hot cup in Kelsey’s Shh…there’s wine in here mug. Pumpkin spice never went out of season in New Hampshire.

Pulling her blazer a little tighter, Cami sat back down and yawned. She flipped through the notes on her desk, vowing to be more organized with administrative duties. She knew she had a few meetings coming up, but she couldn’t remember when or why. She stacked the papers neatly and reread the one on top. Ugh. She had that meeting with some journalist the following day. She’d tried everything she could think of to get out of it, but the captain insisted that she take the meeting. The mayor wanted transparency, and a restless public wanted answers. Cami understood the motive behind the monthly reports that the mayor had requested, and she even agreed with it. She just didn’t want to be the one to do it.

Public speaking and the press were the only drawbacks to becoming a detective. Cami knew it was all part of the job when she’d applied for it, but the kind of detective work that she was usually involved in didn’t require much more than an email or a quick phone call to the paper. Kelsey was a Detective I—and a patrol officer since there was barely enough work for one detective on the Oakview force—why couldn’t she do it?

“You’re direct and to the point,” Captain Brandt had told her. “You’re the one with the experience here, not Kelsey. You’ve got, what, almost twenty years to her ten? The people want to hear from a face they know and trust.”

“They know Kelsey, too,” Cami had grumbled, petulant. But she had seen from the captain’s face that the decision had been made.

Cami cracked her neck a few times before settling into the phone records again. Her head felt like a balloon about to detach from her body. The tiny numbers and locations began to blend together. She sighed dramatically and shoved them back in her drawer. Maybe it was time to call it a day.

She locked her office door and called out a couple of quick good-byes. Kelsey waved to her smugly.

Cami shoved another cough drop into her mouth to try to quell the scratchy throat that had been plaguing her since lunchtime. She checked her phone to see that she’d missed a call from her aunt, who was probably just checking to see how she was feeling. Earlier that day, one of the administrative assistants had told Cami that she’d seen her aunt at the Market Basket over by the bakery. They’d discussed the squelchy brakes in Cami’s police cruiser as well as her red, puffy eyes.

Cami couldn’t do much but smirk and shake her head. Privacy was all but nonexistent in Oakview.

As she pulled into her designated parking spot in the back of her brick apartment building, Cami could feel a sneeze coming on. She fumbled with her glove compartment and found an ancient pack of tissues shoved in the back. Stuck on the back of it was a small round sticker that read, Sunkist Navel 3307. Cami took out a tissue and threw the pack back into the glove box. No matter how certain she was that she’d purged Alicia from every facet of her life, every once in a while, something would pop up. Cami hated oranges.

Eh, just confirmation that it was probably time to get a new car. Not that she would ever do that. Her Jeep was her baby.

She unlocked the door to her apartment and tossed her keys on the kitchen table. It was quiet, and the sun was setting. She could see tiny dust motes swirling around the living room, mocking her. She quickly undressed and left her clothes in a pile on the floor. She crawled into her messy bed and was asleep within minutes.

 

Chapter Two

A Knox County teen had his phone ripped from his hands by a thief on a bicycle, but it wasn’t the easy getaway that the perpetrator had envisioned—the teen was livestreaming on TikTok when

 

Alicia Flynn jumped at the sound of the train whistle. She’d only been in her new place for a few weeks, but she thought she’d be used to it by now. Her home office was just about complete, in the small second bedroom that she’d painted gray with a brown accent wall to give the feeling of an old-timey private investigator’s office. All that she was missing was a green-rimmed visor and a cigar.

Spring had been threatening to make an appearance for the last several weeks, but it seemed to have finally arrived. Her window was cracked open, even though it was after eight o’clock, and darkness blanketed her regular view of trees and train tracks. She pulled her ponytail out of its worn elastic and plucked a strand of hair from the shoulder of her T-shirt. Upon inspection, it was dark brown, not gray. Good.

Alicia swiveled back and forth in her chair to get back into the groove of her article. It would be her first byline with the Knox County Sun since she’d left nearly three years ago. They said you couldn’t go home again, and Alicia wondered if there was more truth to that than she’d been willing to acknowledge.

It had been wonderful seeing her brother, sister-in-law, and nieces and nephew after being away for so long. She’d come back for holidays before, but that was pretty much it. Her parents had been overjoyed to have her back for good this time. Finding a place in Oakview had been fairly easy, even if it wasn’t in the quietest of locations. But there was a black cloud that hung over her like an overfilled bubble of guilt, where the slightest provocation would cause it to burst and douse her in the regret she’d so deftly compartmentalized.

