Chapter One

“Camp Rewind?” Alice Wu stared at the cheerful brochure her therapist had just pushed into her hands, instinctively dubious that a sleep-away camp for grown-ups could offer even one answer to her many problems. “This is because I told you I wished my parents had sent me off to camp like a normal kid instead of forcing me to study next year’s schoolwork and practice cello in my bedroom all day, every summer. Isn’t it?”

Her therapist, a wonderful woman named Dawn Jackson whom she’d located via an online search only thirty minutes after being served divorce papers by her ex-husband, combatted Alice’s negative tone with a sunny smile. “Looks like fun, don’t you think?”

As usual, Dawn managed to radiate such genuine good cheer that, despite her anxiety, Alice couldn’t help but return her smile. “It looks…interesting.”

“And fun.” Dawn clasped her hands together on her lap and established eye contact, a sign that she was trying to make a serious point. “Alice, we’ve been meeting once a week for almost a year now. Again and again, you’ve made it clear that you blame the lack of opportunities you had to interact with other kids during your so-called ‘non-childhood’ for the social anxiety you feel now. I know the idea of a summer camp for grown-ups is intimidating, but you’ve made real strides over the past few months, even if it doesn’t always feel that way. Camp Rewind is an opportunity to interact with your peers in an environment that’s not only ideal for making new friends, but which also happens to encompass exactly what you missed growing up. Sounds perfect, doesn’t it?”

Alice studied a glossy photo of two women and a man standing next to one another at an archery range, arrows nocked, aiming at targets some distance away. Her stomach churned at the thought of subjecting herself to a week of unfamiliar activities with strange people. According to the brochure, in addition to archery, the camp offered volleyball, arts-and-crafts activities, horseback riding, swimming, boating, nighttime campfires, and what they called a “drunk field day.” “Bring your own booze?” She skimmed the rest of the text. “You know I’m not a drinker. I’m not going to become a drinker just to fit in.”

“Drinking isn’t required.” Dawn’s tone, like always, remained calm and modulated in counterpoint to Alice’s rising anxiety. “It’s an option, since this is a getaway for adults, but I’m confident you wouldn’t be the only person to choose not to imbibe. Plenty of people will go simply to bask in the nostalgia, or perhaps to experience a piece of a childhood they never had. Like you.” She paused. “Believe me, I know how frightening this sounds. But doesn’t some part of you want to go?” She pointed at a photo of two women laughing and appearing full of joy while sitting side by side in a paddleboat. “Don’t you want this for yourself?”

The image blurred as Alice’s eyes filled with tears, which spilled over and ran down her cheeks before she could force away the emotional maelstrom triggered by the pointed question. “Of course I do. I want to be happy. To have friends, a boyfriend, or…whatever. You know that.”

“Yes, I do.” Dawn softened her voice. “I know, too, how scary it is to imagine putting yourself out there like I’m suggesting. But, darling, if you want to change your life, you’ve got to do the work.”

“I understand that, really, but this feels like learning to swim by jumping into the Bering Sea.” Alice turned the brochure over in her hands before hurriedly passing it back to Dawn. She couldn’t possibly spend four days and three excruciating nights in the company of total strangers. What if everyone hated her? Or ignored her altogether? “Can’t I try something a little less intense at first? Like, an event that lasts only a few hours?”

“You can do whatever you want.” Dawn set the brochure on the arm of her chair, still within Alice’s line of sight. “I certainly can’t force you into anything. You’re an adult. You make your own decisions. That said, I believe you’re ready for this. I really do.”

Dawn’s words stirred up a whole lot of complex feelings, likely as intended. At thirty-six years old, Alice didn’t have all that much experience making decisions for herself. Her parents—particularly her mother—had dictated her entire life, including her daily schedule, until she was twenty-one years old. That was when her then-college boyfriend, now ex-husband, managed to secure her father’s blessing to propose marriage, freeing her from one prison to live in another. John, her ex, was a brilliant engineer, as well as a narcissist and control freak. Though she’d accompanied him to work and family events, and occasionally, in the beginning, out with friends, she’d spent most of her married life alone at home, isolated from the outside world. She read a lot. Tinkered with her own engineering pet projects. Fantasized about being a happier person, more normal, more socially adept. More loved.

It wasn’t that John explicitly forbade her from having friends. He simply hadn’t cared to include his painfully shy wife in his plans, more often than not, and she felt too socially awkward to even attempt to meet people outside of work on her own. Now that they were divorced, the loneliness had become too much to bear. She was desperate for a social life, but her first few efforts had been near-to-complete disasters: one Internet date with an attractive firefighter who’d reacted to her obvious case of nerves by immediately losing interest, an evening at a social painting event where she’d frozen up and seemingly rebuffed a very nice woman who’d tried to engage her in small talk, and two meetings of a local book club where she’d failed to work up the courage to contribute beyond a mumbled introduction. That had been starting small, hadn’t it? Why would Camp Rewind be any different for a hopeless dork like her?

“What are you thinking?” Dawn’s low, soothing voice interrupted her headfirst plummet into self-flagellation.

The tears started to flow again, which only added to the immense shame Alice already felt. “I’ve already tried less-intense activities, haven’t I? And failed. I don’t know how to talk to people. I freeze up, stutter, lose my words…even mix them up or run them together, sometimes. So why would attending a summer camp that will not only force me to interact with a bunch of people I don’t know, but also sleep in their presence, work out better than what I’ve already attempted?”

Dawn scooted to the edge of her chair and extended her hands. After a brief hesitation, Alice took them. Squeezing gently, Dawn murmured, “I can’t promise it will. What I can promise you is that this is exactly the sort of experience you feel would have benefited you as a child. Would have changed your life, I believe you said.”

Alice had made that foolish statement two sessions ago. Now she wished she hadn’t. She’d been so certain, at the time. I guarantee that if my mother had let me spend even one summer at camp like a normal kid instead of locking me away in my bedroom to become the perfect student and musician—a daughter she could take pride in—I wouldn’t struggle so hard to make friends today. Just one week in the summer having fun with other kids my age…would have changed my entire life. Scowling, Alice realized that she couldn’t deny how much importance she’d arbitrarily placed on the notion of a traditional summer-camp experience. “I was being silly. A few days of arts and crafts and drunken three-legged races has never really changed anyone’s life.”

Dawn clucked her tongue. “I wouldn’t be so sure about that.”

Alice allowed herself to imagine actually going, for a moment. “But what if…” To her absolute horror, the tears that had recently subsided threatened to return on the back of a single, humiliating thought. “What if I don’t make any friends?”

Once again, Dawn squeezed her hands. “I have faith that you can and will. You’re intelligent, attractive, and quite funny, once you’re able to relax. There’s plenty for you to talk about and potentially connect with someone on: your robotics career, your garden, music, the trip you took to China last year to meet your father’s family for the first time.” After a moment of obvious hesitation, she added, “To be perfectly candid, I’m told there are usually plenty of opportunities for casual romance at camp, if you were interested in that sort of thing. I know you’re lonely, and you’ve said you’re curious about whether you could enjoy physical intimacy with someone who isn’t John. This could be a safe place to explore that area of your life as a single woman. If it’s a fling you’re after, I can’t imagine you won’t find a willing partner. Even if you are a little quiet in the beginning.” Dawn winked.

“Yeah. Maybe I’ll meet someone who enjoys their women silent and frozen in fear,” Alice muttered. “Which, let’s admit, would be astoundingly creepy.”

Dawn laughed and let go of Alice’s hands. “Oh, I have more faith in you than that. You’ve learned to talk to me, right? It took you only two sessions to find your voice. First day at camp, you look around, find the friendliest face there, and pretend you’re talking to me. Even if you don’t come out of the weekend with a real friendship, I highly doubt that anyone will be outright mean to you. It may be called Camp Rewind, but these are adult men and women we’re talking about. There might be one or two jerks in the crowd—there always is, right?—but I’m positive most everyone will play nice.”

Alice swallowed against the boulder that had lodged in her throat. “I’ll probably be the only one who shows up alone.”

“I wouldn’t be so sure about that, either.” Dawn picked up the brochure, drawing Alice’s attention to the cover for the umpteenth time. Ideal for singles, couples, and platonic groups of nostalgia-seekers! “But even if you are the only one who shows up alone, many adults want to go to a camp like this to make new friends the way they did when they were young. The brochure talks about that at length. You’re not the only grown-up who hasn’t had recent practice in the art of meeting people. For many, it’s a real struggle to form new friendships after graduating from school.”

Wasn’t that the truth? Alice’s last friendship, which had been admittedly superficial and largely based on the fact that she and Lin were the only two women in their class following a robotics engineering track, ended when she graduated from college and became John’s wife. Since then, she’d yearned for another female friend—a real one, like she read about in books or saw on television—but hadn’t any clue where to find someone like that. Was it possible Camp Rewind really could be the answer?

Maybe I should go.

“If you hate it, you can always leave.” Dawn reassured her with a smile. “The cool part about being a grown-up at camp is that you’ll have your own car. You can drive yourself right the hell home, whenever you want.”

“That’s true.” Alice flicked her gaze again to the brochure in Dawn’s hands. She sighed. “I’m sorry. As much as I want to try, I honestly can’t see myself going through with this.”

“Well, then that’s the problem.” Dawn handed the brochure back to her, and Alice took it without thinking. “Close your eyes with me.”

Having learned to trust Dawn’s methods—especially when they didn’t involve communal sleeping arrangements or cavorting with groups of attractive strangers—Alice did as instructed. “Now what?”

“Imagine yourself arriving at camp. Parking. Getting out of your car, pulling your suitcase from the trunk, finding the main office where you’ll give your name to check in.”

Eyes tightly shut, Alice was already struggling not to vomit. “I feel sick.”

“Breathe. In, out.” Dawn inhaled and exhaled audibly. Alice matched her rhythm, and after a few breaths, as her stomach began to settle, Dawn went on. “Now picture yourself meeting someone—a friend or something more—and having the time of your life. What that might feel like, how much confidence you would gain. How happy you would be.”

Alice let the fantasy carry her away, but not for long. She’d yearned for true companionship as far back as she could remember, but thinking about the subject stirred up vague, confusing, unsettling desires that she didn’t know how to address. Forcing back those thoughts before they could take hold and prey on her emotions, she opened her eyes and pinned Dawn with a hard look. “I don’t want to talk about this anymore today.”

Dawn’s expression faded, ever so slightly, into disappointment. “Like I said, Alice, I can’t make you do anything you don’t want to.”

More than almost anything, Alice hated to disappoint. She blamed her mother for that. Guts twisted, she mumbled, “Sorry.”

“There’s no need to apologize. But will you do me a favor?”

Alice sniffled. “Maybe.”

That earned her a chuckle. “Take the brochure home. Go online and do a search for more information. Think about it, sincerely. Optimistically.”

Full of dread, Alice stared again at the brochure that had made its way back to her hands. “All right.”

“Nobody will force you to go.”

Good. She nodded. “I understand.”

“You’ll have to make the choice yourself.” Dawn caught her gaze, forcing eye contact. “All I can do, Alice, as your therapist and someone who genuinely cares about you, is strongly advise that you consider enrolling in the upcoming session. You can’t overcome your fears until you confront them. After all the good work you’ve done during the past year, it’s time to take the next step. I have no doubt that you’re ready for this. You’re ready to be happy.”

She was ready. Except when she wasn’t. Alice cursed under her breath, fighting the urge to rip the Camp Rewind brochure to shreds. It would be better than succumbing to the full-body sobs threatening to take over. If only the happiness she so desperately wanted would simply…happen to her. Unfortunately, as Dawn never hesitated to point out, life didn’t work that way. If she wanted to be happy, she had to do her part. She had to try.

“Fine,” Alice muttered. When she saw the degree to which Dawn’s eyes lit up, she clarified her point. “I’ll go online. Check it out. Think about it.”

Dawn beamed at her as though she’d already signed up. “I’m proud of you.”

“I didn’t say I was going.” Alice frowned. Why did it feel like she had?

Dawn’s expression of deep satisfaction never wavered. “You can let me know what you’ve decided next week. We’ll talk about coping mechanisms and the cognitive behavioral tools for dealing with your anxiety in a camp-like setting. We can also role-play introducing ourselves to one another and making small talk.”

As much as she hated the way Dawn always managed to push her exactly where she didn’t want to go, she was also grateful. A little. Maybe. Stomach aching, Alice heaved a sigh and buried her face in her hands.

“Want to spend our last couple minutes together telling me how much you hate my suggestions? That usually seems to make you feel better.” Dawn sounded amused. Good for her.

Alice shook her head. “Not this time.”

She did hate the suggestion, of course. A summer camp for grown-ups sounded like the perfect social hell. Unfortunately, it also kind of, sort of, sounded like fun.

And it was probably, as much as she hated to admit it, exactly what she needed.


 

Chapter Two

Rosa Salazar parked her brand-new-to-her-but-used car in an empty spot in the corner of Camp Rewind’s gravel parking lot, as far from the main office as she could get. Then, hands shaking, she slipped on her sunglasses and checked her appearance in the mirror. She was still struggling to get used to her recently bobbed haircut, a dramatic change from the long, dark locks she’d treasured since adolescence. She hoped the sacrifice had been worth it and that nobody would recognize her during this first tentative step back into the land of the living after a year and a half in Internet-induced hell.

As was her habit, Rosa glanced at her phone despite the fact that she’d vowed to stop doing so for the next four days, minimum, at least fifty miles ago. An on-screen notification alerted her to the fact that she’d received three emails during her hours-long drive through the redwoods. One from her mother, full of concern, a short, encouraging note from her best friend Trayvon—one of the few people who’d stuck around after the firestorm she’d unleashed with a single, freelance essay picked up by a popular gaming website—and finally, an anonymous, colorfully detailed rape and death threat bearing the subject line, Die you cunt social justice warrior slut whore.

“Just another day online.” Wearily, Rosa deleted the threatening email and powered down her phone. She was almost numb to such correspondence at this point. Almost. “What a perfect time to unplug.”

She studied her reflection again, trying to judge the likelihood that someone would recognize her. The woman in the mirror looked nothing like the small photo posted alongside her lengthy critique of the previous year’s massively bestselling video game for both its sexist and racist sensibilities, as well as its overreliance on sexually violent imagery to tell a lurid, immature story. She also appeared far older, and less optimistic, than the various snapshots of her younger, carefree, sometimes provocatively posed, college-aged self that her detractors had scraped from every social media account she’d ever created during the ugly, rage-filled aftermath of her essay’s publication, when the Internet reacted to her opinions by creating cruel memes and sometimes downright pornographic images mockingly depicting her face and body. Best of all, she bore very little resemblance to the woman whose solo masturbation video—filmed for and texted to an ex-boyfriend years ago, long before she’d realized how easily cloud storage could be hacked by those determined to ruin someone’s life—had been disseminated online without her consent, swiftly going viral and doing exactly that.

Some days it felt like everyone in the world had seen her naked. Touching herself. Moaning, saying stupid, insipid things. Things she’d never intended for anyone except her ex-boyfriend Marcus to hear. Logically, she knew not everyone followed Internet and social media scandals of the month, but living in the Bay Area, it rarely felt that way.

Even her father had seen the stupid video, the first few seconds at least, after some asshole emailed him the file. And it didn’t happen only once. Both her parents’ inboxes had been so flooded in the beginning that eventually her mother had to change addresses. Her father stopped going online altogether.

Rosa flipped the mirror up, no longer able to stomach the sight of her own face. After the past year and a half, she had a keen understanding of why public shaming persisted as one of the most universal, enduring, devastating forms of punishment known to civilization. It worked. Between her public humiliation and the unrelenting flow of threats promising physical and / or sexual violence, suffering, and even death, she spent most days feeling lower than nothing. Subhuman. A source of endless pain for all the people who cared about her. Those few she had left, at least.

She exhaled. “Enough self-pity.” This whole summer-camp experience was supposed to help her escape her life and return to a simpler time when she wasn’t an object of ridicule and / or someone who incited violent rage the world over. A time when she wasn’t afraid to make a new friend or look a man in the eyes. Camp was about reinventing herself, even if only for a few days.

Here, Rosa Salazar didn’t exist. During her stay at Camp Rewind, she would be Lila Sanchez: high school teacher, technology-phobic thus unfamiliar with Internet culture, interested in socializing only with other women. She didn’t normally close herself off to any possibility for friendship or romance, having dated across the gender spectrum over the years, but between her almost exclusively male online cult of hate and the ex-boyfriend who’d dumped her right before the vicious comments on her article hit critical mass, she was ready to take a break from guys for a while. Besides, women seemed more unlikely to be familiar with the saga of her gaming-induced infamy. A sexist thought, she knew, but likely also the truth.

With a deep, steadying breath, Rosa got out of her car and trudged to the back of it. She hoisted her duffel bag from the trunk, then stopped and glanced around the lot as wave after wave of doubt rolled over her. Two guys who looked to be in their mid-thirties emerged from the front and passenger seats of a souped-up muscle car parked next to the entrance. They both spared her semi-interested glances as she stood rooted in place behind them, and then one slapped the other on the back of the head and took off running. His buddy whooped and sprinted after his friend, both of them acting like twelve-year-old boys instead of grown men pushing forty.

Maybe this was a mistake. She should have gone to a women-only camp, at least, even if the closest one she’d been able to locate was five states away. After being threatened with sexual assault in all its horrific permutations for more than seventeen months, she had a hard time not feeling skittish about the idea of wild, enthusiastic, alcohol-fueled masculinity.

Even as the worries flew through her head, Rosa rejected them. “No.” She slammed the trunk shut and turned to face the office where the men had disappeared. “Fuck everyone. I’m not a victim.”

As far as mantras went, it wasn’t the most elegant or convincing. But it was hers.