Cami.

Even thinking her name gave Alicia a pit in her stomach. When it had finally hit her, not long after landing in a strange place, and she had to think about—feel—how she had left things, she’d decided she would make things right. She had calmed her rising panic by talking herself into the notion that she could make up for the chaos she’d caused. She’d apologize to Cami for leaving the way she had, she’d call up her friends and family, and things could hopefully just go back to normal but with Alicia’s newfound sense of appreciation for the world around her. Or something like that.

She still couldn’t explain why she’d originally left, not really. She’d been spending so much time on social media and covering national politics and every other world crisis of the day that she’d just had enough. Facing her inevitable mortality, the state of humanity, and an overwhelming sense of unimportance had pushed her to the edge. It was vague and formulaic, but it was the only explanation she had. She wished she’d had something more concrete, something meatier to share with her family, and eventually, Cami, but the epiphany she’d been expecting while sitting alone on a secluded beach watching gentle waves lap at the sand had never come. She’d still felt the same, maybe just a little less…muddled. The profound insight she’d been seeking had eluded her.

Texting Cami had become a nightly ritual that she’d attempt but ultimately fail. I’m sorry sounded trite. I didn’t mean it sounded empty. I’ll always love you sounded vapid. She’d pulled up the message box and typed something, deleted it, and then continued that ad nauseam until she’d eventually tossed her phone onto her nightstand and fall into a fitful sleep. She’d left voice mail after voice mail, pouring her heart out, trying to get Cami to respond. Sometimes, they were sad and full of longing; other times, they were chipper, and she’d recounted happy memories. Cami had never called her back.

Not long before her journey was scheduled to end, she’d realized she hadn’t planned for the after. Alicia wasn’t the most organized and cautious person, but she wouldn’t have called herself impetuous, either. Clearly, she was. She needed something solid to return to. She’d been too ashamed to ask for her job back, and she really didn’t want to live with her parents. She certainly couldn’t move back to her old apartment with Cami. She was pretty confident that Cami hated her, and she didn’t have much justification for Cami to not hate her. She’d acted selfishly. Alicia knew that. All of her attempts to contact Cami had gone unanswered, so she’d known that she wouldn’t be able to simply ease back into her old life as she’d imagined. She’d become adept at compartmentalizing her emotions so she didn’t have to feel the full weight of her grief.

“Come stay with me,” Alicia’s cousin Leila had shouted when Alicia had told her the predicament she’d been in. “I’m only ten minutes from Boston. There are tons of journalist jobs around here.”

“Tons” of jobs had been an exaggeration, but Alicia was still intrigued by the idea. It was the only option she felt she had. She’d worked for the local paper, Knox County Sun, but before that, she’d been mostly freelancing while working for a few different pop culture websites. The pay wasn’t great, but the work was interesting. Reviewing movies and testing out video games had been like a dream come true.

She’d ended up taking a job with a Boston-based college in the external affairs department. Living with Leila had been a huge adjustment, but she was happy to have someone to talk to without the baggage of home. She’d kept Cami pinned to the top of her text message “favorites,” even though the last thirty messages were all one-sided.

Renewing her friendships hadn’t been as easy as she’d thought it would be either. Sure, her friends were Cami’s friends, but she didn’t think they’d hold her nihilistic crisis behavior against her until the end of time. She was wrong. Aside from a couple of cold texts, there wasn’t much to go on. The phone calls hadn’t been much better. Violet had made small talk with her, welcomed her back to New England. Said she’d be in touch so they could plan a dinner date. Never happened. Katie had cut right to the chase.

Alicia cringed as the conversation replayed in her head:

“Alicia? Wow, I’m surprised to hear from you,” Katie had said.

“I know. It’s good to be back, though. I’ve missed you guys so much,” Alicia had told her, wondering why she’d thought calling Katie out of the blue had been a good idea. “How are things?”

“Fine. Does Cami know you’re back?”

“I don’t think so, I haven’t talked to her—”

“What you did was really shitty. I didn’t know if she was going to get through it. God, the crying, the wondering, the not knowing…it wasn’t good.”