As she took her first, tentative steps away from the security of her car, Rosa noticed that she wasn’t the only one experiencing second thoughts. At the other end of the row where she’d parked, a lovely but absolutely petrified-looking woman with dark, shoulder-length hair was white-knuckling her steering wheel while she watched Rosa’s slow march toward the main office. What a relief to see someone who appeared even more anxious than she felt. Rosa smiled at the woman but immediately regretted it when she saw the obvious alarm her attempt at encouragement had caused. The woman’s arm twitched as though she was going to turn the key she’d no doubt left in the ignition, but instead she stared down at her lap, hard.

Rosa glanced away quickly, happy to afford the woman some privacy to battle her nerves. She, more than anyone, appreciated the exquisite agony of being scrutinized in public. Still, she hoped the woman would manage to gather her courage. Now that they’d shared a few seconds of panic in the parking lot of Camp Rewind, Rosa couldn’t help but feel that a kind of bond had been created. Or, at the very least, that she’d identified a promising candidate for a camp friendship. It was impossible to imagine someone so obviously timid passing judgment or making critical, mean-spirited comments to a stranger, though Rosa had certainly been taken by surprise in the past.

Once she reached the camp office, Rosa paused, still tempted to turn around and leave. And go where? When home was no longer a sanctuary and death threats were delivered to her purse, did it really matter where she spent the next three nights? She sighed. In the end, only the thought of the shy woman in the parking lot—and how badly she would need a friend if she ever made it out of her car—imbued Rosa with the strength to go check in.

 

v

 

“Stupid,” Alice muttered to her thighs, still too afraid to raise her head and check if the woman was gone. She tightened her hands into fists, digging her short fingernails into her palms until it hurt. “Can’t even smile back and I’m supposed to spend the next three nights here? Yeah, that’ll be great. Just perfect.”

Frustrated when a fat tear dropped onto one of her balled fists, Alice consciously relaxed her fingers and used the collar of her T-shirt to dab at her face. The only way she could possibly make this situation worse was by giving herself red, crybaby eyes. That’s what her mother had called them, on the few occasions when Alice had failed to keep her emotions in check and wept in her presence. Red, crybaby eyes would embarrass everyone, not least of all Alice. They would draw judgment, criticism, perhaps even mockery. Tears were unacceptable. Inappropriate.

Wrong.

Alice finished dabbing her eyes and peered at her face in the mirror. She looked…mediocre. Her mother had raised her to present herself as perfect as possible in front of others. That meant not only her appearance, which ought to be impeccable, but also her mood, attitude, and intellectual abilities. Alice sighed. No wonder she was so intimidated when she interacted with her peers, why she expected everyone she met to critically assess her and then find her lacking. As a child, she’d been told that’s what would happen, every time, without fail. Dawn kept assuring her that, by and large, most people didn’t care enough to scrutinize strangers for faults, and furthermore, the world was full of kind, open-minded, nonjudgmental people. Rejecting the lessons of her upbringing in favor of a less harsh outlook was a constant struggle, but Alice knew she needed to trust Dawn’s wisdom if she ever wanted to grow.

Girding herself, Alice scanned the parking lot but couldn’t find the woman who’d smiled at her. Evening was fast approaching, and the lot had filled up since Alice had first arrived two hours ago. She assumed most everyone had already checked in. They were likely in their cabins choosing beds right now, which would leave her no option except whatever was left over. With her luck, probably a terrifyingly tall top bunk in the middle of a crowded room. Tonight the camp was hosting an opening ceremony, some kind of group trivia challenge designed to help introductions, then a bonfire scheduled for after sunset, and every last bit of it sounded almost as fun as being waterboarded. Could she really go through with this? She didn’t want to disappoint Dawn by leaving, but this was even more terrifying than she’d anticipated.

Alice steadied her breathing and closed her eyes, then visualized herself getting out of the car and walking into the main office. Pictured the woman who’d smiled at her standing in there, also checking in. Maybe if the whole interaction wasn’t so unexpected, Alice could manage to smile back. With her eyes still closed, she practiced. Imagined the woman—pretty, seemingly friendly—greeting her with an amiable nod, a flash of her teeth. Fantasy-Alice grinned back while real-life Alice ghosted a smile, in case someone was watching. After a moment, she opened her eyes. As the real world flooded back, so did her doubts.

Exhaling, Alice murmured, “Plan B, then.” She opened her glove box and withdrew three hand-rolled cannabis cigarettes she’d brought along in case of emergency. After a lot of research and a little experimentation, she’d discovered that certain strains of the plant helped to calm her anxiety, even enabling her to become more social at times. A toke or two usually had a positive effect, and although she’d had reservations about actually bringing her alternative medication to camp, now it seemed like quite possibly the only thing that would make her brave enough—or at least mellow enough—to walk through that front gate.

She crawled into the backseat and rolled the window halfway down, grateful for the now-deserted parking lot. Lighting up, she took three long drags in slow succession, exhaling each time into a personal air filter so as not to stink up her car or her clothes. When she was done, she carefully extinguished the remainder of the joint and sealed it in a smell-proof container she’d brought along for just that purpose. Once she’d tucked all of her supplies back into her suitcase, she returned to the driver’s seat, leaned back, and let out a sigh of relief as both her body and mind began to relax.

“That’s better.” Alice closed her eyes again, once more picturing the woman who’d smiled at her. She really had been attractive, which was a big part of the reason the friendly gesture had been so frightening. Though Alice had never seriously considered dating women, she couldn’t deny that they figured prominently in her deepest, darkest sexual fantasies. Warm and euphoric from the cannabis, Alice allowed herself to slip into a brief daydream.

She imagined walking into camp, only to be grabbed by the smiling woman and pushed against a tree for a passionate make-out session. She fantasized gaining the sexual confidence to both give and receive pleasure like she never had before and finally behaving like a normal person, capable of doing and feeling the things normal people did and felt.

Alice opened her eyes, glad when the fear didn’t come roaring back. Rather than feel afraid, she felt peaceful yet resolved, albeit frustrated and even a little horny. If she didn’t go inside, she would end up spending the next three nights alone, as always, wishing for more, stupidly, while refusing to go out and grab the opportunities that presented themselves.

If there was one thing Alice wasn’t, it was stupid.

Besides, like Dawn had said, she could simply leave if she didn’t like it here. Because she was a grown-up. With a car of her own.

Feeling anything but grown up, Alice opened the driver’s-side door and got out. One foot in front of the other. She walked around the car, opened the passenger door. Grabbed her suitcase. Shut the door. Stopped to breathe, to steady her legs. To imagine the smiling woman again, this time as a friend. Someone with whom she could share a paddleboat.

Seduced by the thought, Alice defied her own expectations and went inside.


 

Chapter Three

Later that night, Rosa scanned the laughing, jovial faces around the roaring campfire in an effort to find Alice, the shy woman from the parking lot. She knew her name only because Marcia, the exceedingly bubbly head counselor, had forced everyone to introduce themselves during a get-to-know-each-other team trivia challenge they’d played following the opening ceremony. Poor Alice had been visibly stricken to be the center of attention for even a few seconds, barely murmuring her name loud enough for Rosa to hear. As the last camper to check in, Alice had joined them shortly after the ceremony began. Unfortunately, Rosa had been seated at the opposite side of the dining hall and so didn’t get the chance to introduce herself before they were placed on opposing teams for the trivia challenge. After the challenge ended, she watched Alice literally flee from the dining hall, but by the time she made it out the door behind her, she couldn’t see the woman anywhere.

Had she left already? Maybe one forced instance of public speaking had been too much for someone that shy to bear. Rosa’s writer mind whirled with possible explanations for where she’d gone and why she was at camp at all when she appeared far too reserved to enjoy the experience. Despite the handful of friendly interactions Rosa had already enjoyed with fellow campers, she was too intrigued by the mystery that was Alice to focus on anyone else.

Her newfound obsession with introverted Alice might simply be a convenient way to avoid throwing herself into camp social life, but she didn’t care. As far as she knew, Alice was still at camp, too terrified to speak to anyone unless forced and apparently determined to avoid group activities in favor of hiding out on the periphery. If she really was still in the vicinity, Rosa wanted to find and befriend her. Not only to learn her story, but to offer her a boost in confidence, the feeling that she wasn’t totally alone.

Truthfully, Rosa ached for her, knowing how unwelcome certain types of solitude could be.

Circling the bonfire, she drifted away from the raucous, tipsy, celebratory crowd as she fanned out her search. Glad for the big, bright full moon above, she made her way to the women’s cabin but found it empty. Then she walked to the dining hall, where a lone camp employee was sweeping the floor. After that, she made a tense journey to the parking lot, where she discovered, to her relief, Alice’s car still in its spot. So she hadn’t left. Not yet.

Back inside the campgrounds, Rosa walked the same path they’d followed during the orientation tour they’d been given after the trivia game. She’d ventured to the far side of the main campus, almost to the lakeshore, when a familiar smell wafted across her path. Pausing to inhale, Rosa suppressed a chuckle and scanned the dark trees surrounding the trail. If that was Alice, she definitely wanted to be her friend.

Unsure whether to call out and risk making Alice run or startle her by sneaking up, Rosa searched the moonlit trees for some sign of life. She followed her nose a few steps down the trail, then stepped off the path into the woods. A branch snapped beneath her foot, eliciting a startled gasp from behind a nearby tree. Going still, Rosa cursed under her breath, then said in a loud whisper, “Alice?”

She saw something move behind the tree, and then everything went still. It had to be Alice, right? Taking a step closer, Rosa decided to identify herself, only barely remembering to use her fake name. “It’s Lila. From the parking lot. I’m coming over there, so if you wouldn’t mind at least reassuring me that you’re not some B-movie sleep-away camp serial killer…”

“I’m not.” The quiet, shaky voice was unmistakably Alice’s. She said nothing else.

Approaching Alice’s hiding spot like she would a frightened animal, Rosa held up a hand as though preparing to stop her from escaping. “Good. I was hoping to find you. Engaged in my preferred method of social bonding, no less.” She came around the tree in time to see Alice’s mouth twitch into a reluctant smile. When Alice tentatively offered the better half of a smoldering joint, Rosa accepted with a grateful nod. “Thank you.” She attempted to take a hit, but the end had gone cold. Surprised and even a little impressed when Alice smoothly produced a lighter and sparked a flame in front of her face, Rosa grinned as she took a long, deep toke and held it in her lungs until they burned. Exhaling, she said, “Oh, that’s nice. I’m not much of a drinker, to be honest, but this hits the spot.”

Alice took the joint back with a shy half-smile, tipping her head to stare at the ground as she took her own lingering draw. Rosa sensed that she was trying to stall, unable to work up the courage to enter into full-fledged conversation. That was fine. Somehow, Alice’s lack of self-confidence bolstered her own.

“This is nice. Peaceful,” Rosa remarked mildly. She hoped Alice could detect the honesty in her words and understand that she wasn’t mocking her. Anything but. “No pressure to talk.” She took another two hits when Alice gave her the joint again, then a third when Alice waved at her to keep going.

Mid-inhale, Alice briefly caught her eyes and murmured, “You should catch up. Save me from myself.”

Rosa blew a lungful of smoke up to float among the branches of the majestic redwoods towering above. “Does that mean you’re already baked?”

Alice actually giggled. “A little.”

“Is it helping?”

For the first time, Alice looked directly into her eyes. “Apparently.”

Rosa chuckled and passed the joint. “I was a nervous wreck all last week. Nauseated every time I thought about coming here.” She didn’t intend to mention her biggest worry: the possibility of being recognized or, worse, harassed, during what was supposed to be a chance to escape her shitty existence for a few days. It didn’t really matter, the reason for her fears. Alice’s eyes lit up, evidence she’d made a connection. Eager to offer more, Rosa said, “I barely talked myself into checking in. If I hadn’t noticed you sitting in your car looking even more terrified than me, I’m not sure I would have. But I figured we might need each other on the inside, you know, for moral support. So…I’m glad I found you.”

Alice no longer seemed able to meet her gaze. “I’m glad, too.”

“I’m hoping this means I now have someone to sit with in the cafeteria. Because I totally had this nightmare the other day where I was carrying my lunch tray around the dining hall, but all the seats were taken and everyone was staring at me.” Rosa left out the part where they’d started to scream that she was a whore, a cunt, a feminist piece of shit who should go back to where she came from. She figured Alice would get the picture without that level of detail. “So…yeah. It would be a real relief to have a friend here. Someone to help me get through the next few days, to enjoy this experience I really do want to have.”

Alice nodded. “I’d like that.”

Rosa waited, wishing that Alice felt comfortable enough to share a little more. For whatever reason, there was so much she wanted to know about her mysterious new friend. Possibly there was nothing at all fascinating about Alice, but the fact that it was so difficult to find out only whetted Rosa’s appetite for details. When Alice didn’t offer anything, choosing instead to take another pull from the fast-dwindling joint, Rosa asked, “So what inspired you to sign up for camp in the first place? No offense, but you don’t seem to be enjoying any bit of this so far. While I’m really impressed that you followed through and actually came, it’s hard to imagine you choosing this experience for yourself unless you had a pretty specific reason.”

When Alice looked at her, wide-eyed—presumably at the prospect of having to give an answer consisting of multiple sentences—Rosa attempted some damage control. “Or maybe I should mind my own business. Sorry.”

Alice handed over the cold roach, which Rosa accepted mostly so it couldn’t be used as a further distraction. Then, sighing, Alice shook her head. “No, I’m sorry.” She took a deep breath and exhaled slowly. Managing only sporadic eye contact, she said, “This was my therapist’s idea. I’ve been seeing her about a year now, and recently she’s decided to push me harder to challenge my social anxiety. She’s probably right. But I’m extraordinarily bad at this stuff. Like, beyond bad.” Sagging, Alice rested against the wide tree trunk and closed her eyes. “So bad that even though all I want is to meet someone this weekend, a friend, you know, or…” She shook her head. “I just want to meet someone and you’re really nice, but I still feel so awkward, even with you.”

Rosa couldn’t help but grin at the unexpected torrent of words from Alice’s beautiful lips. They were beautiful, she decided, around the same time she figured out that she was staring at Alice’s mouth. And that Alice was watching her do it. Rosa cleared her throat. “You’re not awkward.” Alice shot her a look that made it clear she wasn’t buying it. Rosa shrugged in concession, then amended, “Well, not inherently. You’re just…apprehensive. For whatever reason.”

“That I am.” Alice managed a genuinely friendly smile. “I appreciate you being so kind.”

“Same here.” Rosa returned the smile, warmed by the knowledge that a tentative friendship had indeed been formed. She couldn’t explain why meeting someone so gentle and unassuming meant so much to her right now, but Alice’s timid nature felt like a gift after too many fear-tinged, judgment-filled encounters with strangers whose motivations she couldn’t discern. “Want to walk back and check out the bonfire together?” When a look of dread passed across Alice’s face, she said, “Or we could…stay here awhile.”

Sheepish, Alice said, “Here works for me.”

“Yeah, me too.” A small, dark shape zipped past Rosa’s face, some type of nocturnal insect. She flinched and batted it away. The winged beast disappeared into the shadows enveloping them, gone in an instant. Then something buzzed near her ear, making her yelp. “Well, maybe not here.”

Alice politely hid her laughter behind her hand. “To be honest, my legs are feeling a little wobbly all of a sudden. Maybe we could find somewhere to sit down?”

“Yes!” Rosa leapt out from behind the tree, scurrying back to the relative safety of the path. “Want to check out the lake? We can leave if anyone else has beaten us there.”

Alice trailed behind. “Are we allowed to go down to the water at night?”

“Nobody said we couldn’t.” Feeling somewhat bolder now that they’d established a two-sided conversation, Rosa planted her hands on her hips so she could watch Alice’s approach. “And we’re adults, right? What’s the point of being a grown-up if not to do whatever we want?”

“I’ve always been more of a follow-the-rules, exercise-caution kind of grown-up.”

“I’m most likely here to corrupt you, then.” Rosa pretended to curtsey, silly from the joint they’d shared. “Sent by the universe is my guess.”

Alice giggled, then promptly stumbled over a tree branch in her path. Rosa moved forward quickly, reaching out to catch Alice’s wrist before she could fall. Her hand automatically slid down to entangle with Alice’s, like they’d done this hundreds of times before. Rosa held her breath, worried that she’d just blown it, that she’d scared Alice away.

But Alice didn’t run. Instead, she tightened her fingers on Rosa’s and, chest rising and falling rapidly, whispered, “You lead.”


 

Chapter Four

They were still holding hands when they reached the lake. Alice wondered whether she should let go—had been wondering from the moment their fingers linked together—but couldn’t bring herself to do it. Lila wasn’t letting go. Did that mean she liked what they were doing? Alice felt like a sixteen-year-old girl with a crush as she obsessed over every detail of what was happening, desperate to find the meaning in this improbable turn of events.

Perhaps Lila was simply happy to have found a fellow pot-smoker amidst a sea of drinkers. Perhaps tomorrow morning they’d wake up and her new friend would want nothing to do with her in the cold light of day. Or perhaps Lila really was as genuine as she seemed, and as sweet, focused as she was on making Alice feel better about being at camp. That last possibility almost seemed least likely of all, if only because Alice refused to believe that she’d managed to accomplish her one true wish so quickly and easily. That would mean Dawn had been right. She’d made a friend.

“Oh, look!” Lila pointed at three paddleboats tied to a long wooden dock that extended nearly twenty feet into the water. “Let’s go sit in one of those—and don’t worry. I won’t try to talk you into going for a moonlight cruise.” She squeezed Alice’s hand and tugged her forward. “We can save that for tomorrow night.” When Alice faltered, hesitant, Lila laughed. “Kidding. Come on. Let’s look out at the water while we talk.”