Alicia had stood there with the phone up to her ear, stunned and silent. Was she really that out of touch? Obviously. “I…I know. I shouldn’t have sprung it on her the way that I did. I never meant to hurt her. I was going through something that I didn’t know how to deal with.” Trying to explain it had made it seem even worse.

“Did you ever consider reaching out to me before you up and left the country? Or Taryn? Or Violet? We had no idea anything was wrong. No one did. I get that you were going through something, but you ghosted all of us. We had to pick up the pieces, comforting her and providing explanations that we basically had to make up. We were mourning the loss of you, too, for reasons none of us understood.”

Alicia had opened her mouth to speak, but nothing had come out. She’d felt tears spring to her eyes but blinked them away. Katie, who was usually the pragmatic one, tackled issues logically and calmly, so her tone and palpable anger had surprised Alicia.

Katie wasn’t finished. “And how long have you been back? Obviously, they don’t have phones or internet in Australia. Otherwise, you could have called or texted, but it’s been well over six months, and I’m just hearing from you now?”

Alicia had cleared her throat. “I wanted to settle back in before I reached out. To make sure I was in the right headspace before calling. I’ve left so many messages for Cami, but she hasn’t returned my calls. I’m staying just outside of Boston and—”

“I didn’t realize you needed to be in the ‘right headspace’ to have a conversation with me.”

If she’d known how the phone call was going to go, Alicia probably would have put a little more thought into the whole headspace thing. “Katie, I really am sorry, but I had to make this about me. I felt suffocated by the open air, and I didn’t know how to deal with it.”

“Just don’t, Alicia. You know I’m all about self-care and putting yourself first. It’s the way you went about it. Just up and leaving like that without any notice or warning or anything. It was cold, and it was selfish. But like you said, you had to do what you had to do. Enjoy Boston.”

The soft beeps following Katie’s last word had confirmed that she’d hung up. Alicia had thrown her phone on the bed. She’d allowed herself to cry, the tears a mixture of anger and regret and a sprinkling of resentment, warranted or not. She’d done what she’d done. No second chance to do it the right way.

She’d wiped the moisture from her cheeks and picked her phone back up. She’d shot off another text to Cami this time, willing herself to just suck it up and contact her again, even though everything up to this point had gone unanswered. Let her rant and rave and yell at her, and maybe she could eventually forgive her. Just let her say something.

It’s me. Can we talk? Please?

Simple, but to the point. She’d kept eyeing her phone while trying to occupy herself with other things, waiting for the unmistakable chime of a reply.

It had never come.

Sitting at the desk in her little room in Oakview now, watching the cursor flash in her unfinished article, Alicia forced herself out of her reverie. Maybe she shouldn’t have come back here.

No, she told herself, everything will work out, one way or another. She wanted to be closer to her family, especially since her dad had been diagnosed with prostate cancer. He’d had the offending organ removed and was going to be okay, but it had made Alicia realize how precious and fleeting life could be. She wanted to be closer to her family and the town that she’d called home for so long. She didn’t even necessarily have to interact with Cami or Katie or any of her old circle. The town was small, yes, but she was a grown-up and could nod curtly if she ran into any of them in the supermarket.

She hadn’t seen Cami in the short time that she’d been back, but she felt like she would be able to handle it. Enough time had passed. She missed her something fierce, and she’d played the night that she left over and over in her head. She’d gone on a few dates in the time since they’d split up, but since all she did was compare them to Cami, they were doomed from the start. That little jump in her stomach every time she’d see Cami walk into a room, even after being together for so long. That way Cami would gaze lovingly into her eyes while they whispered to each other in the soft darkness of their bedroom.

Why did I leave? Why did I leave her?

Alicia shook her head, forcing the thought away. Obviously, Cami had moved on, rightfully so, but Alicia did wish she’d had the chance to explain that her leaving truly wasn’t about Cami or anything she had done. It might not have mattered, but she still wished Cami knew.

She looked at her calendar, the next day circled in bright red marker. Her stomach flip-flopped. Alicia might get her chance after all.

 

Chapter Three

The screaming alarm caused Cami to bolt upright in panic. She didn’t usually need an alarm; her body was so accustomed to waking up at seven thirty a.m., she awoke naturally. But since she had to meet that reporter at the diner for eight o’clock, she’d set her phone to blare some hard rock at seven. She fumbled for the stop button and flopped back on her pillow. Thirty minutes of sleep deprivation felt like a lifetime.