Alice felt drawn along by an invisible force, despite the mild tingle of anxiety still in her belly. The joint had softened the sharp edges of her nerves, allowing her a detached coolness that simply wasn’t possible most of the time. For that, she was eminently grateful. Despite her uncertainty over how this experience with Lila would ultimately play out, she’d accomplished more socially in the past fifteen minutes than she had during the previous year of therapy sessions. At this point she was committed to see where this experience led her. She would let the universe take its course.

The dock swayed gently as they stepped onto it, causing Lila to tighten her grip on Alice’s hand. Unperturbed by the need to adjust her center of gravity, Alice slipped from Lila’s grasp—a move that elicited a low noise of protest—to instead loop their arms together. “I’ve got you.”

Lila pressed closer to her side, cutting the slight chill of the night air. Alice felt her shiver. “Thanks.”

Surprised by the quaver in Lila’s voice, Alice asked, “Are you cold?”

“No.” They walked until they reached the farthest boat from shore, then stopped, still arm in arm. “For being so shy, you’re pretty damn smooth.” Lila stepped away, but not before giving Alice one last squeeze. “Here, let me get in first.”

With surprising grace, Lila climbed into the far seat before offering her hand so Alice could follow. Alice grabbed on without hesitation, already so comfortable in the other woman’s presence that she found it impossible to keep second-guessing Lila’s motives. She stepped into the boat carefully, pleased when she didn’t tumble onto her face. Though with Lila there to break her fall…

Alice shook her head, stunned by where her mind had chosen to wander. She’d found women attractive in the past, certainly. Since the divorce, she’d swapped a real sex life for a secret porn habit, with the girl-on-girl stuff her drug of choice. When she touched herself these days, women almost always played a starring role in her fantasies. Fear of disappointing her parents had kept her from considering such a possibility for herself when she was younger, but now that she was in her thirties, she frankly lacked the capacity to care what her aging parents thought about her romantic choices. She’d already disappointed them with the divorce, her social awkwardness, and her failure to produce grandchildren, among countless other minor failures. So why not follow her heart and explore whatever might actually make her happy?

“You okay?” Lila touched her hand. Now seated, she stared up at Alice with open curiosity.

Embarrassed by her thoughts, Alice nodded with a little too much vigor. “Just light-headed.”

Lila’s fingers caught hers and tugged. “Sit down, then. Relax.”

Relax. Alice nearly laughed out loud. That was impossible now that she’d pictured Lila lying beneath her…naked…moaning. She cleared her throat, unsettled by her increasingly dirty thoughts and the unchecked arousal that flooded her veins. At this point, she’d been celibate for nearly two years. That had to be the problem—that, and the fact that she was higher than she’d ever been before. Lowering herself into the boat’s seat, she moved with exaggerated care, afraid of revealing her lascivious thoughts through her body language.

Lila launched back into their conversation mid-stream, casual as ever, apparently oblivious to Alice’s out-of-control libido. “So, therapy, huh? I actually started going again last year. Same woman I used to see when I was in college. It’s nice to have someone objective to talk to about your shit.”

“It can be.” Unsure what to do with her hands now that she wasn’t touching Lila, Alice folded them in her lap. “My mother doesn’t believe in therapy. She thinks it’s shameful, even crude, to discuss your personal business with strangers.” She paused. “With anyone, actually.”

“That sounds healthy.” Lila’s voice was heavy with sarcasm yet tinged with concern. “I’m sorry.”

“As you can imagine, she’s one of the main topics of conversation during most of my sessions.” At the mercy of her upbringing, Alice cringed at the realization that here she was, unloading her personal business onto a complete stranger. What if this was inappropriate to discuss? “Anyway, I can’t imagine you want to hear me talk about my mother. That’s why I have a therapist, right? To spare everyone else.”

“I’m happy to talk about whatever you’re willing to share.” Lila reached across the center console of the boat and touched Alice’s arm, tentatively. “I want to get to know you. Overbearing mother and all.”

Alice stared at where Lila’s warm fingers rested on her skin. She wanted to ask, Why? Instead she said, “Careful. You can’t imagine how overbearing my mother actually is. I could spend the rest of the night counting the ways and boring you to death.”

Lila withdrew her hand, laced her fingers behind her head, and gazed up at the sky. “Go ahead.”

Relieved not to have to worry about maintaining eye contact, Alice joined Lila’s study of the stars. “How about I give you the short version?”

“All right.”

She experienced a moment of worry before speaking, driven by the familiar fear of appearing stupid. Confront your fears, she coached herself, focusing on a cluster of stars while imagining her therapist Dawn was seated beside her. “My Irish mother got pregnant by her secret Chinese boyfriend—my father—when she was eighteen years old. Her parents kicked her out of the house, and despite the fact that my father’s mother despised her and blamed her for ruining her son’s life, they got married and moved into his parents’ home. We lived there until I was five, when we moved three houses down the street. My mother embraced the Tiger Mom stereotype wholeheartedly, no doubt because my grandmother constantly judged and criticized her every move. So she put enormous pressure on me to be perfect in everything I did. School, the cello, debate team. I was a reflection of not only her, but of her relationship with my father. If I was anything less than perfect, Grandmother won.” Alice stopped talking, feeling as though she’d been speaking forever. “That wasn’t very short, was it? My apologies. Apparently that’s what a year of therapy gets you.”

“No apology necessary.” Lila straightened, half turning to stare at Alice’s face. “That sounds like a rough childhood.”

“Oh, I don’t know.” Alice hated to claim any kind of disadvantage, particularly without knowing anything about Lila’s background. “I had a roof over my head, food on the table, two parents at home, an extended family, a gorgeous cello to play for hours every day.” She forced a smile, careful not to sound ignorant about her level of privilege. “Millions of people have rougher childhoods, believe me.”

“Very true, but that doesn’t make growing up under the expectation of unflinching perfection any less arduous.” Lila’s hand found hers again, the palm cradling her knuckles. “Don’t diminish your experience just because you don’t have the most tragic sob story I’ve ever heard, all right? My mom was always my best friend. I can’t imagine growing up any other way. To me, not having that seems rough.”

Alice shrugged. “Point taken. And it was rough—mostly in that I withdrew socially, too busy chasing my mother’s ideals to make any real friends. Or to learn how not to be a total dork.”

Lila stroked her thumb over the side of Alice’s hand. “Stop that. No more.”

“No negative self-talk, as my therapist says.” Alice nodded, watching the motion of Lila’s thumb. “Right. I’m done.”

“Good.” Lila ducked her head to catch Alice’s attention. “Is your mother still around?”

“Yes. My father, too.” Suddenly self-conscious, Alice looked away. “She was brutally disappointed in me when my husband filed for divorce last year. Things have been strained since, to say the least.”

“What would she think of Camp Rewind?”

Laughing, Alice glanced over her shoulder at the shore, then grinned at Lila. “Considering that I never went to camp as a kid, I’m guessing she wouldn’t be impressed. Luckily, the other benefit of a year in therapy is that I’ve largely stopped caring what she thinks. Honestly. I’ll never make her happy, so I’m no longer trying.” Still loopy from the pot, Alice let herself be swept away by her passionate rejection of her mother’s judgment. “Now I’m trying to make me happy.”

“Good for you.” Lila sounded wholly sincere, and the praise warmed Alice in ways she could never have anticipated. “Seriously, you need to give yourself a lot of credit. It takes courage to reject a lifelong authority figure and do your own thing. And it definitely took courage to come here.”

“I don’t know.” Reluctant to accept the compliment, Alice tried to change the subject. “So what about you? Why are you here?”

Lila’s smile seemed to freeze almost imperceptibly. It was the sort of thing that Alice noticed when no one else did. She’d hit a nerve, though she couldn’t imagine what. Afraid she’d somehow ruined the easy air between them, she opened her mouth to apologize, but Lila recovered her composure before she could get a word out.

“I just…needed to get away for a few days.” Lila’s eyes glistened, making Alice’s heart beat faster in sympathy. “Recapture a simpler time, maybe. I don’t know. I thought it seemed like a good idea, and so far I’d say I was right.” She glanced away, then lowered her hand over the side of the boat to test the water. “The lake is still pretty warm.”

“I’m not surprised. Temperatures have been unseasonably hot.” Alice hesitated, not wanting to trigger any more negative memories in her quest to get to know Lila better. Still, she felt the need to address the tension she’d introduced. “I’m sorry if it felt like I was prying. That wasn’t my intention.”

Lila gave her a smile that reflected a complex mixture of emotions. “You didn’t. Shit.” She shook her head, tugging on the ends of her bobbed haircut with what seemed like frustration. “Here you just shared your entire life story—”

“Not the entire story.” Alice kept her voice mild, all of a sudden worried she was about to chase her only friend away. “I haven’t even started talking about my ex-husband yet.”

Lila giggled, then fished around before producing the roach she’d passed off earlier. “I’m willing to bet we can get another hit out of this thing. Two, if we’re lucky. If you want to talk exes, we probably ought to try.”

Alice fumbled in her pocket until she found the lighter. “I’m in.”

They erupted into uncontrolled giggles when, during a coordinated lighting of the joint, Lila nearly singed the tip of her nose on the flame Alice held in unsteady hands. The shared laughter felt so good that Alice quickly found herself near tears. She flashed back to the brochure she’d seen in Dawn’s office, specifically the way the photo of the two women in the paddleboat had made her feel. After not believing she could ever have a moment like that for herself, here she was only weeks later, having it. Here they were.

Lila continued to chuckle as she confiscated the lighter. “Here, let me.” She carefully lit the tiny roach, then said, “Want to shotgun this hit?”

Rather than admit she wasn’t sure what that meant, Alice said, “Okay.”

Lila took a long drag, then leaned across the boat’s console to curl her hand around the back of Alice’s neck. She pressed her open mouth against Alice’s, so gently it made Alice’s heart race and her body tremble. Startled by the intimate contact, Alice parted her lips on instinct, despite having no idea what to do. Lila passed the hit to her by exhaling into her mouth, lingering close for long moments after she ran out of smoke. The tip of Alice’s tongue poked out automatically and bumped against Lila’s top lip, almost as though she were actually bold enough to initiate a real kiss. Panic swept through Alice at the same moment her lungs finally registered the acrid heat of the hit and instantaneously threatened to explode. She jerked away and turned her head to the side, coughing heartily as she tried to recover from everything about the experience Lila had just introduced. A warm hand landed on her back and rubbed soft circles through her T-shirt.

“Easy,” Lila murmured. “That was a big one.”

It sure was. Alice rested her arms on her thighs and hung her head low as the euphoria of the plant swept over her, grateful for the excuse not to look Lila in the eye. Had Lila felt her tongue? Did she think that had been her attempt at a seduction? If so, was she disgusted? Horrified? Interested? Breathing deeply, Alice picked her head up to look out at the reflection of the moon on the water. She had no idea what to say or do next, yet she couldn’t help but notice what a beautiful night it was. A night she would no doubt remember for the rest of her life.

Lila’s hand ceased its rubbing motion but remained pressed between her shoulder blades. “I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to embarrass you.”

Alice shook her head, still not sure how to recover their rapport. Finally, desperate to say something, anything to break the awkwardness of the moment, she observed, “We seem to be apologizing to each other a lot.”

“Well, I think it’s necessary this time. I never wanted to make you uncomfortable.”

Alice shrugged and shook her head again. “You didn’t.” She didn’t expand beyond that. Honestly, she couldn’t. “I just didn’t want to cough into your mouth.”

“I appreciate that.” Lila’s hand left her back, the spot it had been covering cold with its absence. “That’s an old college trick. I was a little wild back in those days.”

“I would guess we had pretty different college experiences.” Alice chanced a sidelong glance at Lila, relieved yet strangely disappointed to find her once again studying the night sky. “I only started smoking cannabis after the divorce…occasionally, for anxiety. It seems to help.”

“I’m glad.” Lila shifted her gaze to Alice and met her eyes. “You said your husband was the one who filed. It wasn’t a mutual decision?”

“Mutual between him and his girlfriend, perhaps. They didn’t consult me.”

“Ouch.” Lila grimaced, then offered her a half-smile. “His loss, right?”

The cliché rolled over her without connecting. “I doubt he thinks so, but I appreciate the sentiment.”

“Have you started dating again?”

Was it her imagination, or did Lila’s question hold a note of restrained hope? As difficult as that was to fathom, the evening had already yielded one impossibility after the next. “One date so far, which was a total disaster. I could barely even speak to the guy.”

“Why?”

“He was this overly attractive, well-muscled firefighter with a movie-star grin. I froze. Sometimes I think it’s my fear of freezing—and by extension looking foolish—that actually makes the social paralysis happen. A self-fulfilling prophecy, I suppose. It’s always been like that when I try to interact with people, ever since I was a kid.” She could no longer hold eye contact when Lila smiled in a way that lit up her entire face, reminding Alice that she was every bit as attractive as her Internet paramour had been. More, even. “Dating…is possibly not for me.”

“I hate to repeat myself, but again, give yourself some credit. You’re doing really well right now, with me.” Lila tapped her arm, rewarding her with a kind expression once Alice gathered the courage to look up into her eyes. “Or am I not overly attractive enough to make you really shut down?”

Not for the first time, Alice detected something in Lila’s voice that hinted at genuine sexual interest, which wasn’t impossible, right? It wasn’t like she was some hideous monster from the deep. John had been into her, once upon a time. A strange calm came over Alice, no doubt helped along by her unprecedented high. If she made a fool of herself tonight, she could always leave first thing tomorrow morning. Right? Even if that did happen, she’d already achieved more than she’d ever dreamed by coming to Camp Rewind. This entire experience had been so surreal, so wonderful, that Alice felt moved to trust her instincts and lower her inhibitions ever so slightly.

“I think you’re plenty attractive. Extremely attractive would be the more accurate way to put it.” Alice cringed at the sound of her own voice, yet the words kept tumbling out. “You’re exactly the right amount of attractive, I think, so…no, not overly. Which is a good thing.” Her cheeks warmed, yet she managed not to hide her face, allowing her to witness the obvious pleasure her words elicited. “Maybe I find women less intimidating?”

“You and me both. There’s a lot to like about men, but it’s easier with other women, isn’t it?” Lila moved closer, and for a crazy moment, Alice thought she might actually initiate a full-out kiss. Unsure whether she was ready to take that step, while simultaneously desperate for something to happen, Alice felt only marginal relief when Lila gestured at the narrow slice of water visible between her side of the boat and the dock. “Any way I might talk you into a quick swim? The water really does feel nice, if you want to test it with your hand.”

Alice’s head spun at the sudden change in topic. “Um…”

“You don’t have to if you don’t want. It’s okay, really.” Lila pulled back and peered down over the side of the boat, then out at the open expanse of water in the lake beyond. “I just…wouldn’t mind cooling off a little.”

Alice tried to decide whether she’d done something wrong, but she didn’t think that was the problem. Was Lila nervous, too? Or embarrassed? Had Alice not been clear enough about her interest? Or had she misinterpreted Lila’s intentions from the start? Stop. STOP. The stern admonishment in her head sounded like Dawn, yet it resonated with a righteous dose of her own self-directed anger. Stop overanalyzing. Go with it. It’s the only way to change.

Lowering her fingers into the water yielded the pleasant surprise that the lake was even warmer than the night air. Alice craned her neck to survey the shore, half-expecting to find that other campers had discovered their hiding spot, but it appeared they were alone. Still, she hesitated. “Won’t we be cold after we get out?”

Lila beamed as though Alice had already jumped in headfirst. Before Alice could turn away, she pulled her T-shirt over her head and tossed it onto the dock. Left in what appeared to be a black satin bra, she seemed only mildly bashful as she stood up in the boat and began to unbutton her linen shorts. “I wasn’t planning to get my clothes wet.”

Alice opened her mouth, but no sound came out. She couldn’t tear her eyes away from Lila’s belly button or stop herself from imagining what it might be like to put her lips against it, or below it. She watched Lila’s hands ease the shorts down over her hips, drawing her attention lower, to black panties with a cut that perfectly emphasized the shapely bottom they concealed. Throwing her shorts onto the dock atop her shirt, Lila turned away from Alice, leaving her little choice but to admire the round butt that was suddenly right in front of her face.

Alice tried not to stare, but there was nowhere else to look. Desperate to speak as if to somehow prove that Lila hadn’t rendered her completely tongue-tied, she managed to say, “Yeah, I’m not sure I’m ready to take my clothes off in front of you yet. No matter how well I seem to be doing tonight.”

Lila looked down over her shoulder, smirking as Alice finally forced her eyes upward. “Like I said, that’s totally fine, and I understand.” Her gaze slid down Alice’s body, a brief assessment. “For the record, though, there’s no reason to be self-conscious. I think you’re very attractive, too, and nothing about seeing you in your bra and panties could possibly make me like you any less.” She cleared her throat and turned back to the lake. “I’m going in. Wish me luck.”

Alice started to do exactly that, but Lila launched herself over the side of the boat and into the water before she could utter a single syllable. Crawling over the center console, she scanned the dark water as she waited for Lila to surface. At first she worried that Lila would attempt the classic gag of frightening her by not coming up—which she would have hated—but instead, a dark head and shoulders popped up out of the water about five feet away, and Lila graced Alice with a clearly exhilarated grin.

“It feels amazing!” Lila lay back, arms spread, legs extended, and allowed her body to float on the surface. “So refreshing. We should definitely go swimming when it gets hot tomorrow afternoon. It’ll feel divine.”

Of course, they’d naturally have to share the lake with their fellow campers during the hottest part of the day. Alice had packed a modest, one-piece bathing suit—and oh, how she wished she’d thought to wear it under her clothes today—but in a crowd, that would feel even more revealing than her cotton bra and panties did now. If she wanted a semi-private swim at camp, she would probably have to do it at night. Maybe even tonight. Alice grabbed the hem of her T-shirt in both hands and took a deep breath as she contemplated pulling it over her head.