Sighing, Cami slid out of bed and turned on the shower. She let the hot water pulse over her shoulders while she longed for the days of catching kids carving their initials in trees and giving them lectures about the environment. Her town, and the memories she cherished, felt almost tainted now. She wasn’t looking forward to providing what amounted to a thimbleful of information to the crime reporter that the Knox County Sun felt like they’d needed to hire. Times were changing.

By the time she arrived at the Crumbly Biscuit, the parking lot was full, and the tables were crowded. She could barely entertain the idea of a bagel, and these people were having three course meals. Cami scanned the restaurant, looking for someone sitting alone, but she didn’t see anyone. Since she hadn’t taken the call personally, she realized she probably should have asked for more info, specifically, a name. The captain had just told her it was the new crime reporter, and the Sun had said the optics would be better if they could meet at a neutral place.

Cami found an empty booth by a back window and sat. There were muffin crumbs on the table, so she used the side of her hand to swipe them into a napkin. Yuck. She fumbled with the napkin holder to pluck out another one, but they were packed in tight. She struggled to pull out a full one instead of the tiny pieces that kept breaking off.

“Detective Lyons.”

Cami turned quickly and stood. “Yes, sorry—” She stood there, frozen to the spot next to the table. She couldn’t quite bring herself to close her open mouth, though she was aware that no words were coming out.

Alicia was standing across from her wearing a gray suit and small gold hoops in her ears. Cami focused on her earrings. She didn’t remember Alicia having pierced ears. She assumed that pierced ears were something she would have noticed in their six years together.

Alicia swallowed. “Cami, hi. Hi. I’m sure you’re wondering what I’m doing here.” She licked her lips and swallowed again. Her nervousness had always been pretty transparent.

“Are you the reporter they sent?” Cami asked. Her voice sounded like it was coming from someone else. From a tunnel far, far away.

“I am. I was afraid if they told you who you were meeting with, you would have said no, so I was purposely vague.”

She could feel her blood returning to its normal state, and it flooded her face with vigor. “I would have.”

Alicia seemed to falter. “I know, I’m sorry for the ambush. I shouldn’t have…we can get right into it if you want and catch up later.”

“I think I’m actually going to go.” She pointed to the exit. “I’m sure Kelsey can meet with you at some point.”

“Please don’t go,” Alicia said quickly. “We can do this quick. The town needs to know what’s going on. Captain Brandt even said on the call that you would be the best person to interview. Please don’t take whatever it is you feel toward me out on the people you serve.”

Cami scoffed. Nice attempt at manipulating her sense of duty to the town. “Please. If it’s really the story you’re after, you can meet with a number of people who know what’s going on. This is obviously not just about that.”

Still awkwardly facing her, Alicia gestured to the booth. “Just sit with me for five minutes. Then you can go, and I won’t try to stop you. I promise.”

The desperation in her eyes was evident. Years of heartache and confusion and self-doubt came back in an instant. Cami wanted nothing more than to get out of there, but her curiosity was piqued, and her heart felt like it was frozen in her chest. She rubbed her cheek absentmindedly and sat. “You have five minutes. What do you want to know?”

Alicia sat, her relief visible. Cami stared while she pulled out a notebook. She knew her eyes were boring into Alicia, but she couldn’t look away. She was seeing a ghost. Why was Alicia back in Oakview? Why now? She tried to assess her feelings, seeing the woman she’d loved for such a long time across from her now, a stranger. There were no feelings to assess. Cami was numb, and her chest felt tight, and her silky button-up blouse was choking her, even though the first two buttons were undone.

A server approached the table as Alicia clicked her ballpoint pen and tucked her hair behind her ear. Cami found herself staring again until the server interrupted. “Are you ready to order?”

“Can I just get an iced coffee, two creams, two sugars?” Alicia asked.

Cami could have mouthed the order along with her. Funny how certain things stuck.

“Well, the cream and sugar is on the table. For you?”

Silence ensued. It took Cami a few seconds to realize the server was speaking to her. “Uh, yeah, I’ll have the same. Thanks.”

“Again, cream and sugar is on the table. Two iced coffees,” the server said. She sounded annoyed, but Cami was pretty sure that was just part of the job description.

“Still drinking iced coffee, huh?” Alicia asked, smiling.