“Would you prefer I turn around?” There was a splash, and when Alice checked the source, she saw Lila bobbing in the water, facing away. “I promise not to look.”

Silently cursing Lila’s keen sense of observation, Alice closed her eyes and tried to decide what she wanted to do. Anxiety aside, fears forgotten, did she want to swim mostly naked with Lila? The answer was yes. Yes, of course she did. Of course. Because that was the kind of thing the woman she wished to be would do, and because this real-life fantasy might get even better if she mustered enough courage to be bold. Go with it, she reminded herself.

Feeling as though someone else was controlling her hands, she tugged her T-shirt over her head and launched it a little too carelessly toward Lila’s pile of discarded clothing. Unfortunately, it fell well short of its goal, sliding off the deck and into the water before she could react. “Shit!” Alice fished her shirt out of the lake, feeling both stupid and alarmed by the idea that she had nothing dry to wear back to their sleeping cabin. “Damn it.” She squeezed the excess water out of her shirt, then clumsily spread the sodden garment across the dock’s surface to let it dry as much as possible without the benefit of sunlight. “Stupid.”

“Hey, it’s okay.” Lila swam up to the boat, waving a hand to get Alice’s attention and snap her out of her angry self-recrimination. “You can borrow my shirt. I don’t mind, really.”

Alice blushed, then folded her arms over her chest when she remembered that she’d stripped down to her bra. “You don’t have to do that. It was my mistake.”

“I told you, I don’t mind. Swimming was my idea in the first place. And plus, that’s what friends do.” Lila pushed away from the boat to tread water. She smiled, carefully. “Still want to come in? Or are you afraid to risk your jeans?”

Alice managed to chuckle and then, seconds later, to lower her arms from their protective stance in front of her bra. “I’m still coming. Just a little less cavalierly, at least when it comes to casting off my inhibitions.”

Lila laughed, not unkindly. “Is it a fair guess you’ve never said that before?”

“Extremely fair.” Aware that Lila was still watching, apparently having forgotten her promise not to, Alice overcame the last vestiges of her modesty and stood. Lila’s gaze traveled down her body, settling on her hands as she fumbled to undo the button at her waist. She remembered how entranced she’d felt watching Lila do the same thing and marveled at the possibility that her attraction was truly reciprocated.

Lila jerked suddenly and swiveled in place to give Alice privacy. “I’m so sorry. I kind of…spaced out for a minute.”

Once she’d managed to thumb the button open, Alice pulled down her jeans before painstakingly placing them, folded, onto a dry patch of dock. “No more apologies. For the rest of the night, at least. Deal?”

Lila nodded without turning around. “You’re on.”

Though she normally liked to acclimate herself to water slowly—excruciatingly so, according to her ex-husband—the urgency to ensure that her scantily clad body would be submerged before Lila turned around compelled Alice to immediately leap over the side of the boat and into the lake in a less-than-graceful half-dive, half-belly flop. She kicked her feet and rose to the surface upon entry, glad that Lila hadn’t witnessed the ridiculous display. After smoothing wet hair away from her face, she cleared her throat and said, “I’m in.”

Lila wore a grin when she turned around. “Doesn’t it feel incredible?”

Alice had to admit, it did feel nice. Every bit of it. She smiled, then kicked her legs to spin in place like a little kid. “Yes.” After a few rotations, Alice stopped abruptly at the sight of Lila swimming closer. Her chest expanded, part pleasure, part pain. All good. Past the point of self-censoring, she said, “Thank you for talking me into this. No matter what else happens, this will always be a night to remember.”

Lila’s grin melted into something softer, more melancholy. Her eyes shone brightly under the moonlight, full to the brim with emotion too complex for Alice to interpret. Worried that she’d embarrassed herself with the confession, Alice shook her head to clear it. She felt like she was in a dream state, like she was inhabiting someone else’s life. She was probably making a complete fool of herself. Was Lila nearly as caught up in this experience as she was?

As if to answer her question, Lila swam closer. Close enough to touch. Alice kept her hands far below the surface of the water, fisted at her sides, so she wouldn’t get herself into trouble like she had earlier, when her tongue had gone rogue during that shotgunned hit. She studied Lila’s face, tingling with the anticipation of what might happen next.

Lila’s hand brushed against her hip, making her jump. “Sorr—” Lila stopped, perhaps remembering their pact. “I was going to say that I’ll always remember tonight, too.” As she studied the surface of the water, Alice got the impression she was actively struggling not to swim away.

She’s embarrassed, too. At this point, their entire interaction felt so mind-blowingly reciprocal that Alice stopped trying to convince herself that her attraction wasn’t returned. It had to be. Why else would Lila be so nervous? The question triggered an automatic litany of paranoid thoughts, each more frightening and far-fetched than the last. Alice looked around, peering into the darkness to make sure they were truly alone, that this wasn’t just some massive practical joke.

“I was going to hold your hand,” Lila blurted out. When Alice met her eyes, she lifted a shoulder and grabbed the back of her neck in one hand, visibly squeezing. “When I touched you just now. I don’t want you to think I was trying to grope you or anything like that.”

No, Lila’s anxiety was 100 percent genuine—and 100 percent unnecessary. “I wasn’t offended,” Alice explained. “Just startled. Really.”

“Okay.” Lila exhaled, then forced a fairly unconvincing chuckle. “I have no idea what I’m doing either, as you can tell. Socially.”

Alice continued to tread water as she tried to read Lila’s face. Did friends usually hold hands? Or had that been Lila’s attempt to signal that she was interested in venturing beyond mere platonic friendship? Though Alice had daydreamed about what it might be like to have a casual fling at Camp Rewind, she’d never believed she’d actually get the opportunity. Especially not with a woman. But maybe, inexplicably, this was her chance. Clearing her throat, Alice tried not to sound as excited as she felt. “You’re fine. And if you want to hold my hand…” Slowly, once again detached from her actions, Alice raised her outstretched fingers to skim across the surface of the water, toward Lila. “I’m okay with that.”

“Just okay?” Lila seemed to hold her breath as she awaited the answer.

“Completely okay.” Alice managed not to react when Lila’s fingers carefully entwined with hers. Their bodies drifted closer together, as though compelled by an invisible current. Alice’s leg brushed against Lila’s, their hips touched, and then suddenly Alice watched her arms loop around Lila’s neck—for balance, she thought, preparing an excuse even as she committed the transgression—as they fell into a natural embrace. Frightened by her own lack of timidity, Alice attempted to pull away, but Lila tightened the arms she’d already wrapped around Alice’s waist.

“Don’t leave,” Lila whispered. She rested her chin on Alice’s shoulder and placed a hand in the center of her back, holding her so they didn’t have to meet each other’s eyes. “Please, unless you don’t like it.”

Alice more than liked it. Surrendering to the comfort, she closed her eyes and rested her head against Lila’s, enjoying the warmth of another human’s skin, the thrum of a second heartbeat echoing through her chest. She hadn’t been hugged in years, certainly not by her parents, not since the last time John had bothered to offer her an emotionless squeeze. Being touched felt so good she never wanted it to end. She raised her hands to Lila’s back, tracing her fingers over the soft skin, relishing the quiet sigh of contentment she was able to draw out with a simple caress.

They stayed that way for five minutes, perhaps, until Lila began to shiver in her arms. When Alice tried to release her, Lila shook her head and clung tighter. “Wait.”

“All right.” Alice dropped a hand to rest against Lila’s lower back, keeping her close. “But you’re cold.”

“Getting there,” Lila admitted. She kissed Alice’s neck, a warm, soft press of her lips, before disentangling herself sheepishly. “So…wow. I know we’re not supposed to apologize to each other anymore, but—”

Full of unfamiliar confidence, Alice shook her head. “Don’t. We both needed that, obviously. There’s no reason to be embarrassed, right? Either one of us.”

For the first time, she noticed a shallow dimple in Lila’s left cheek. “You’re absolutely correct.”

“Anyway, that’s what friends do.” Not that Alice had the first clue what friends actually did. It sounded good, though. “Right?”

“Totally.” Lila shivered again and nodded toward the dock. “Should we get out?”

Alice emerged from the water before remembering her wet shirt and Lila’s offer to let her borrow the dry one. Indeed, despite the fact that her teeth chattered audibly, Lila didn’t hesitate to pick up the cold, damp T-shirt. Alice hastily snatched it away. “Thanks, but I’ll wear that.”

Lila surprised her by swiping it back. “No. I know you’re self-conscious, and it’s very possible we’ll run into other people on the way to our bunks. I meant it when I said I’d wear it for you. Please, let me.” Her hands trembled as she pulled the shirt over her head. “Consider it payment for the awesome hug.”

Not wanting to start an argument no matter how well-intentioned, Alice nodded. “Thanks.” She knelt to gather her jeans and Lila’s dry shirt, which smelled so good it made Alice dizzy. Dressing as fast as she could, she waited for Lila to button her shorts before extending her arm in invitation. “At least let me help keep you warm?”

With a fairly violent shiver, Lila stripped off the wet shirt. “You know what? I’d rather walk back in my bra. I can carry the damn shirt.” When Alice opened her mouth to protest again, her guilt renewed, Lila moved close to her side and cuddled up tight. “I’ll happily accept your offer of warmth, though.”

Alice curled her hand around a cold, bare shoulder instinctually. The obvious goose bumps beneath her fingers prompted her to tighten the embrace and made her wish she could somehow transfer the heat from her body to Lila’s through sheer will alone. Though she’d met the woman less than two hours ago, she already wanted nothing more than to make her happy. As inexplicably happy as Lila had already made her.

They walked to the end of the dock before Lila broke the silence that had risen between them. “That was fun.”

Alice smiled at the dark, slightly uneven ground. “It really was.”

Lila’s cold arm slid behind her back, making the embrace mutual. “And I really haven’t made you uncomfortable?”

“Not at all.” Alice was glad she didn’t have to look Lila in the eyes right then, because she didn’t trust herself not to somehow reveal exactly how much she’d enjoyed everything they’d just done—and what they were still doing now. She caressed Lila’s upper arm with her thumb, betraying at least a little of her true feelings. “Sadly, I’m already more comfortable with you than nearly everyone else I know. Except my therapist.”

“That is sad, but only because I don’t like thinking of you feeling that alone.” Lila hugged her around the waist. “On the other hand, hearing you say you feel comfortable with me pretty much wins the goddamn night.”

“It’ll make sitting together at breakfast less awkward, as well.”

Lila’s laughter made Alice feel all-powerful, like a bigger and better version of herself. So did the smile Lila directed her way, and the sparkle in what appeared to be a gaze full of affection. “Glad to hear we’re still on for that.”

“Are you kidding? Of course we are.” The combined effect of the cool air, Lila’s chilly, still-shivering body pressed tightly against her side, and her own excitement sent a noticeable tremor through Alice, which prompted Lila to draw her nearer. Alice went willingly. “You’re stuck with me now.”

“Good.” As they drew closer to the dwindling bonfire, Lila lowered her voice. “You cold, too? We could go warm ourselves by the fire, if you want.”

Alice shook her head. Tonight had been more magical than she could have ever dreamed. No need to ruin it by involving other people. “I think I’ll turn in for the night. You go ahead, if you’d like.”

“Nah.” Lila steered them toward the women’s cabin without missing a step. “I’m stuck with you, remember?”

“Yes, but I know you’re cold.”

Lila released her to climb the cabin steps, leaving Alice bereft in her absence. “True, but I’ve got dry pajamas inside. Come on.”

Alice followed Lila into the canvas-covered structure, blinking rapidly as she tried to adjust to the sudden darkness. Despite two large, screened-in windows on either side of the room, the path between the double rows of bunk beds was only dimly illuminated and wholly perilous to navigate. After stumbling over an object she couldn’t identify, Alice whispered, “I can’t see anything.”

Lila’s hand touched her arm, easing anxiety that had only just begun to stir. “Close your eyes and then massage them gently with your fingers for about ten seconds. Supposedly it helps to reset your low-light vision.”

Alice gave it a try. When she reopened her eyes, she had no trouble discerning Lila’s pretty face only a few tantalizing inches from her own. Something came over her or, more accurately, swept through her. A moment of impossible courage, no doubt inspired by a lifetime of vicarious romantic thrills delivered by Hollywood movies. Unable to detect even a hint of rejection in Lila’s expression, Alice moved forward and pressed their lips together in a nearly chaste, somewhat clumsy kiss. Lila gasped audibly the instant their mouths touched, then shot out her hands and gripped Alice’s elbows to prevent her from backing away.

As soon as she understood that the kiss was welcome, that she’d only surprised Lila, Alice shut off her brain and let her body take over. Lila’s tongue poked out, licking her upper lip, so Alice opened up to let her inside. She moaned at the improbable softness of another woman, so different than anything she’d felt before. Her hands moved on their own, at first resting on Lila’s shoulders, then tangling in her hair. Stirred by the incredible passion of this single, first kiss—a kiss more arousing than anything she and her ex-husband had ever done—Alice brought her own tongue into play, sliding against Lila’s in a dance that left her so hot, so instantly slick, that she couldn’t help but blush and pull away.

“Please don’t say you’re sorry,” Lila whispered before Alice could catch her breath. “Please.”

“That was the deal, right?” Alice amazed herself by speaking, and coherently at that. But her knees wobbled, threatening to send her to the floor. “I think I need to sit down.”

Lila threaded their fingers together, the new familiarity of the gesture making it no less thrilling this time around. “Which bed is yours?”

Alice had only a fuzzy memory of depositing her suitcase on the last available bunk—a top one, naturally—en route to join the opening ceremony-in-progress. “Um…”

Lila pulled her along to the far corner of the room. “No worries, you can use mine. Over here.”

Alice’s legs melted away when she reached Lila’s unmade bed. She sank onto the edge, watching in silence as Lila unzipped a large duffel bag and dug around inside. Though she knew she should probably find her suitcase if only to change out of her wet bra and panties, she didn’t yet trust her legs to carry her. Eager to fill the oppressive silence, she murmured, “It’s a top bunk, unfortunately. It was the only one that hadn’t been taken…I left my suitcase on the mattress.”

Lila turned to the side, partially shielding her body from view as she unhooked and discarded her wet bra. “I’ll look as soon as I get my pajamas on.” Alice tried not to stare at the silhouette of a full, bare breast as Lila rolled a dry tank top on over her head. She adjusted the hem so it hung low over her hips, then swiftly unbuttoned and discarded both her shorts and wet panties in a single, fluid motion, revealing a brief, alluring flash of one plump buttock as she shimmied on a fresh pair of boxer shorts. “Please excuse the half moon.”

It took a moment for Alice to understand the playful nature of the comment, but as soon as Lila’s meaning registered, any embarrassment she might have felt about sneaking a peek dissolved, along with her, into giggles. “I didn’t mean to look.”

“It was hard to miss.” She could see Lila’s flirtatious wink even in the low light, yet somehow managed not to look away. “Anyway, I’m taking it as a compliment.”

“Good.” In a quieter voice, she added, “You should.”

Lila bent to kiss the top of her head, then straightened. “What color is your suitcase?”

“Blue.” Alice surveyed the room, growing sheepish as a thought occurred. “It might actually be—”

“Right here?” Smiling, Lila hefted the suitcase down from its place on the bunk directly over Alice’s head. “Nice choice.”

“I guess so.” Alice shivered violently, no longer able to fight off the chill in the air. She sank onto her knees beside her suitcase and unzipped it with shaking hands, searching for an embarrassingly long time before coming up with the long pajama pants and T-shirt she’d brought to sleep in. Glancing over her shoulder, she found Lila with her back already turned. “Thanks.”

“Not a problem.” Lila shook out a light bedsheet she’d taken from her bag, laying it over the thin mattress as Alice performed the quickest wardrobe change of her life. “I wish I’d realized how chilly it would be at night…or anticipated that I’d do something silly like decide to swim right before bed.” She unfolded a second sheet and arranged it on top of the first. “I’d have brought an actual blanket.”

Alice hung her wet T-shirt and bra from the corner of the top bunk, then returned to her bag for the quilted nylon blanket she’d packed alongside every other possible supply she’d thought she might need. “Borrow mine.” She tossed the drawstring travel bag onto Lila’s bunk. “It’s my fault you had to walk back pretty much topless.”

“Maybe so, but you’re cold, too.” Lila sank onto her bed and lobbed the blanket back to Alice. “I should have packed smarter.”

Exhaustion crept into Alice’s bones, sapping her of the energy to argue. Still, she had to try to make amends somehow. She was the reason Lila was suffering. “I’m not sure I’ll be able to sleep if I know you’re freezing right below me…”

Lila crawled between her sheets and rested her head on the pillow with a quiet, contented sigh. Then she rolled onto her side. “So let’s share the blanket. Come on. Get in here next to me before you pass out.”

Too tired to argue and not at all eager to attempt a nighttime ascent to the top bunk, Alice found it almost easy to accept Lila’s invitation. She withdrew the thermal blanket from its bag, spread it over Lila’s body with an air of tenderness she had no idea she possessed, and crawled beneath to stretch out on her side. Perched at the very edge of the mattress, she worried that the bed wasn’t big enough for two adults to sleep comfortably until the moment Lila wrapped an arm around her stomach and dragged her backward into a cozy embrace.

Alice relaxed, muscle by muscle, until she no longer had any sense of where Lila ended and she began. A heart beat against her back, mimicking her own. Quiet, even breaths stirred the tiny hairs on her neck, a reminder that tonight, at least, she wasn’t alone. Alice relished the heat of Lila’s body behind hers, the security she provided. Truly at peace, she gave the arm around her waist a tender caress and then closed her eyes. Within moments, Alice fell into the soundest sleep she’d enjoyed in years.