Cami didn’t smile back. She’d been a hot coffee purist before meeting Alicia, but Alicia had worn her down over the years. Against her better judgment, Cami had ended up ordering iced more often than not. It was pretty damn refreshing.

“What do you want to know?” she asked again.

“Right. Well, what can you tell me about the uptick of crime in town, as well as the murder? Can I record this?” Alicia positioned her phone in between them.

“No.”

“Okay,” Alicia whispered softly. She put the phone back in her bag.

“There hasn’t been an ‘uptick’ in crime. Statistically, we’re in about the same place as we were last year, and in some cases, lower than last year. There’s just more awareness of what’s happening in the community with the advent of that NeighborTakes app. Seems like the whole town is on it. We’ve deployed a few more police officers to patrol the neighborhoods, which has had a direct impact on property damage and vandalism. We’re committed to putting the town’s tax dollars to work in a meaningful way.” Cami tried to make sure she regurgitated all the points the captain had wanted her to hit on. She’d felt good about her talking points before walking into the nightmare that sat before her. Now she couldn’t even be sure what she’d said was accurate.

“And what about Beverly Lawson? Are you any closer to catching her killer than you were a week ago?”

Cami heard the words, but they were taking their time sinking in. The whole scene still felt surreal. “We haven’t reached any definite conclusions. We are still combing through evidence, speaking with witnesses, and making sure we leave no stone unturned. It would be premature to discuss things like means or motive.”

“Understood.” Alicia wrote in the same flowery hand that Cami remembered. “Do you believe it was a targeted killing? Does the public have any reason to fear that an indiscriminate killer is on the loose?”

“As I said, answering those questions would be premature. But I can say that the Oakview Police Department is doing everything in our power to make sure the residents of this community are safe,” Cami said.

“Got it. Did the killer leave behind any physical evidence? Have you checked to see if there have been any other murders in New Hampshire or anywhere, for that matter, that seem to have the same MO?”

“If you’re asking about patterns or calling cards or anything like that, we have an active investigation going on, and there are details that I can’t divulge.” Cami focused on the iced coffee the server had dropped off. She was about four creamers in when Alicia spoke up.

“I didn’t think you liked it that light,” she said.

Cami didn’t, but she’d been so focused on focusing that she’d lost track. “Yeah, well, things change.” She took a long swallow that tasted a lot like iced half and half.

Alicia bristled. “Yes, they do. Sorry. Anyway. Is there anything else you want to say here? I don’t want to make it seem like the Oakview PD is sidestepping.”

“I’ve told you what I can tell you. Unless you’d like me to make something up, I think we’re done here.” Cami took out a few dollars to pay for her coffee. If Alicia thought she was going to cover the bill, she was mistaken. She’d be damned if she was indebted to Alicia for a sip of rainwater, never mind a coffee.

“Listen, Cami. I know this is weird, but I just want to tell you how sorry I am. I’ve tried to reach out to you so many times. I’ve been waiting for this moment for years. Can we just have a conversation?” Alicia asked, reaching out to place her hand on top of Cami’s.

Cami snatched her hand back. “Nope. I don’t know why you’re back, and frankly, I don’t care. I’m not going to be a stop on your rehabilitation tour, so you can scratch me right off that list. It’s been three years, Alicia. Let it go. I have.” She grabbed her keys from the table and walked toward the exit door that had a little bell above it that tinkled sweetly when anyone walked in or out. Cami contemplated shooting it with her service weapon but decided that would probably be seen unfavorably by the other diners.

Fuck Alicia and whatever amends she was seeking. Fuck her for dropping back in after all this time and thinking Cami was just going to welcome her with open arms to have a drippy conversation about the way things had ended or the way things should have been. Fuck Alicia for going halfway around the world and leaving Cami behind like a lost sock. Fuck her and fuck it.

She slid behind the wheel of her Jeep and closed her eyes. She took a few deep breaths, trying to ground herself. She was parked next to a shiny blue Prius, and she just fucking knew that it was Alicia’s. Cami had been driving the same military-green Jeep Wrangler for nearly a decade, so Alicia had parked next to her on purpose. Of course she did.

Alicia exited the restaurant and headed in her general direction. At one time, Alicia’s predictability had been one of Cami’s favorite things about her. But then she’d upended everything and thrown all dependability out the window. Cami started her ignition and nearly peeled out of the parking lot. Fuck her.